Food Safety’s Cost

During the many discussions regarding food safety in recent years, one recurring theme kept rearing its ugly head: there was no way growers could pass along the costs. After all, growers historically haven’t been able to pass down other costs, such as the rising price of inputs they need to produce quality crops. That’s why the recent news from Dole came like a bolt out of the blue. Beginning April 29, Dole informed its customers, it would be tacking a surcharge of 22¢ per carton to strawberries and vegetables to pay for food safety enhancements.

In a letter signed by Mike Cavallero, president of Dole Fresh Fruit North America, and Eric Schwartz, president of Dole Fresh Vegetables, the company informed its customers that the surcharge was necessary to recoup its investments in enhanced food safety in order to protect consumers. “All of us in the produce industry — growers, shippers, processors, food service operators, brokers, and retailers — took a tremendous hit last year from the spinach E. coli outbreak, both financially and in terms of consumer confidence in the safety of our products,” the letter begins. “In the consumers’ eyes, all of us are in a common arena when it comes to food safety, so we must continue to find ways to restore consumers’ trust and economic health to the industry.”

Dole states that the company took a leadership role in the development of the California Leafy Greens Marketing Agreement, which took effect April 1. The agreement puts a number of Good Agricultural Practices (GAPs) in place. Under the agreement, the California Department of Agriculture does charge a 2¢-per-carton assessment, but that is solely to cover the costs of a new government inspection program. “This 2¢- per-carton assessment is only a fraction of the incremental food safety costs we are incurring,” Dole states, adding that the expenses “are not limited to California or just leafy greens.”

Anatomy of Legislation

Reading and writing on the wall regarding food safety, Florida tomato growers took it upon themselves to approach the state with a mandatory food safety program. The growers were, quite simply, concerned that any food safety scare might turn off consumers to tomatoes, said the manager of the Florida Tomato Committee, Reggie Brown. “The time has basically come,” says Brown. “The industry is better off responding with leadership.”

With growers everywhere pondering the adoption of regulations of their own, AVG decided to take a look at what the legislation entails. Here are the highlights, courtesy of Lisa Lochridge, the director of public affairs for the Florida Fruit & Vegetable Association, which is encouraging all of its members to follow the committee’s lead.

• State regulatory inspections with penalties for violations.

• Annual registration of all locations for all producers, packers, and  re-packers, plus required food safety education courses.

• Stepped-up monitoring and control of the packing process, including required sanitation equipment, pH, and water temperature control to minimize the risk of microorganisms being introduced into the tomato.

• Pest-control programs for insects, birds, and rodents. Also, no domestic animals or other animals would be permitted in areas where tomatoes are packed or handled.

• Extensive record-keeping so products can be traced back from the  point of sale to the point of production.

In addition, the legislation also prohibits:

• Use of irrigation water that is contaminated with animal or human feces.

• Field packing of tomatoes without an approved sanitizing step.

• Use of surface water in packinghouses or other postharvest contact.

In addition, the company states that it is “making substantial investments on our own in enhancements that go beyond the new GAPs and that we believe may eventually become industry benchmarks in the future. We are increasing research funding, increasing field buffer zones, adding field personnel, implementing raw material testing, and implementing RFID tracking of raw materials, among other efforts. These enhancements are not one-time events, but are a part of doing business — ours and yours — for the future.”

Dole’s Not Alone

Dole is not the only grower to begin charging a food safety surcharge. Just weeks before Dole made its announcement, another huge California grower announced it was implementing a similar assessment. Taylor Farms, a large Salinas, CA, vegetable producer, informed its customers it would begin tacking on a 20¢ increase. The increase would apply across the board on all products to all customers, including grocery stores, club chains, and food service outlets.

Large growers like Dole and Taylor have a lot more power, of course, than the average grower. Obviously, it would be a lot more difficult for smaller growers to simply make such an announcement to their customers. However, with all the calls for regulation in the food safety arena in the months since last fall’s E. coli outbreak, change is clearly in the wind.

For example, while a small individual grower might not be able to charge such an assessment, it may be able to as part of a marketing order, as called for in recent federal legislation. Both the Specialty Crop Competition Act of 2007, which was introduced in April, and the EAT Healthy America Act, which was introduced in March, have provisions that allow food safety rules to be used in marketing orders.

