What’s In An Apple Cultivar’s Name?

Jim McFersonWho knew the hardest part of an apple breeding program is finding a name for a new release? We have been led to believe it was all the years of field testing that force growers and tree fruit breeders to wait 15 to 20 years for delivery of a new cultivar. Genetic and genomic tools promise to cut a few years off that development time, but still leave us with a decade or more from the breeder’s initial cross. That is long time to realize a return on investment.

Understandably, growers funding various tree fruit breeding programs get impatient as hundreds of thousands of dollars seem to disappear into a labyrinthine process of testing and re-testing. Similarly, breeders grow old on the job, spending a career to produce only a handful of finished cultivars which may or may not have any impact in the marketplace.

Sometimes that handful can be worth the effort … if that cultivar is Honeycrisp! Jim Luby and David Bedford at the University of Minnesota can certainly be proud of their years of hard work to turn this selection from an interesting (and initially unsuccessful) new release into the breakthrough cultivar that it has become.

It has also become clear that delays in the availability of new cultivars in commercially relevant quantities can run into many years. Propagation problems and genetic identity mishaps are a constant challenge, with the potential to significantly delay access for growers, increase costs to propagators, and lead growers to question their risk to benefit ratios.

Risk Vs. Benefit
Despite such obstacles, a proliferation of new scion and rootstock cultivars in apple and cherry (with a slight trickle starting in pear) leaves tree fruit growers with more choices than ever. While that is an exciting opportunity on one hand, it also adds to the risk on that risk to benefit ratio.

Will the new cultivar perform well and merit the $20,000-plus per acre establishment costs? Will the packing shed figure out handling and storage issues? Will the marketing and sales folks get behind it? And, key to it all, will the consumer return for repeat sales? It took many years for those questions to be answered for Honeycrisp, but everyone in the supply chain is benefiting now.

A large number of Washington growers, 458 to be exact, applied to enter a lottery for the first access to Cosmic Crisp trees for 2017. (Photo credit: WSU CAHNRS Communications)
A large number of Washington growers, 458 to be exact, applied to enter a lottery for the first access to Cosmic Crisp trees for 2017. (Photo credit: WSU CAHNRS Communications)

Exciting Times Ahead
So is this really an exciting opportunity, or just one more vexation for a tree fruit grower? Few plant a single tree anymore without having done their homework on those questions, but sometimes there are not a lot of answers. Despite the best efforts of breeding programs, we lack solid data on horticultural performance and postharvest handling on most introductions. Market potential remains a big guess. The grower learns by doing, while bearing educational costs that make many student loans look like a desirable option.

The apple breeding program at the University of Minnesota led by Luby and Bedford, as well as the Cornell University program run by Susan Brown, have taken up this challenge. Their recent releases — SweeTango from Minnesota and RubyFrost and SnapDragon from Cornell — were tested well enough to provide growers a reasonable shot at making a wise decision and these exciting new cultivars are off to a good start.

WA38’s Turn
Similarly, the Washington State University (WSU) pome fruit breeding program, directed by Kate Evans, has worked very hard to obtain answers to those important grower questions. In addition, WSU has adopted a strong policy of providing growers in Washington State initial access to their products and partnered with my organization to conduct systematic and rigorous multi-year tests before pushing selections to commercialization.

Now, after nearly 20 years of investment, the WSU program is at that commercialization point for its latest release, but one more delay appeared — finding a name for the release, previously identified by its breeding program code, WA38. Thankfully, that process of many months is past and we now have a name: Cosmic Crisp. Grower interest is keen and a drawing was conducted in June to determine who will have first access to the limited number of finished trees available for 2016.

Willing To Take A Risk On Cosmic Crisp
Based on the 458 applications received, it is clear a significant number of Washington apple growers are willing to take an initial risk on this release. Based on the overwhelmingly positive evaluations of the cultivar’s horticultural performance and handling characteristics, the industry finally has an apple that grows and stores better than anything else out there. Based on consumer testing, in which it regularly surpassed Honeycrisp, Cosmic Crisp could provide another excellent choice at retail.

So why was it so difficult to find a name for a WSU release, given its obviously superior characteristics in Washington conditions and pull-through demand from the state’s apple growers? While I understand the claim that a catchy name is helpful whether you are selling apples, breakfast cereal, razors, or perfume, it eludes me why we can’t rely more on the creativity and competence of our U.S. apple breeding programs to develop and deliver new cultivars that do not need a clever name and marketing gloss to attract the consumer.

Honeycrisp should have proven to all skeptics that if a fruit product provides a superior consumer experience, it will sell itself, despite production and appearance challenges. Here’s hoping that is true for Cosmic Crisp. Based on the data, the risk to benefit ratio is quite favorable.

