Get Used To GMOs [Opinion]

David Eddy

Whenever I write about genetically modified crops — the shorthand GMO is commonly used, which stands for genetically modified organism — I usually get feedback from members of the anti-GMO crowd. The comments range from the uninformed, about how Americans will never stand for them in our food, which is ridiculous because they’ve been there for 20 years and now the lion’s share of corn and soybeans are genetically modified; to the unrealistic, who say they will never, ever make their way into fruits and vegetables.

I was reminded of this the other day in talking on the phone with a staff scientist for Los Alamos National Laboratory in New Mexico. First off, just the fact that I found his name associated with the research I was interested in — about how they’re wiping out Pierce’s disease in grapevines, which you can read about here — struck me. I don’t know about you, but for me the name “Los Alamos” has always been associated with the Manhattan Project and black and white movies of nuclear detonations.

I asked about that, and the scientist, Goutam Gupta, said Los Alamos has been doing bioscience research from the beginning, when they began to investigate the effects of radiation on living organisms. More recently, they have become heavily engaged in bioenergy research such as on ethanol, and they employ two scientists focused on trying to come up with transgenic plants from which they can more easily derive glucose, the main stumbling block to ethanol production.

Frankenphooey

But getting back to the fruit research, and how they managed to kill Xylella fastidiosa, the bacteria responsible for Pierce’s disease, the kiss of death for grapevines. Gupta and his colleagues engineered a gene containing a bit of human genetic material, and inserted it into the grapevine. Having heard often enough from critics complaining about “Frankenfoods,” alarm bells immediately went off in my head. But Gupta, unperturbed, explained that they only used the human genetic material because the human genome had been previously mapped and they knew where to get what they needed. Once the grape genome is sequenced, which is expected soon, they will use genetic material from grapes. To which I replied, quite sensibly: “Wow.”

Then I immediately thought of another currently incurable disease in another important fruit crop, citrus greening, or huanglongbing. The disease has wreaked havoc in the orange groves of Florida as well as other parts of the world. It immediately leapt to mind because it has most recently been found, for the first time, in California where I live. Fortunately it has not been found in the San Joaquin Valley citrus belt, at the foot of the Sierra Nevada, where about 80% of the nation’s fresh-market orange crop is grown. Gupta, who was a few minutes late for the interview because he was on a two-hour conference call, explained that citrus greening was precisely the topic of that call, as he is co-chair of the Citrus Health Response Program.

Hanging up, I thought about how we might have practical, commercially viable answers to these menacing diseases facing our fruit crops in the not-too-distant future. I also thought how even the most entrenched Luddite is going to have a hard time saying sure, we can save our nation’s fruit crops, but we’re going to sit back and do nothing. If there’s one thing we’ve learned in agriculture, and the course of human history at large, it’s that science marches on.

Leave a Reply

One comment on “Get Used To GMOs [Opinion]

  1. I don't self-identify with the "non-GMO crowd", but I do agree with them that labeling is a very reasonable expectation. It places virtually no extra burden anywhere in the supply chain and yet will allow consumers the freedom to choose. Isn't that what a free market is all about?

