GMO Debate Worth The Fight [Opinion]

Mary Hartney, FFAA 2013Absent a federal solution, Florida will be the next major battleground in the war against modern agriculture. We are battling fears, misinformation, and activists with an anti-GMO agenda — but there is hope. A recent survey conducted for the International Food Information Council (IFIC), showed there’s support for the current FDA policy for labeling foods produced using biotechnology.

Additionally, when provided information about the benefits of biotechnology, of those surveyed: “The majority say they would be likely to purchase foods modified by biotechnology for various nutrition and health-related benefits. Seventy-two percent would be likely to purchase food products made with oils that were modified by biotechnology to provide more healthful fats, such as Omega-3 fatty acids. More than two-thirds of Americans say they would be likely to purchase foods improved with biotechnology to reduce the potential for carcinogens (69%), be protected from insect damage and require fewer pesticide applications (69%), enhance nutritional benefits (67%), and eliminate the trans fat content in foods (67%),” (IFIC survey news release, May 28, 2014).

But we have our work cut out for us in sharing information about biotechnology and its safety record with the general public. Thus far in 2014, 30 states saw more than 100 proposed bills introduced regarding GMO labeling. Florida had two of those bills, HB 1 and SB 558.
In May, Vermont became the first state to enact standalone mandatory labeling (bills passed in other states have triggers to be met before taking effect). Vermont’s law will likely be challenged in the courts. Ballot initiatives are looming threats in Colorado and Oregon (two Oregon counties already have voted to ban GMO cultivation and sales). Hawaii, home to world-leading research, development and production of GMO crops, is under siege from well-orchestrated anti-GMO campaigns. Voters in counties there may be taking up bans of GMO crops this fall.

Sticking To it

Whether it’s in Florida or Hawaii, Oregon, or Vermont, these attacks on modern agriculture and piecemeal labeling approaches are problems. It is time to find a comprehensive solution. The recently introduced Safe and Accurate Food Labeling Act of 2014 (HR 4432) does just that. HR 4432, bipartisan legislation sponsored by Rep. Mike Pompeo (R-KS), establishes the FDA as the authority on GMO food use and labeling issues.
The bill does more to address consumer interests. According to the Coalition for Safe and Affordable Food, HR 4432 will:

  • Eliminate Confusion: Remove the confusion and uncertainty of a state-by-state hodgepodge of GMO safety and labeling laws.
  • Advance Food Safety: Require the FDA to conduct a safety review of all new GMO traits before they are introduced into commerce. FDA will be empowered to mandate the labeling of GMO food ingredients if the agency determines there is a health, safety or nutrition issue with an ingredient derived from a GMO.
  • Inform Consumers: The FDA will establish federal standards for companies that want to voluntarily label their product for the absence-of or presence-of GMO food ingredients so that consumers clearly understand their choices.
  • Provide Consistency: The FDA will define the term “natural” for its use on food and beverage products so that food and beverage companies and consumers have a consistent legal framework that will guide food labels and inform consumer choice.

Differences Of Opinion

Much of agriculture — the typical exceptions being organic associations and outliers — opposes mandatory labeling as it is being proposed because it is arbitrary, capricious, unnecessary, and expensive, adding between $400 to $800 a year to a family’s annual food costs according to various economic studies.
Activists and others who don’t want GMOs already have options and choices. They can buy certified organic products or those labeled GMO-free. Those choices exist today, driven by the free market.
Your support is needed for science-based food labels for human health. Join the Safe and Affordable Food Coalition’s grassroots campaign for HR 4432. Share the GMOAnswers.com site and defend modern agriculture.