Regional, Crop-Specific Challenges

The Florida Fruit & Vegetable Association is encouraging all of its members to join together and follow the lead of organizations such as the Florida Tomato Committee and others in calling for legislation. The food safety regulations in such legislation needs to be tailored for certain segments of the industry, says Lisa Lochridge, the association’s director of public affairs. “They should vary by commodity and region; that just makes common sense,” she says. “There is no ‘one size fits all’ when it comes to standards.”

It’s in growers’ interests to institute such standards, says Lochridge, as any more foodborne pathogen outbreaks could be disastrous for them. “It’s not a new topic, it’s just that there’s greater urgency,” she says, referencing the deadly E. coli outbreak. “Stiffer regulations are going to dominate the discussion.”

Indeed, the E. coli outbreak will have far-ranging changes on the business of producing fruits and vegetables, changes that will forever change the face of the industry. As the Dole letter concludes: “None of us could have predicted the extraordinary events of the past seven months or the position we find ourselves in today"

Leave a Reply

Featured Stories

All Vegetables Stories >All Fruits Stories >All Nuts Stories >All Citrus Stories >

The Latest

TomatoesProduction Reaches An All-Time High For Processing Toma…
August 29, 2014
A record high is predicted for the 2014 processing tomato crop. Read More
CitrusFlorida Department Of Citrus Knocks NPR Piece Over Juic…
August 28, 2014
Agency goes to bat for the industry regarding statement slighting OJ's health benefits. Read More
Disease ControlLate Blight Update Reveals Heightened Activity
August 28, 2014
While several states in the Northeast have confirmed the presence of late blight, the disease has not been reported in North Dakota or Minnesota. Read More
CitrusFlorida Energy Firm Charged Up About Citrus Biomass Pot…
August 28, 2014
Machine called a game-changer when it comes to a cost-effective, efficient way for tree removal and re-purposing. Read More
EquipmentNew Tractors Improve Maneuverability And Operator Contr…
August 28, 2014
The Magnum Rowtrac tractors from Case IH meet growers’ cropping needs through a wide variety of row spacing and belt options.   Read More
NutsCalifornia County Passes Ordinance To Protect Walnut Gr…
August 27, 2014
Verification of ownership needed to complete sales of valuable nuts. Read More
NutsAlmond Growers Hit By Russian Import Limits
August 27, 2014
Growers reflect on changes to export market in light of produce ban. Read More
Farm ManagementLeadership And Management Expert To Speak At California…
August 27, 2014
Daniel Goleman will make presentation at California State University-Fresno. Read More
CitrusNational Scientific Summit On Herbicide Resistant Weeds…
August 27, 2014
Topics to be covered include the economics of proactively managing herbicide resistance, education and outreach efforts, and incentives and regulatory initiatives. Read More
FruitsFlorida Organic Group Dedicated To Serving Growers, Com…
August 27, 2014
Education and development programs are plentiful for interested producers. Read More
VegetablesExperimental Herbicide Technology Blasts Weeds In Rows
August 27, 2014
The technology uses an air compressor to spray corncob grit on both sides of a crop, killing young weeds. Read More
Disease ControlFungal Disease Outbreak Hits Pacific Northwest Vegetabl…
August 27, 2014
An outbreak of blackleg, light leaf spot, and white leaf spot can be significant problems in several vegetable crops.   Read More
CitrusClean Water Conundrum: Ditch The Rule Or Ditch The Myth…
August 26, 2014
Regulation inundation causing a rising tide of confusion for farmers. Read More
BerriesMichigan State University Extension Offers Tips To Prev…
August 26, 2014
Humidity, rainy periods conducive to disease development. Read More
FruitsSpotted Wing Drosophila Populations Rising In Michigan
August 26, 2014
Extension researchers advise berry growers on trapping, salt testing to take stock of pest population. Read More
Apples & PearsNorthwest Pear Crop Estimate Revised Upward
August 26, 2014
Washington and Oregon pear growers forecast a larger size crop than that originally estimated. Read More
VegetablesAgrium Acquires A Controlling Interest In Biotech Compa…
August 26, 2014
The company also acquires stake in Agricen Sciences as part of strategic effort to expand their offering of integrated, next-generation plant health technologies. Read More
Insect ControlCover All Angles When Taking On Threecornered Alfalfa H…
August 25, 2014
Learn how to ID, the survival and spread, and management methods for this insect pest. Read More