Topics: , , , , , ,

Leave a Reply

Apples & Pears Stories
Apples & PearsReal-World Solutions Highlight First Biocontrols 2015 Conference & Tradeshow
January 22, 2015
Topping the inaugural event's marquee are presentations on “Driving Crop Quality and Productivity Using Biocontrols” by representatives from two of the largest produce growing organizations in the country. Read More
Apples & PearsRosBREED 2 Program Focuses On Disease Resistance And Quality
January 19, 2015
The next generation of the federally funded RosBREED research program uses DNA techniques to deliver varieties that benefit both growers and consumers. Read More
Apples & PearsRubyFrost Hits Stores This Month
January 14, 2015
Marketed as wintertime apple, this second managed release from New York Apple Growers is available through retailers in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic area. Read More
Apples & PearsCold Winter Took Bite Out Of Minnesota Apple Crop
January 14, 2015
Research scientist with University of Minnesota reported how the 2013 growing season and subsequent winter affected the state’s apple crop. Read More
Apples & PearsOpal Apples Launched Into Space
January 14, 2015
Washington grower sends new variety to the International Space Station. Read More
Apples & PearsTwo Strains Of Listeria Found At California Apple Processing Facility
January 12, 2015
Bakersfield, CA, company works with federal and state officials to determine source of listeriosis-associated outbreak. Read More
Apples & PearsManage Brown Marmorated Stink Bug Without Abandoning IPM
January 5, 2015
Research shows a mix of traps, monitoring, and insecticides can help Eastern peach growers keep brown marmorated stink bug in check. Read More
The Latest
Apples & PearsThe Dark side of Honeycrisp
January 27, 2015
Growers say there’s a love-hate relationship with America’s darling apple. Read More
Apples & PearsExpanded Market Access For U.S. Grown Apples To China
January 26, 2015
Agreement expected to boost apple exports by $100 million per year. Read More
Apples & PearsSurvey: Positive Indicators For Biocontrols In U.S. Hor…
January 22, 2015
Preliminary results of a survey conducted in December 2014 of more than 850 readers across six Meister Media Worldwide titles Read More
Apples & PearsReal-World Solutions Highlight First Biocontrols 2015 C…
January 22, 2015
Topping the inaugural event's marquee are presentations on “Driving Crop Quality and Productivity Using Biocontrols” by representatives from two of the largest produce growing organizations in the country. Read More
Apples & PearsRosBREED 2 Program Focuses On Disease Resistance And Qu…
January 19, 2015
The next generation of the federally funded RosBREED research program uses DNA techniques to deliver varieties that benefit both growers and consumers. Read More
Apples & PearsRubyFrost Hits Stores This Month
January 14, 2015
Marketed as wintertime apple, this second managed release from New York Apple Growers is available through retailers in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic area. Read More
Apples & PearsCold Winter Took Bite Out Of Minnesota Apple Crop
January 14, 2015
Research scientist with University of Minnesota reported how the 2013 growing season and subsequent winter affected the state’s apple crop. Read More
Apples & PearsOpal Apples Launched Into Space
January 14, 2015
Washington grower sends new variety to the International Space Station. Read More
Apples & PearsTwo Strains Of Listeria Found At California Apple Proce…
January 12, 2015
Bakersfield, CA, company works with federal and state officials to determine source of listeriosis-associated outbreak. Read More
Apples & PearsManage Brown Marmorated Stink Bug Without Abandoning I…
January 5, 2015
Research shows a mix of traps, monitoring, and insecticides can help Eastern peach growers keep brown marmorated stink bug in check. Read More
Apples & PearsOn The Road With The International Fruit Tree Associati…
January 4, 2015
Win’s posts, like this one, share the flavor of growing fruit in Italy, as well as some of the production techniques unique to the region. Read More
Apples & PearsJohnny Appleseed Has More In Common With You Than Just …
January 4, 2015
Strategic planting, understanding the soil, and projecting profits are among the reasons John Chapman was a true apple grower. Read More
Apples & PearsUSApple’s Social Media Numbers Sweet As Honey
January 4, 2015
Outreach abuzz with with many fruitful efforts to connect with apple consumers. Read More
Apples & PearsFifth-Generation Orchardist Wins Jan Cook Mack Painting
January 3, 2015
Winner presented painting at Washington State Horticultural Association’s 110th annual meeting in December. Read More
Apples & PearsNovember Cold May Hurt Washington Orchards
December 17, 2014
But it’s too early to tell if well-below-normal temperatures will increase tree mortality. Read More
Apples & PearsFour Highlights You May Have Missed At Great Lakes Expo
December 16, 2014
Record-setting crowd sat in on presentations featuring precision orchard management, mechanical berry harvesters, biocontrols, and more. Read More
Apples & PearsRecord Crowds Flock To Washington Horticultural Show
December 16, 2014
More than 1,600 attend; banquet attendance is up by nearly 100. Read More
Apples & PearsUSApple Hits 50,000 Facebook Fans
December 3, 2014
Trade organization surpasses follower milestone with social media programs created to deepen online engagement with consumers. Read More