Find Out How E. Coli And Salmonella Work In Spinach And Lettuce

Research on E. coli and Salmonella in lettuce and spinach will help industry make better decisions on growing practices, risk reduction, and regulatory and food safety policies.
Research on E. coli and Salmonella in lettuce and spinach will help industry make better decisions on growing practices, risk reduction, and regulatory and food safety policies.

Spinach and lettuce are high-value leafy vegetable crops that are grown extensively in California. Because these crops have been subject to periodic E. coli and Salmonella contamination, it is critical to develop practical information on how these bacteria operate in these specific cropping systems. Prior to our multi-year study, few researchers examined the ecology and biology of E. coli and Salmonella under real-world leafy green production environments, and no such studies were conducted in coastal California.

The University of California Cooperative Extension facility in the Salinas Valley enabled researchers to study E. coli and Salmonella under commercial coastal California conditions. Applied field-oriented research is also needed so that industry and regulators can make informed decisions on growing practices, risk reduction and audit compliance metrics, and regulatory food safety policies for the field. The research program was designed to provide answers to several questions regarding human pathogenic bacteria in the field.

1. If bacteria-contaminated water or organic material is in the field at planting, will germinating seedlings become infested? Will bacteria end up on the harvested commodity?
Various E. coli strains applied as water-based sprays (simulating irrigation events) or mixed with sand and placed in mesh bags (simulating point sources of contamination) did not survive in soil for long periods of time under commercial growing conditions in the Salinas Valley. Spray or bag inoculum was not recovered, via direct plating, from the lettuce or spinach plants growing through inoculated soil or next to bag inoculum.

2. Does “internalization” of human pathogenic bacteria take place in leafy green crops grown under real-world field conditions?
“Internalization” is the phenomenon in which plant roots absorb microorganisms and transport them into above-ground leaves and stems. Some laboratory and growth chamber studies indicate leafy green plants can absorb E. coli in this way, resulting in contaminated leaves that could be eaten by the consumer.

We established trials on a commercial farm to investigate internalization under field conditions. When various generic E. coli strains were inoculated onto spinach roots by using a subsurface drip irrigation system, the above ground foliage did not test positive for the E. coli strains when using direct plating methods.

Surface sterilizing plants with mercuric chloride followed by enrichment culture resulted in only one of 80 plants being positive for our generic E. coli strains. Based on this experiment, we believe that internalization of E. coli does not occur in leafy vegetables grown under field conditions.

3. What is the likelihood of bacterial survival if mature leafy green crops are contaminated and are then disked into the soil?
Trials were established on a commercial farm to investigate E. coli survival on crop residues under field conditions. Lettuce or spinach was grown by the farmer.

At crop maturity, replicated blocks were inoculated with high levels of generic E. coli as liquid inoculum or attenuated E. coli O157:H7 as liquid inoculum. Immediately following the foliar inoculation sprays, the plants in each plot were incorporated into the soil with a tractor and disk. No other field production steps were taken until the field was irrigated later in the summer.

Both inoculated strains were recovered from the soil and crop residue samples. Bacterial populations generally increased within the first week after inoculation and then gradually declined. However, in the undisturbed field we recovered E. coli from soil for a long period of time, more than 85 days post-inoculation (dpi). Despite an additional application of water at 95 days dpi and disking at 103 dpi, bacterial numbers did not reach the limit of detection even after 105 dpi. Recovery of attenuated O157:H7 was lower, overall, than recovery of generic E. coli.

4. Since bacteria apparently can survive on crop residues, what can be done in the field to enhance bacterial degradation and decline?
Other studies were conducted to see if production practices could enhance death and decline of foodborne pathogens on lettuce or spinach crop residues. We simulated the contamination of lettuce by inoculating mature, commercially grown crops with generic E. coli and Salmonella. Lettuce plots were then differentially treated by mowing, ring-rolling, or leaving the contaminated crop undisturbed.

After a holding period, the contaminated crops were disked into the soil. One set of plots, including all the soil treatments, was subject to an irrigation treatment one week after disking. E. coli and Salmonella survival was monitored by sampling soil plus crop residue beginning with the day of incorporation and then at 1, 6, 11, 20, and 48 days post incorporation.

After 21 days, a second lettuce crop was planted into the original plots and plants were sampled at thinning stage (27 days after emergence) to evaluate for transference of the inoculated strains to this replanted crop. Following incorporation of the first crop, target bacteria were quantifiable only in a few plots from the first sampling date, but were recovered by sample enrichment from most plots at all sampling dates up to 48 days after inoculation. No second crop lettuce plants in any of the plots tested positive for E. coli, and only a few second crop plants tested positive for Salmonella. Leaving the crop residue above ground and exposed to the sun and wind may help in decreasing bacterial survival.

This research was conducted by Steven Koike, Trevor Suslow, and Michael Cahn, all of the University of California. They acknowledge the support of the Center for Produce Safety, California Leafy Greens Research Board, and the leafy greens industry in California.

