Codling Moth Monitoring Tips in Walnuts

Codling moth can look benign, above, but do serious damage. (Photo: UC Statewide IPM Project)

It is important to understand how mating disruption affects the ability to monitor codling moth in walnut orchards under mating disruption (MD) as well as in orchards in proximity to MD.

Researchers are currently investigating just how far-reaching the impacts of mating disruption are to nearby non-MD blocks. Pheromone-only trapping methods will certainly be impacted in MD blocks, and can be affected in nearby non-MD environments — without the added benefit of substantial disruption, and thus population and damage reduction. Other monitoring methods are necessary in and near MD orchards to effectively manage codling moth populations.

 

Damage from a codling moth feeding is seen walnut which was cut open. (Photo: UC Statewide IPM Project)

Disruption of sexual communication in moths is thought to function by the following broad types of behavioral mechanisms, and combinations of the two mechanisms:

 

  • Competitive attraction (false-plume-following), in which males are diverted from orienting to females because they are attracted to competing “‘false”’ trails emitted by synthetic pheromone dispensers.
  • Non-competitive mechanisms, whereby exposure to synthetic pheromone inhibits or blocks the ability of males to sense and/or respond normally to pheromones emitted from females. These include camouflage, desensitization (i.e., adaptation and habituation), and sensory imbalance.In a practical sense, the presence of synthetic pheromone in and around the orchard environment, if effectively impacting impeding mate location/mating success, will impact our ability to use pheromone lures to track population abundance and activity. Codling moth (CM) females emit sex pheromones which elicit responses from males of the species.

Therefore, pheromone traps predominantly track only male activity.

Successful MD will shut down pheromone traps to zero or very low male catches relative to non-MD environments. In a MD orchard, you will want to monitor pheromone-only traps to gauge this measure of MD effectiveness. However, it is also critical to be able to track flights and relative population abundance to determine if supplemental insecticide treatments are necessary, and to properly time the applications.

The Suterra aerosol is trade-named “Suterra CheckMate Puffer CM.” (Photo: Suterra)

Fortunately, there are options available for monitoring CM in/near MD that can overcome trap shutdown by (1) incorporating non-pheromone based lures to trap males, females, or both sexes; and (2) employing additional surveillance methods (non-trap-based) to gauge pest pressure and inform treatment decisions.

Combination Lures
Both female and male moths respond to pear ester. This is available in the CM-DA combo lure, which (contains codlemone, the codling moth pheromone, plus pear ester, a plant volatile-based kairomone). Traps baited with these lures should be used in orchards under MD in addition to pheromone- only traps (baited with 1X or L2 lures), necessary to detect trap shutdown as a proxy for efficacy of the MD treatment. If you are concerned with the performance of pheromone-only CM traps in non-MD orchards, consider adding some CM-DA traps, particularly if you suspect you are in proximity to an MD block that is affecting your pheromone trap catches.

Another option is the three-way lure (CM-DA combo plus acetic acid, AA). Think of this as a “‘super-charged”’ lure, which can provide more robust capture in terms of numbers of males and females (in both MD and non-MD orchards).

With both the CM-DA and CM-DA+AA lures, be cautious in your evaluation of trap numbers. Numbers may be higher or lower than pheromone trap catch numbers, depending on your particular environment (MD, non-MD, near MD), and may not directly correlate with the same moths/trap/night thresholds you are accustomed to.

Non-Trapping Methods
These surveillance methods involve in-season damage/population estimates via dropped nut counts and canopy counts looking for strikes (visible as small chimneys of frass at the CM entry point). These monitoring methods can and should be incorporated into your IPM program to aid in treatment decisions, regardless of presence of MD and the trap-lure combination you are using.

More information and details regarding these monitoring and treatment options for codling moth are available online in the University of California IPM Guidelines.

