Citrus Tissue Culture Club Set To Grow

Duarte Nursery in California has produced roughly 900,000 citrus trees on tissue culture rootstocks with few problems reported by growers. Photo courtesy of AgroMillora Research, SL
Duarte Nursery in California has produced roughly 900,000 citrus trees on tissue culture rootstocks with few problems reported by growers. Photo courtesy of AgroMillora Research, SL

The July 2013 installment of “Citrus Nursery Source” highlighted the likely methods of propagation for new promising rootstocks in light of disease challenges and the need to produce a large number of trees in a short period of time. Since that article, discussion has ensued among nurseries and growers about the pros and cons of rootstock production via tissue culture (TC). Rumors abound about inconsistent vigor, poor root health, susceptibility to windstorms, etc., though little research has been done in this area. In an effort to substantiate or dispel these concerns, we reached out to folks with expertise and experience in this field.

Letters From Spain
Dr. Francisco Llatser (AVASA) confirms that though TC has been used extensively in Spain (for approximately a decade), TC production of rootstocks was only recently authorized for use on rootstocks that do not produce enough seed. This was initially done to accommodate Dr. Juan Forner’s citrus tristeza virus-tolerant FA 5 rootstock.
Dr. Mireia Bordas (Agromillora Research, S.L.), who operates in several production areas, including the U.S., has produced 260 million trees by micropropagation over 27 years, including plants of 400 species and varieties. Dr. Bordas offered, “Similar issues regarding tree vigor, quality of roots, and susceptibility to wind were raised at the beginning of the development of the TC technology in other fruit trees. After 30 years of experience and a large number of plants micropropagated and planted in fields, all of these concerns have been addressed. In fact, uniformity and consistency in field performance are among the main advantages of TC plants. In citrus sps., micropropagation guarantees the genetic identity, avoiding tetraploids or zygotic embryos that could escape selection in the nursery.”

California Cues
Duarte Nursery has produced about 900,000 citrus trees on TC rootstocks with few problems reported by growers. Their experience and observations indicate no difference in tree vigor or root health. There was at least one grower with J-roots but this has been an issue related to transplantation into larger pots and it would be inappropriately identified as an issue related to TC production. Duarte also reports equal vigor on the nursery bench between trees produced from seed and those from TC. Though they are not aware of any TC citrus trees being challenged with severe winds, nut varieties produced from TC have performed well through high spring winds.
Dr. Graham Barry offered a key point for consideration. “If the nursery trees are of similar stem diameter at the time of planting, then there will be relatively little difference in tree performance. However, one of the goals of using TC instead of seedlings is to speed up the process of tree propagations and, as a result, its conceivable that tissue cultured trees would be smaller at the time of planting.”
It is critical to make a fair comparison of TC trees vs. seedlings. When this issue was discussed with Florida growers, one grower suggested he might consider low cost structures to house TC trees for growth prior to planting in the field. This would assure better survival in the field and still maintain production at the nursery level.

Applicable Florida Observations
In his early work at the Citrus Research and Education Center (CREC), Dr. Bill Castle, UF/IFAS, compared growth of seedlings vs. cuttings. These observations have taken on renewed importance as trees from rooted cuttings and TC behave very similarly. He observed no difference in tree performance, root health, or wind anchorage. This remained true throughout the trial. Furthermore, Dr. Castle emphasized that in the Flatwoods, the tap-root — usually present on seedling rootstocks — serves no real purpose because of the shallow soil. Even distribution of roots remains the key.

Managing The Fundamentals
Though the foundations of TC production are in science, there are a number of other factors that seem to influence results. Several labs could use the same mother stock, but the resulting plantlets may vary in quality and performance. Following a prescribed laboratory protocol is important, understanding it is another. Tony Fortier of Phoenix Agrotech identifies the following fundamental management issues in production of TC plants:

  • Source and quality of mother-stock (the most important)
  • How long the plant material is run through the lab
  • Level and types of plant growth regulators at each stage (speed does not always translate to field performance)
  • Type of nitrogen source and quantity and overall media composition
  • Ability to identify the right type of cells and callus to work with once initiated in the lab (microscopy)

Phillip Rucks of Phillip Rucks Citrus Nursery emphasizes similar factors as his TC lab places great emphasis on the custom composition of media and the establishment of specific protocols for each variety. This involves keen knowledge of the process and product as well as the investment of time in the process. This is not a one-size-fits-all business.
Based on input from those knowledgeable in the science and art of TC plant production, nurseries and growers can have confidence in the science of TC production. Like conventional propagations, performance may vary depending on the management of the process. Labs that have the expertise and experience will develop trees with similar vigor and performance of standard trees. Nursery practices after receipt of TC liners from the lab also will vary and have some bearing on the final product. One thing is certain, this process provides hope of acreage replacement on a large scale and is another important tool in the box.

In addition to those mentioned in the article, the author also would like to thank Dr. Javier Castillon (Duarte Nursery) and Dr. Fred Gmitter (UF/IFAS, CREC) for their insights.