Topics: , , , ,

Leave a Reply

Food Safety Stories

Food SafetyUSDA Issues Updates To Food Safety Modernization Act
September 19, 2014
Water testing, definition of applicable farms based on produce sales among clarifications to proposed rules. Read More
CitrusFDA Announces Cooperative Agreement To Implement National Produce Safety Rule
September 17, 2014
Agreement will provide information to help plan and carry out the produce safety rule in partnership with state regulatory agencies. Read More
Food SafetyBe Ready For Food Safety Rules
September 5, 2014
Stay one step ahead of the food safety rules but anticipating the changes you will need to make on your farm. Read More
Crop ProtectionMost Fresh California Produce Has Little/No Detectable Pesticides
September 4, 2014
State Department of Pesticide Regulation finds that 95% of produce was in compliance. Read More
Food SafetyLinkfresh ERP Technology Provides A Comprehensive Traceability Solution For Growers
August 12, 2014
ERP technology from Linkfresh is Produce Traceability Initiative compliant, and helps growers streamline their traceability plan from field to fork. Read More
Food SafetyTraceability Software Offers Flexible System For Users
August 4, 2014
The software, available from Schoneman Inc., provides growers with the tools they need to remain PTI compliant. Read More
Food SafetyTraceability And Food Safety: Are You Prepared? [Opinion]
August 1, 2014
My relatives are asking questions about the safety of your produce. Help me make sure I have a great story to tell. Read More

The Latest

Food SafetyUSDA Issues Updates To Food Safety Modernization Act
September 19, 2014
Water testing, definition of applicable farms based on produce sales among clarifications to proposed rules. Read More
CitrusFDA Announces Cooperative Agreement To Implement Nation…
September 17, 2014
Agreement will provide information to help plan and carry out the produce safety rule in partnership with state regulatory agencies. Read More
Food SafetyBe Ready For Food Safety Rules
September 5, 2014
Stay one step ahead of the food safety rules but anticipating the changes you will need to make on your farm. Read More
Crop ProtectionMost Fresh California Produce Has Little/No Detectable …
September 4, 2014
State Department of Pesticide Regulation finds that 95% of produce was in compliance. Read More
Food SafetyLinkfresh ERP Technology Provides A Comprehensive Trace…
August 12, 2014
ERP technology from Linkfresh is Produce Traceability Initiative compliant, and helps growers streamline their traceability plan from field to fork. Read More
Food SafetyTraceability Software Offers Flexible System For Users
August 4, 2014
The software, available from Schoneman Inc., provides growers with the tools they need to remain PTI compliant. Read More
Food SafetyWawona Packing Expands Recall Of Stone Fruit
August 4, 2014
Dates extended to July 17 added as precaution of possible listeria contamination of packed peaches, plums, nectarines, and plots. Read More
Food SafetyTraceability And Food Safety: Are You Prepared? [Opinio…
August 1, 2014
My relatives are asking questions about the safety of your produce. Help me make sure I have a great story to tell. Read More
Food SafetyU.S. And Mexico Form Partnership To Strengthen Produce …
July 29, 2014
The two countries agree to work toward strengthening their cooperation on the pressing matter. Read More
Food Safety9 Traceability Tools To Keep You Compliant
July 24, 2014
With the mounting food safety requirements and increasingly stricter standards from retailers, traceability is not an option for growers wanting to stay competitive. Read More
Food SafetyPacking Company Recalls Stone Fruit For Possible Lister…
July 22, 2014
Peaches, nectarines, plums, and pluots packed in June and July tested positive during internal testing at Wawona Packing Company. Read More
Farm ManagementGMO Debate Worth The Fight [Opinion]
June 20, 2014
Despite barrages against modern agriculture, there is hope. Read More
Farm ManagementFood Safety Water Rules Getting Stricter
June 13, 2014
The Food Safety Modernization Act will prescribe numbers to a once generic standard. Read More
Food SafetyDogs Sniff Out Food-borne Pathogens
May 30, 2014
Man's best friend is being trained to use scent detection to identify contaminated produce. Read More
Food SafetyWestern Institute For Food Safety And Security Strives …
May 30, 2014
The Western Institute for Food Safety and Security is focusing on rural communities and making them aware of threats to crops or livestock. Read More
Apples & PearsNon-GMO Fruit Labels Send The Wrong Message To Consumer…
April 29, 2014
Consumers don't equate fresh fruit and genetically modification technology. GMO-free labels confuse the issue and create fear where there should be none. Read More
Farm ManagementGrowers Can Control Our Industry’s Public Image […
April 3, 2014
Negative portayals of ag in the media aside, the real threat to the public image of the grower is growers themselves. Read More
Food SafetyStudy Shows Treating Spinach With Viruses Reduces E. Co…
April 2, 2014
A Purdue University study shows that treating food products with bacteriophages, which are viruses that kill bacteria, may significantly lower concentrations of E. coli. Read More