Taking A Hard Look At Whither Pruning Almonds

Whither PruningAlmond growers have traditionally pruned their trees, and the practice went unquestioned for many years. Perhaps it was a holdover from caring for fruit trees, says University of California Cooperative Extension farm adviser John Edstrom. After all, many of the state’s original almond growers started as peach growers, and the trees are closely related. However, many of the very good reasons for pruning peach trees simply don’t apply to almonds. Peach growers prune their trees mainly to increase fruit size and improve color, neither of which apply to almonds. Edstrom has now been studying the issue for nearly a quarter of a century, and he’s convinced that when it comes to yield — the primary reason almond growers prune — there’s no advantage to pruning. The first pruning trial was planted at the Nickels Soils Lab in Colusa in 1979. Edstrom and his colleague Bill Krueger took over the trial in 1984, and at the time he too thought pruned trees would fare better. But not any more. “The yield was at least as high, and certainly no lower, in the minimally pruned trees,” he says. “It’s a shocking piece of data in almond culture.” Many growers have remained skeptical, especially since the original trial was on a high-density (7 feet by 22 feet) hedgerow block with questionable soils. So in 1997 he planted a second trial to better reflect the state of the industry. It was planted in good soil with a more standard spacing of 16 feet by 22 feet and irrigated with microsprinklers. “It’s a nice, strong orchard by any standard,” he says. “And it too showed that minimally pruned trees yield at least as well as traditionally pruned trees.” (See chart.)

Minimal Vs. Unpruned

While many growers use the term “unpruned,” Edstrom is quick to note that’s not entirely true. After the first leaf, it’s important that an almond tree is pruned during dormant season. This pruning is mainly for limb training, he says. Three or four primary limbs are selected, and all competing limbs are removed to provide the tree with a sound structure. After that initial pruning, however, the trees are left alone. Edstrom adds that it’s not just the trials he and Krueger have performed that bear out his conclusion. His Cooperative Extension colleagues have conducted similar trials throughout California almond country, and have garnered similar results. Edstrom understands why growers are skeptical; he himself once was. He thinks a lot of it stems from the fact that a pruned block of trees looks a lot cleaner and better-maintained than a block that hasn’t seen pruning shears in many years. “People will get embarrassed if their trees don’t look as good,” he says. “But it’s hard to argue with the facts.” Yet another fact is that pruning obviously costs more than simply leaving the trees alone. In addition, growers who prune have to dispose of the clippings, says Edstrom. While in the past that wasn’t that big a deal because they could simply be burned, air quality regulations have been instituted in recent years that prohibit burning in many areas.

Take A Hard Look

Some growers still insist that they need to prune to let in light so the lower fruiting wood doesn’t get shaded out as the trees age. However, if that were a big concern, Edstrom thinks the minimally pruned trees in his original trial would have started yielding less than the pruned trees. He understands the concern, however, and will continue to monitor the trees carefully as they age. “How much light do we need to maintain? We really can’t say for sure,” he says. “But my hunch is that it’s really not going to turn out to be that big a deal.” Edstrom emphasizes that he doesn’t want to be so presumptive as to simply tell growers not to prune. However, he’s heard many reasons for pruning, and most of them don’t hold up. According to Edstrom, growers shouldn’t prune just because: – Your trees look better. – Your labor contractor recommends you do it. – The grower across the street does it. – You’ve always done it. Instead of looking at the issue from that angle, Edstrom suggests growers take the opposite approach. “You need a strong reason to make a pruning cut,” he says. “Think about it before you do it.”

Topics: ,

Leave a Reply

Nuts Stories
More than 30 loads of tree nuts - like this truck being filled with walnuts - have been stolen in the past six months. (Photo credit: David Eddy)
Nuts
April 20, 2016
California Legislators Give Preliminary OK To Nut Theft Prevention Law
California experienced 158 cargo theft incidents in 2015, costing businesses nearly $19 million – more than any other state. Read More
almond_bloomstage1010-opt
Nuts
April 19, 2016
Understanding Almond Set And Nut Drop
Almond Doctor David Doll shares insight into what impacts nut set. Read More
WalnutSpacing70-web
Nuts
April 19, 2016
Rethinking Walnut Irrigation
Watering walnuts too early can harm root systems, while waiting too long can lead to reduced kernel size. Researchers are working to find the sweet spot. Read More
'Durham'

