Growers Left High & Dry

Growers Left  High & Dry


For years, some California winegrape growers have complained that wineries — who hold all the cards when it comes to their contracts with growers — made them hang their grapes on the vine too long in the pursuit of more intensely flavored wines. “Growers have suffered unnecessarily because of hang time,” says Nat DiBuduo, president of Allied Grape Growers, a cooperative of 500-plus growers. “The wineries would schedule the harvest late; they would just keep holding the growers off, saying that they were waiting until grapes lost their vegetative flavors.”

The growers didn’t like this because most of those contracts called for them to be paid on a tonnage basis, and the longer the grapes would hang past what the growers considered ripe, the more water weight they would lose. If the growers thought they were really producing better fruit, it would have made some sense, but DiBuduo said it did not. “Obviously there’s going to be some raisining,” he says. “You can taste the change when you eat the fresh fruit, so of course you’re going to change the wine quality.”

The issue really got contentious in the late 2000s when growers began to learn that the grapes were so dry that the wineries had difficulty crushing them, to the point that the winemakers had to add water. How could the growers not suspect they were being taken advantage of, says DiBuduo, when the moisture was essentially removed and then replaced. “How is that good for the wine?” he says. “Replacing the natural water to get it through the crusher and destemmer doesn’t make sense.”

No Long-Term Damage Found
A half-dozen years ago, when the controversial issue of extended hang time bubbled over, winegrape growers were concerned that by waiting to harvest grapes past what they considered the optimum time, their vines might be sustaining damage.

The issue came to a head following the relatively small California harvest of 2004, when with overall tonnage already down, growers saw tonnage fall further because of wineries’ mandating increased hang time. The then-president of the California Association of Winegrape Growers, Karen Ross, said it wasn’t fair that in their contracts with wineries structured on a tonnage basis, growers were taking all the risks. Ross, who now heads up the state’s Department of Food and Agriculture, also said growers had concerns about their vineyards’ future.

“Do we really know what (increased hang time) is doing to the long-term health of the vineyard?” she said at the time. “Do we really understand the whole picture regarding the ramifications of what we’re doing?”

Today, Sanliang Gu’s research team has found extended hang time has no impact on the long-term health of the vineyard, at least in warm growing regions. “We’ve never seen a negative effect,” he says, “even on the vineyards we never harvested.”

Gu believes that there were other factors at work in the vineyards of those growers who have seen negative impacts on their vines. In an attempt to produce high-end wines with intense flavors, many growers, especially those in cooler areas such as Napa and Sonoma, stress the vines. “If you’re water-stressing them, that’s a different story, and I suspect that’s what’s happening,” he says. “I don’t believe hang time is as stressful as water stress or nutrient stress.”

He emphasizes that his research was done only in the warm weather growing area of the San Joaquin Valley, and not only was he growing the grapes under “normal” conditions — with no water stress — the region has a longer growing season than cooler areas. That could be a factor in that the vines have more time to recover following harvest. However, as he notes, even the unharvested vines recovered nicely.

Gu believes the vines’ health isn’t adversely affected for the same reason that increased hang time doesn’t produce better wines in warmer climes. “The plants stop sending sugar to the fruit after it reaches 25 Brix,” he says, “so they probably wouldn’t be stressed.”

“Toasting” Raisins

A few years ago, Sanliang Gu, who holds the Ricchiuti Chair of Viticulture Research at California State University-Fresno’s Viticulture and Enology Research Center, got to wondering about this issue, too. He led a research study (See “Research Conclusions At-A-Glance”) into hang time, and sure enough, DiBuduo and his fellow growers were right. However, Gu is quick to note that all his group’s research was done at vineyards in the Fresno area, under very warm growing conditions. That’s part of the reason so much fruit is produced in the Fresno region — tellingly, the Raisin Capital of the World is in nearby Selma — and in fact about two-thirds of the state’s winegrapes are grown in warm weather climates.

Gu found that the growers were absolutely right in their contention that 25 Brix was the upper limit for accumulating sugar. Wineries were calling for 28 to 30 Brix, mandating the fruit hang into fall, but they were only getting it because of dehydration, he says. “There’s a reason why the raisin growers have their fruit out then,” he says. “We’re not just hanging fruit on the vine, we are toasting it.”

Gu is quick to add he’s not a wine expert, and his conclusions are based on fruit quality. He notes that at that same time, in late September, it begins to cool in other growing areas of the state, such as Napa and Sonoma. “Hanging fruit on the vine in cooler regions is totally different,” he emphasizes.

Less Color, Mouthfeel

But in warm weather regions, besides dehydration, hang time can cause other fruit quality problems, he found. For example, pH is dramatically increased. He found the pH of grapes harvested in late September as well as early October could be 4.0 or greater, and above 3.8, vintners can actually have trouble making wine. “The wine gets unstable and bacteria can start to grow, which will of course ruin the wine,” he explains. “That’s what stopped a lot of winemakers from demanding hang time.”