Best Practices For Trapping/Monitoring
Some thoughts on best practices for lure-based trapping, and monitoring in general:

The Pacific Biocontrol aerosol is trade-named “Isomate CM Mist.” (Photo: Pacific Biocontrol)
  • Storage and handling: Always follow manufacturer guidelines for storage and handling of lures. Most lures are best kept refrigerated or frozen (in non-cycling freezers). It is best to order fresh lures each year, as keeping lures for multiple years can impact alter performance. If lures are particularly “‘hot’” initially, be sure to pre-age lures — open packaging and let them sit out for a day or so — prior to deploying them in the field to avoid misinterpretation of activity peaks. Use new traps every year and wear disposable rubber gloves when handling lures and traps to avoid cross-contamination. (This will help prevent by-catch of non-target species).
  • Interpreting catches and perceived failures: If you are encountering trap catch data that seems unusual, first consider any potential storage, handling, or contamination issues. Next consider other factors, such as new MD blocks in proximity to traps and unusual environmental conditions. Most manufacturers have strict quality control practices; if you have eliminated all other sources of a problem, contact your lure supplier.
  • Adopting new trapping techniques: When possible, adopting new monitoring techniques should be a multi-year process, in which new trapping method(s) are introduced alongside those for which historical data is available to help you best understand new results.
  • Pesticide applications: Ensure that you are accounting for all treatments and field activities when interpreting trap catches and population activity.
  • Interpreting data and making pest management decisions in the field is as much art as science: Although researchers seek to provide the best decision-making guidelines, in reality, there are no exact thresholds and every situation is different. Individual pieces of information, while valuable, often do not provide robust enough evidence to support a “treat” vs. “don’t treat” recommendation. Incorporating knowledge from trap data, other surveillance methods, orchard history, and environmental conditions is critical to developing effective pest management programs that you are confident in recommending.

 