Photo by Chuck Leslie
Nuts
April 13, 2016
New ‘Durham’ Walnut Offers Earlier Harvest
‘Durham’ offers excellent kernel color and fill, reduced susceptibility to blight, and harvests about 10 days earlier than ‘Chandler.’ Read More
AGERpoint Inc.'s aerial LiDAR platform drone
Nuts
April 13, 2016
The Future Of Orchard Irrigation
Drone-based thermal imaging could help growers drastically improve irrigation efficiency in orchards. Read More
Western Growers Technology for web
Farm Management
April 8, 2016
Western Growers’ Center For Innovation & Technology To Focus On Labor, Water Solutions
The Western Growers Association sets up a Silicon Valley-like innovation hub — in the heart of farmland. Read More
Mohammad Yaghmour
Nuts
April 6, 2016
Meet The Expert: Mohammad Yaghmour
Mohammad Yaghmour recently joined UCCE as Orchard Systems Advisor for Kern and Kings counties. We caught up with him to find out what he’s most interested in researching further, and what he can bring to the table to help nut growers succeed. Read More
The Latest
Nuts
April 29, 2016
Look Out For Jacket Rot On Almond Leaves
Rains at bloom are causing higher than normal incidents of bacterial infections. Read More
Citrus
April 26, 2016
Farm Bureau Says Labor Visa Backlogs Thr…
Agency calls for swifter processing of paperwork so growers' requests for crews can be met. Read More
Equipment
April 22, 2016
Whole Orchard Recycling Could Improve So…
A giant new machine gobbles up whole trees and spits out the chunks, which eventually get worked back into the soil. Read More
Nuts
April 20, 2016
California Legislators Give Preliminary …
California experienced 158 cargo theft incidents in 2015, costing businesses nearly $19 million – more than any other state. Read More
Nuts
April 19, 2016
Understanding Almond Set And Nut Drop
Almond Doctor David Doll shares insight into what impacts nut set. Read More
Nuts
April 19, 2016
Rethinking Walnut Irrigation
Watering walnuts too early can harm root systems, while waiting too long can lead to reduced kernel size. Researchers are working to find the sweet spot. Read More
Nuts
April 13, 2016
New ‘Durham’ Walnut Offers E…
‘Durham’ offers excellent kernel color and fill, reduced susceptibility to blight, and harvests about 10 days earlier than ‘Chandler.’ Read More
Nuts
April 13, 2016
The Future Of Orchard Irrigation
Drone-based thermal imaging could help growers drastically improve irrigation efficiency in orchards. Read More
Farm Management
April 8, 2016
Western Growers’ Center For Innova…
The Western Growers Association sets up a Silicon Valley-like innovation hub — in the heart of farmland. Read More
Nuts
April 6, 2016
Meet The Expert: Mohammad Yaghmour
Mohammad Yaghmour recently joined UCCE as Orchard Systems Advisor for Kern and Kings counties. We caught up with him to find out what he’s most interested in researching further, and what he can bring to the table to help nut growers succeed. Read More
Nuts
April 6, 2016
Almond Growers Key To Solving Bee Loss P…
Experts believe those on the front lines in the battle to save the bees are absolutely critical. Read More
Nuts
March 30, 2016
Meet The New Almond Board Leadership Pro…
We caught up with 2016 program participant Ethan Nicol to find out about his career goals, as well as his thoughts on some of the greatest challenges facing the almond industry. Read More
Nuts
March 30, 2016
Walnut Bot Canker And Blight Management …
Researchers share insight into the latest developments in the treatment and management of Bot canker and blight. Read More
Nuts
March 23, 2016
Wonderful Orchards Removes 10,000 Acres …
The company cites limited water resources and other market factors for the almond removal. Read More
Berries
March 21, 2016
FMC Fungicide Triggers New FRAC Group
Multi-site mode of action classified in new group by Fungicide Resistance Action Committee. Read More
Nuts
March 15, 2016
Annual Walnut Pruning Unnecessary During…
Most walnut orchards are pruned annually during the establishment phase – a costly, laborious endeavor. But, there has been some promising research showing that annual pruning might not be necessary. Read More
Nuts
March 15, 2016
Experts Weigh In On Water Year
While the situation seems to be improving, California still has about 5.5 million acre-feet less surface water storage than average for this time of year. Read More
Food Safety
March 11, 2016
Pistachios Recalled Due To Possible Salm…
Limited number of in-shell and shelled nuts sold under Wonderful label. Read More
[gravityform id="62" title="false" description="false"]