Two other desirable components were decreased through increased hang time: anthocyanins and tannins. Anthocyanins give red wine its color, and perhaps it comes as no surprise, but the level of extractable tannins dropped to near zero as the fruit began to raisin. As for tannins, the optimal temperature for formation is 75°F, well below the temperatures found in the southern San Joaquin Valley on an average September day. Tannins give wine mouthfeel, the quality that make people refer to a wine as a “big” Cabernet Sauvignon. “It’s hard to get enough tannins in the valley, because the high temperatures ‘burn’ the tannins out of the grapes,” says Gu. “Increasing heat through hang time actually reduces tannins.”

As for DiBuduo, who serves on American/Western Fruit Grower’s Editorial Advisory Board, he says the hang time problem has lessened in the past couple years because consumers have been turning away from those more intense, high-alcohol wines. He’s obviously happy that Gu’s research cleared up the issue, though, and highlights its value. “Dr. Gu’s research has given us a leg to stand on. It’s like ‘Hey, we told you so.’ This shows the value of research on cultural practices so we can improve the quality of our fruit,” he says. “We need to support the American Vineyard Foundation and the National Grape and Wine Initiative, because winegrape growers in general are not funding enough research for our future.”

Research Conclusions At-A-Glance

Here are the conclusions of a study led by California State University Fresno Professor Sanliang Gu titled “Influence of Berry Hydration on Berry Fresh Weight and Fruit Composition During Hang Time in Cabernet Sauvignon Grapes in a Warmer Region.” Note: the study’s co-authors were Yulin Fang, Guoqiang Du, Erik Mallea, Sean Jacobs, and Robert Wample.

- Berries without visual shriveling had similar weight and composition regardless of hang time, irrigation, and cluster location in the canopy.

- Shriveling berries had higher Brix, TA, and pH but reduced fruit fresh weight.

- Shriveling berries had much lower model wine extractable anthocyanins, phenolics, and tannins.

- Berry shriveling was associated with a greater number of dead pedicels.

- Berry shriveling associated with longer hang time reduced yield and fruit quality in warm regions.

Leave a Reply

Featured Stories

All Vegetables Stories >All Fruits Stories >All Nuts Stories >All Citrus Stories >

The Latest

TomatoesProduction Reaches An All-Time High For Processing Toma…
August 29, 2014
A record high is predicted for the 2014 processing tomato crop. Read More
CitrusFlorida Department Of Citrus Knocks NPR Piece Over Juic…
August 28, 2014
Agency goes to bat for the industry regarding statement slighting OJ's health benefits. Read More
Disease ControlLate Blight Update Reveals Heightened Activity
August 28, 2014
While several states in the Northeast have confirmed the presence of late blight, the disease has not been reported in North Dakota or Minnesota. Read More
CitrusFlorida Energy Firm Charged Up About Citrus Biomass Pot…
August 28, 2014
Machine called a game-changer when it comes to a cost-effective, efficient way for tree removal and re-purposing. Read More
EquipmentNew Tractors Improve Maneuverability And Operator Contr…
August 28, 2014
The Magnum Rowtrac tractors from Case IH meet growers’ cropping needs through a wide variety of row spacing and belt options.   Read More
NutsCalifornia County Passes Ordinance To Protect Walnut Gr…
August 27, 2014
Verification of ownership needed to complete sales of valuable nuts. Read More
NutsAlmond Growers Hit By Russian Import Limits
August 27, 2014
Growers reflect on changes to export market in light of produce ban. Read More
Farm ManagementLeadership And Management Expert To Speak At California…
August 27, 2014
Daniel Goleman will make presentation at California State University-Fresno. Read More
CitrusNational Scientific Summit On Herbicide Resistant Weeds…
August 27, 2014
Topics to be covered include the economics of proactively managing herbicide resistance, education and outreach efforts, and incentives and regulatory initiatives. Read More
FruitsFlorida Organic Group Dedicated To Serving Growers, Com…
August 27, 2014
Education and development programs are plentiful for interested producers. Read More
VegetablesExperimental Herbicide Technology Blasts Weeds In Rows
August 27, 2014
The technology uses an air compressor to spray corncob grit on both sides of a crop, killing young weeds. Read More
Disease ControlFungal Disease Outbreak Hits Pacific Northwest Vegetabl…
August 27, 2014
An outbreak of blackleg, light leaf spot, and white leaf spot can be significant problems in several vegetable crops.   Read More
CitrusClean Water Conundrum: Ditch The Rule Or Ditch The Myth…
August 26, 2014
Regulation inundation causing a rising tide of confusion for farmers. Read More
BerriesMichigan State University Extension Offers Tips To Prev…
August 26, 2014
Humidity, rainy periods conducive to disease development. Read More
FruitsSpotted Wing Drosophila Populations Rising In Michigan
August 26, 2014
Extension researchers advise berry growers on trapping, salt testing to take stock of pest population. Read More
Apples & PearsNorthwest Pear Crop Estimate Revised Upward
August 26, 2014
Washington and Oregon pear growers forecast a larger size crop than that originally estimated. Read More
VegetablesAgrium Acquires A Controlling Interest In Biotech Compa…
August 26, 2014
The company also acquires stake in Agricen Sciences as part of strategic effort to expand their offering of integrated, next-generation plant health technologies. Read More
Insect ControlCover All Angles When Taking On Threecornered Alfalfa H…
August 25, 2014
Learn how to ID, the survival and spread, and management methods for this insect pest. Read More