Chemical Companies Win Appeal On Pesticide Lawsuit

Courtroom ruling with gavel

The 4th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals found for the plaintiffs in Dow, Makhteshim and Cheminova  v. National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS). The first biological opinion (BiOp) issued by NMFS following the Washington Toxics Coalition lawsuit over the potential effects of pesticides on salmon is arbitrary and capricious.

The BiOp covered three insecticides, chlorpyrifos, diazinon, and malathion. The appeals court reversed a lower court decision by concluding that the BiOp was not the product of reasoned decision making. According to the court, “NMFS failed to explain or support critical assumptions in its opinion.” The court vacated the BiOp and remanded the case to the district court with instructions to remand it to NMFS for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.

A key factor in today’s decision was the NMFS’s failure to consider the economic feasibility of its proposed one-size-fits-all buffer zones. According to the court, “NMFS relied on a selection of data, tests, and standards that did not always appear to be logical, obvious, or even rational.”

“This decision is a huge step for sound science and reasoned decision-making,” said Heather Hansen, executive director of Washington Friends of Farms & Forests. “We are thankful that the court recognized the poor process NMFS used in compiling this BiOp. We are hopeful that future actions will be guided by this decision.”

Topics:

Leave a Reply

Crop Protection Stories
UF/IFAS researcher looks after pigs on weed control duty
More VegetablesGot Weeds? Perhaps Pigs Can Help
July 27, 2015
Old-time crop protection method using hogs now being tested by UF/IFAS researchers. Read More
downy mildew symptoms on basil
Disease ControlRed Lights Slow Down Growth Of Downy Mildew On Basil
July 22, 2015
University of Florida scientists say the technology may help growers manage the disease and reduce chemical inputs. Read More
Bacterial wilt of curcurbits
CucurbitsWin The War Against Bacterial Wilt Of Cucurbits
July 22, 2015
Learn how to identify, the survival and spread, as well as management methods of this vegetable disease. Read More
Crop ProtectionRegional Integrated Pest Management Grants Reduced Pest Risks In The West
July 22, 2015
The program created tools and training information designed for Western growers. Read More
Disease ControlStone Fruit Rots Rampant In East
July 21, 2015
The incidents of fruit rots in both sweet and tart cherries and peaches and nectarines are quite high in Pennsylvania Read More
UF/IFAS scientists Edward Evans and Jonathan Crane study diseased avocados in a South Florida grove.
Disease ControlDeadly Disease Cutting Down Florida Avocado Trees Likely To Push Up Prices
July 17, 2015
The economic impacts of laurel wilt disease management costly for domestic producers. Read More
Sweet CornDow AgroSciences Reveals Name Of New Residual Corn Herbicide
July 15, 2015
Dow AgroSciences announced July 14 that its new corn herbicide, previously referred to as GF-3471, will be named Resicore™ herbicide. Read More
The Latest
Bill Stoneman
Crop ProtectionFormer BPIA Head Relishes Challenge Of New Consulting R…
July 28, 2015
JET Harvest Solutions taps Bill Stoneman for his bounty of biocontrol experience. Read More
Crop ProtectionRegional Integrated Pest Management Grants Reduced Pest…
July 22, 2015
The program created tools and training information designed for Western growers. Read More
Crop ProtectionClue Into Chemigation Best Practices
July 15, 2015
Monitoring performance and quick repairs are critical to successful applications. Read More
Crop ProtectionNew Egg Cage System Could Increase Ladybug’s Bioc…
July 13, 2015
A specialized insect cage system developed by USDA scientists could improve the prospects of mass rearing the pink spotted lady Read More
Crop ProtectionIR-4 Call For Nominations For “SOAR” Award
July 10, 2015
The IR-4 Project, a resource that supplies pest management tools for specialty crop growers by developing research data to support Read More
Crop ProtectionEarly Blight And Septoria Leaf Spot Rampant On Pennsylv…
July 8, 2015
According to a news release from Penn State University, early blight and Septoria leaf spot are present in Pennsylvania tomato Read More
Crop ProtectionDowny Mildew Reported In Ohio Cucumber Fields
July 8, 2015
According to a disease update from Ohio State University Extension, downy mildew was reported in cucumbers on farms in West Read More
Crop ProtectionZeal SC Miticide Now Registered With Liquid Formulation
June 26, 2015
Valent U.S.A. Corporation announced that Zeal SC Miticide has been registered by the EPA with a new liquid formulation that Read More
Crop ProtectionStay A Step Ahead Of Weeds
June 26, 2015
Weed control can be a tricky and costly task made all the more difficult by herbicide resistance and the push Read More
money down the drain
CitrusGovernor’s Budget Veto Likely To Shutter UF/IFAS …
June 25, 2015
A $180,000 increase, plus another $720,000 in funding for program gone in the stroke of a pen. Read More
Crop ProtectionDowny Mildew Makes Early Appearance In Michigan Cucumbe…
June 23, 2015
An alert sent by Michigan State University (MSU) Extension confirms the presence of downy mildew on cucumber leaves in Michigan. Read More
BerriesCaptan Gold 4L Fungicide Now Registered In California
June 16, 2015
ADAMA has received EPA approval for Captan Gold 4L liquid fungicide for use on strawberries, tree fruits, and other specialty Read More
infrared image showing the difference between using crop termination fumigation in the field and not
Crop ProtectionMaximizing Nematode Management In Vegetables
June 12, 2015
Crop termination is the foundation of mitigating the soil pests for the following season. Read More
Crop ProtectionNew Chart Helps Growers Choose The Best Cover Crop
June 9, 2015
USDA scientists have developed a Cover Crop Chart that helps growers determine the best cover crop to meet their management Read More
Bagrada bug
Crop ProtectionBagrada Bug Has The Potential To Spread Throughout The …
June 9, 2015
The bagrada bug has moved into South Texas and has the potential to move to other areas of the U.S., Read More
Guava Fruit Fly specimen
CitrusLos Angeles County Under Quarantine Following Guava Fru…
June 9, 2015
A portion of Los Angeles County has been placed under quarantine for the guava fruit fly (GFF) following the detection Read More
CitrusNealta Miticide Receives Registration In California
June 2, 2015
Nealta miticide from BASF has received registration for use in California. Nealta delivers long-lasting control of spider mites at all Read More
Crop ProtectionSmall Parasite May Contribute To Declines In Honey Bee …
June 2, 2015
A single-celled parasite may be infecting bee larvae. Read More