Grapes Stories
GrapesSulfur Spray Best Practices For Winegrapes
August 14, 2015
New research helps growers determine how close to harvest they can safely spray elemental sulfur. Read More
BerriesScientist Has Sights On Shooting Down Spotted Wing Drosophila
August 14, 2015
Study helps flush out possible biological control for dreaded fruit pest. Read More
GrapesResearch Seeks To Find Better Grapevine Roots
August 14, 2015
Rootstocks have benefits, but research shows there’s no silver bullet. Read More
Disease ControlProtect Hail-Damaged Grape Clusters From Botrytis
August 11, 2015
Recent hailstorms hit Northwest Michigan hard. Grapes, tart cherries, and apples orchards were hit by high winds and nickel- to Read More
GrapesDrought’s Impact On California Winegrapes
July 30, 2015
The impact is minimal this year, but the future is uncertain if the drought continues. Read More
Western grapeleaf skeletonizer moths
GrapesNew Winegrape Pest Found In California
July 9, 2015
Western grapeleaf skeletonizer could mean nasty problems for Napa County growers. Read More
GrapesRaisin Grower Wins Supreme Court Decision On Price Support
June 23, 2015
A farmer who refused to hand over half his raisin crop to the government as part of a New Deal-era Read More
The Latest
GrapesWashington Winegrape Harvest Earlier Than Ever
September 3, 2015
  This year’s juice and winegrape harvest in Washington is historic. Michelle Moyer, Washington State University assistant professor, Dept. of Read More
GrapesWildfires Raise Fears Of Grape Smoke Taint
September 3, 2015
 The current wildfires in Washington have left many growers wondering if smoke taint could impact the flavor of their winegrapes. Read More
Apples & PearsSyngenta Receives EPA Registration For Solatenol  Fungi…
September 1, 2015
The fungicide is available in four product offerings, pending state registrations. Read More
GrapesSulfur Spray Best Practices For Winegrapes
August 14, 2015
New research helps growers determine how close to harvest they can safely spray elemental sulfur. Read More
BerriesScientist Has Sights On Shooting Down Spotted Wing Dros…
August 14, 2015
Study helps flush out possible biological control for dreaded fruit pest. Read More
GrapesResearch Seeks To Find Better Grapevine Roots
August 14, 2015
Rootstocks have benefits, but research shows there’s no silver bullet. Read More
Disease ControlProtect Hail-Damaged Grape Clusters From Botrytis
August 11, 2015
Recent hailstorms hit Northwest Michigan hard. Grapes, tart cherries, and apples orchards were hit by high winds and nickel- to Read More
GrapesDrought’s Impact On California Winegrapes
July 30, 2015
The impact is minimal this year, but the future is uncertain if the drought continues. Read More
Western grapeleaf skeletonizer moths
GrapesNew Winegrape Pest Found In California
July 9, 2015
Western grapeleaf skeletonizer could mean nasty problems for Napa County growers. Read More
GrapesRaisin Grower Wins Supreme Court Decision On Price Supp…
June 23, 2015
A farmer who refused to hand over half his raisin crop to the government as part of a New Deal-era Read More
GrapesCalifornia’s Winegrowers Overwhelmingly Back Anti-Pest …
June 22, 2015
More than 80% of growers vote to continue Pierce’s disease/glassy-winged sharpshooter referendum. Read More
Disease ControlFMC’s RHYME Fungicide Labeled In California And Arizona
June 18, 2015
RHYME fungicide is now labeled for use in California and Arizona  for control of powdery mildew and black rot in Read More
GrapesDeveloping The Grapes Of The Future
June 9, 2015
Through advanced chromosome mapping, VitisGen is working to create hardy and disease-resistant grape cultivars. Read More
GrapesASEV-ES Announces Outstanding Achievement Award Winner
June 9, 2015
Wayne Wilcox will be presented with the award at the 40th Annual ASEV-ES Conference in Dunkirk, NY, in July. Read More
Disease ControlTips For Grapevine Trunk Disease Diagnostics, Preventio…
May 28, 2015
Various pathogens and environmental factors are considered to be major threats to the vineyard’s health. Pathogens are disease-causing organisms such Read More
GrapesDeadline Extended For Crucial Winegrape Disease And Pes…
May 27, 2015
Returned ballots to continue the Pierce’s Disease/Glassy-Winged Sharpshooter referendum must be returned by June 10. Read More
EquipmentThe Benefits Of Vineyard Mechanization
May 27, 2015
Labor accounts for a substantial fraction of the production costs of most fruits, including grapes. Manual harvest is particularly laborious, Read More
Apples & PearsSolve Your Labor Problems From Within
May 26, 2015
Summer is here, which means harvest season is just around the corner. Hopefully you’ll have the crews you need this Read More