Topics: , , ,

Leave a Reply

Citrus Stories
Young citrus trees wrapped in The Tree Defender product
Insect & Disease Update
June 27, 2016
Tree Cover Product Created To Help Fight Citrus Scourges
Unique protection for young citrus trees could help cut pest-control costs up to 50% in the first two years. Read More
photo illustration showing confusion
Citrus
June 24, 2016
Is It EPA’s Intention To Help Or Harm Farmers? [Opinion]
A common theme I see in complaints about the government agency is it appears to be taking action more and more based on ideology and public opinion rather than sound science. Read More
produce family shopping grocery
Citrus
June 23, 2016
Survey: Consumers Hungry For More Info On GMOs
University of Florida researchers find learning opportunity among poll results regarding genetically modified foods. Read More
2015 FFVA Annual Convention crowd
Citrus
June 23, 2016
Florida Fruit & Vegetable Association Convention To Cover Critical Issues
Mike Allen, a Founder of Politico and its Chief White House Correspondent, slated as keynote speaker for association's 73rd annual gathering. Read More
UAV in flight
Citrus
June 22, 2016
Heads Up: FAA Finalizes Rules For Small Drones
Regulations will create new opportunities for business and government entities to use unmanned aircraft systems weighing less than 55 pounds. Read More
overflowing beaker in science lab
Citrus
June 21, 2016
Sound Science Struggling To Win Over Skeptics [Opinion]
We all want the truth. But can we handle it? Read More
Florida Citrus Industry Annual Conference 2016 crowd
Citrus
June 20, 2016
Florida Citrus Community Rallies Around Promise Of Bactericides, Biotechnology
Industry stakeholders holding out hope for solutions to HLB through antimicrobials and even transgenics. Read More
The Latest
Citrus
June 28, 2016
Panama Canal Expands For New Trade Oppor…
First vessel passes through new, larger locks as country celebrates. Read More
Citrus
June 24, 2016
Is It EPA’s Intention To Help Or H…
A common theme I see in complaints about the government agency is it appears to be taking action more and more based on ideology and public opinion rather than sound science. Read More
Citrus
June 23, 2016
Survey: Consumers Hungry For More Info O…
University of Florida researchers find learning opportunity among poll results regarding genetically modified foods. Read More
Citrus
June 23, 2016
Florida Fruit & Vegetable Associatio…
Mike Allen, a Founder of Politico and its Chief White House Correspondent, slated as keynote speaker for association's 73rd annual gathering. Read More
Citrus
June 22, 2016
Heads Up: FAA Finalizes Rules For Small …
Regulations will create new opportunities for business and government entities to use unmanned aircraft systems weighing less than 55 pounds. Read More
Citrus
June 21, 2016
Sound Science Struggling To Win Over Ske…
We all want the truth. But can we handle it? Read More
Citrus
June 20, 2016
Florida Citrus Community Rallies Around …
Industry stakeholders holding out hope for solutions to HLB through antimicrobials and even transgenics. Read More
Citrus
June 16, 2016
Florida Citrus Nurseries Seeking To Make…
Undercover production plans and possibilities starting to take shape. Read More
Citrus
June 14, 2016
Monsanto Rejects Second Bid From Bayer
Wall Street Journal reports Monsanto seeks bid increase from Bayer. Read More
Citrus
June 10, 2016
Florida Orange Crop Estimate Climbs Agai…
For the fourth consecutive month, ground is gained in Valencias. Read More
Citrus
June 8, 2016
Study: New Yield Mapping Method Might He…
With the possibility of saving money on inputs and labor, UF/IFAS researchers focus to find immature fruit faster. Read More
Citrus
June 8, 2016
AgAmerica Lending Banks On Experience To…
Industry veteran hired to enhance growth of company’s farm loans portfolio throughout Florida and the Southeast U.S. Read More
Citrus
June 2, 2016
Storm Season Off To Extra-Soggy Start In…
No let-up for parts of the Sunshine State still trying to shake off from wettest dry season in nearly six decades. Read More
Citrus
June 1, 2016
Groups Make Push To Challenge DuPont, Do…
Letter from industry organizations say proposed merger could hinder innovation, raise prices, and reduce choices. Read More
Citrus
May 31, 2016
Cannabis Cultivation Quest Becoming Real…
Planning, preparations finally giving way to production and dispensing of ‘Charlotte’s Web.’ Read More
Citrus
May 25, 2016
Monsanto Says Bayer Bid ‘Financially Ina…
Proposal cited as undervalued, not able to address financial, regulatory risks. Read More
Citrus
May 25, 2016
NRCS Invests $4.3 Million To Combat Clim…
The Natural Resources Conservation Service in California is committing funds to help farmers and ranchers mitigate the effects of climate change and help to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Read More
Citrus
May 24, 2016
Panama Canal Expansion To Bring Trade Op…
Agriculture Commissioner Adam Putnam says a confluence of events is putting the state's producers in a good spot to open new markets. Read More
[gravityform id="62" title="false" description="false"]