Topics: , ,

Leave a Reply

Nuts Stories
Citrus
August 17, 2017
How Wicked Will Winter 2018 Be in the U.S.?
The 200th edition of the Farmers’ Almanac reveals wide-ranging weather patterns and events that would require everything from shovels to shorts. Read More
Nuts
July 30, 2017
The New Normal of Almond Orchard Canopies
Just because an almond orchard has no live lower limbs doesn’t mean it’s not extraordinarily productive. Read More
Nuts
July 29, 2017
New Orchard Systems Advisor Returns Home
Luke Milliron, who’s back in the Butte County area, is ready to help growers, especially improving irrigation. Read More
Nuts
July 28, 2017
Self-Fertile Almond Dominates New Plantings
‘Independence’ almond — which cuts pollination and other cultural costs — now represents one-quarter of all plantings. Read More
Citrus
July 23, 2017
USDA Invests $7.6 Million toward Beneficial Insect Research
Projects to promote beneficial organisms as part of a pest control strategy. Read More
Fruits
July 14, 2017
Brown Marmorated Stink Bug Predator Egg Mass Found
Samuri wasp parasitized egg mass found in Southern New Jersey peach orchard. Read More
Mobile technology farming
Citrus
July 10, 2017
Practical Solutions Are Bringing Precision Agriculture Closer to Earth
Growing the budding ag-tech sector to maturity likely will require a deeper meeting of the minds between technologists and agriculturists. Read More
Nuts
July 7, 2017
Lab Opens to Test for Pistachio Problem
AgExperts Inc. is now testing for Rhodococcus bacteria, which has plagued growers for the past few years. Read More
Nuts
July 7, 2017
California Almond Crop Projected to Increase 5%
This year’s California almond crop is forecasted to exceed 2 billion pounds, according to the California Almond Objective Measurement Report Read More
Closeup of a managed bee hive next to a blueberry field
Citrus
June 28, 2017
Felony Charges in Beehive Thefts
The men accused of heading up an operation to steal and re-sell beehives, Pavel Tveretinov and Vitaliy Yeroshenko, 48, have Read More
Citrus
June 21, 2017
Storm Runoff May Recharge Aquifers and Your Crops
A new study hints that tapping into storm water during dry years does more than increase water table levels. Read More
honeybees
Fruits
June 6, 2017
Survey: Bee Loss Drops Last Season
Bee Informed Partnership says preliminary analysis of results show second-lowest loss rate recorded in last seven years. Read More
Nuts
June 3, 2017
Have Flooded Orchards? Keep an Eye out for Damage
While the damage from waterlogging or Phytophthora may not be immediately known, there are some warning signs to be on the lookout for. Read More
Managed bee hive boxes around a blueberry field
Nuts
May 25, 2017
Stolen Hives Recovered in Nearly $1M Heist
Man likely stole hives from across the state of California in the last three years. Read More
Nuts
May 16, 2017
Another Record California Almond Crop Forecast
Bearing acreage officially hits the million mark, though per-acre yields are off from 2016. Read More
The Latest
Nuts
September 12, 2017
Walnut Crop Expected to be Down 5%
While wet California winter was welcome to growers, some orchards were flooded, compromising root systems. Read More
Nuts
September 3, 2017
Codling Moth Monitoring Tips in Walnuts
Mating disruption doesn’t just affect those orchards directly involved; you need to consider the potential impact on nearby orchards. Read More
Insect Control
August 22, 2017
Stink Bug Threatens High-Dollar Crops in…
While populations are low, it appears invasive pest has recently stumbled upon the state’s peaches and almonds. Read More
Citrus
August 17, 2017
How Wicked Will Winter 2018 Be in the U.…
The 200th edition of the Farmers’ Almanac reveals wide-ranging weather patterns and events that would require everything from shovels to shorts. Read More
Nuts
July 30, 2017
The New Normal of Almond Orchard Canopie…
Just because an almond orchard has no live lower limbs doesn’t mean it’s not extraordinarily productive. Read More
Nuts
July 29, 2017
New Orchard Systems Advisor Returns Home
Luke Milliron, who’s back in the Butte County area, is ready to help growers, especially improving irrigation. Read More
Nuts
July 28, 2017
Self-Fertile Almond Dominates New Planti…
‘Independence’ almond — which cuts pollination and other cultural costs — now represents one-quarter of all plantings. Read More
Citrus
July 23, 2017
USDA Invests $7.6 Million toward Benefic…
Projects to promote beneficial organisms as part of a pest control strategy. Read More
Fruits
July 14, 2017
Brown Marmorated Stink Bug Predator Egg …
Samuri wasp parasitized egg mass found in Southern New Jersey peach orchard. Read More
Citrus
July 10, 2017
Practical Solutions Are Bringing Precisi…
Growing the budding ag-tech sector to maturity likely will require a deeper meeting of the minds between technologists and agriculturists. Read More
Nuts
July 7, 2017
Lab Opens to Test for Pistachio Problem
AgExperts Inc. is now testing for Rhodococcus bacteria, which has plagued growers for the past few years. Read More
Nuts
July 7, 2017
California Almond Crop Projected to Incr…
This year’s California almond crop is forecasted to exceed 2 billion pounds, according to the California Almond Objective Measurement Report Read More
Citrus
June 28, 2017
Felony Charges in Beehive Thefts
The men accused of heading up an operation to steal and re-sell beehives, Pavel Tveretinov and Vitaliy Yeroshenko, 48, have Read More
Citrus
June 21, 2017
Storm Runoff May Recharge Aquifers and Y…
A new study hints that tapping into storm water during dry years does more than increase water table levels. Read More
Fruits
June 6, 2017
Survey: Bee Loss Drops Last Season
Bee Informed Partnership says preliminary analysis of results show second-lowest loss rate recorded in last seven years. Read More
Nuts
June 3, 2017
Have Flooded Orchards? Keep an Eye out f…
While the damage from waterlogging or Phytophthora may not be immediately known, there are some warning signs to be on the lookout for. Read More
Nuts
May 25, 2017
Stolen Hives Recovered in Nearly $1M Hei…
Man likely stole hives from across the state of California in the last three years. Read More
Nuts
May 16, 2017
Another Record California Almond Crop Fo…
Bearing acreage officially hits the million mark, though per-acre yields are off from 2016. Read More