Topics: ,

Leave a Reply

Farm Management Stories
At a one-on-one meeting, Patrick Pinkard, Assistant Manager of Terranova Ranch, (center) meets with Spectrum Technologies' Bridget Graf and Kevin Monk.
Farm Management
November 22, 2016
VegetableGrowerConnect: Delivering Results For Growers And Suppliers
One-on-one meetings with suppliers and networking opportunities were highlights of the third annual Connect. Read More
Photo credit: Washington State University
Farm Management
November 22, 2016
A Hops Crop To Be Thankful For
Washington State University researcher looks back on the growth in the craft beer industry, and a monster hop crop this year. Read More
Sugarcane variety CP 09-1952
Citrus
November 21, 2016
7 Sweet Releases In Florida Sugarcane
New cultivars focus on disease resistance and yield. Read More
This image higlights salad leaf microflora prints. Photo credit: The University of Leicester
Food Safety
November 21, 2016
New Study Shows Pre-Cut Salad Fosters Growth Of Salmonella
A new study shows minimal damage to salad leaves in bagged salads stimulate the presence of Salmonella enterica. Read More
Adam Putnam speaking at the 2016 FFVA Annual Conference
Citrus
November 21, 2016
Insight Welcome On Florida Agriculture’s State Of The Industry
Poorly thought-out government policies loom as a major threat that prevents Florida farmers and ranchers from feeding a hungry world. Read More
Port Tampa Bay shipping channel
Citrus
November 19, 2016
USDA Gives $200 Million To Expand Ag Exports
USDA Secretary Tom Vilsack has announced the USDA’s Foreign Agricultural Service (FAS) is awarding $200 million to more than 70 Read More
One World Challenge wall at the University of Florida
GenNext Growers
November 19, 2016
Agriculture’s Next Generation Aiming To Save The World
University Of Florida program puts feeding a rapidly growing population in the hands of students. Read More
The Latest
Farm Management
December 1, 2016
Florida Farmers Are Good For The Environ…
All three recipients of this year’s Agricultural-Environmental Leadership Awards are proof of agriculture’s longstanding commitment to conserving the Sunshine State's precious natural resources. Read More
Citrus
November 23, 2016
Strength Of Sugar Fuels South Florida Ec…
The Sunshine State's sugar industry employs more than 14,000 people and has an annual income of more than $800 million with a total direct and indirect economic impact of greater than $3 billion. Read More
Farm Management
November 22, 2016
VegetableGrowerConnect: Delivering Resul…
One-on-one meetings with suppliers and networking opportunities were highlights of the third annual Connect. Read More
Farm Management
November 22, 2016
A Hops Crop To Be Thankful For
Washington State University researcher looks back on the growth in the craft beer industry, and a monster hop crop this year. Read More
Citrus
November 21, 2016
7 Sweet Releases In Florida Sugarcane
New cultivars focus on disease resistance and yield. Read More
Citrus
November 21, 2016
Insight Welcome On Florida Agriculture&#…
Poorly thought-out government policies loom as a major threat that prevents Florida farmers and ranchers from feeding a hungry world. Read More
Citrus
November 19, 2016
USDA Gives $200 Million To Expand Ag Exp…
USDA Secretary Tom Vilsack has announced the USDA’s Foreign Agricultural Service (FAS) is awarding $200 million to more than 70 Read More
Citrus
November 17, 2016
How Soil Type Affects Land Values
Sand, loam, and muck all offer something different when setting property prices. Read More
Business Planning
November 17, 2016
Financial Flux Forcing Extra Groundwork …
With challenging issues afoot, it’s not too early to start thinking about policies and funding implications surrounding the next Farm Bill. Read More
Citrus
November 17, 2016
Florida Farming, Sugarcane Pioneer Passe…
George H. Wedgworth founded and led the Sugar Cane Growers Cooperative of Florida for 50 years. Read More
Citrus
November 15, 2016
Help On The Way To Florida Farmers Hurti…
USDA designates four counties as primary natural disaster areas; loans offered to those eligible. Read More
Citrus
November 15, 2016
How The Trump Administration Will Impact…
In new report, experts say policy changes, especially immigration, could have long-term implications on the industry. Read More
Farm Management
November 14, 2016
Asian Trade Deal Killed
In what one prominent economist says is a blow to U.S. fruit exporters, the White House concedes the Trans-Pacific Partnership is not going to be ratified. Read More
Citrus
November 14, 2016
Dry Season Dangers Not On The Radar For …
Emerging from an extended period of plentiful precipitation, near-term water supply, drought issues not anticipated in the coming months. Read More
Citrus
November 9, 2016
U.S. Sweats Out Third-Warmest October On…
So far, 2016 is the second-warmest year-to-date in 122 years. Read More
Citrus
November 9, 2016
It’s Time To Turn The Page On Elec…
Mr. Trump has the White House and Republicans have the Congress. They are in a position to lead, and they must. Read More
Farm Management
November 8, 2016
Washington Sees Record Rainfall
State rainfall for month of October slashes earlier years’ totals. Read More
Citrus
November 8, 2016
National Farmers Union Seeks Amendment T…
Comments sent to IRS say change in provisions makes it difficult for farmers to accurately valuate assets. Read More