Industry Groups Blast Latest “Dirty Dozen” List

Shoppers in the produce section

The Produce Marketing Association (PMA), the Alliance for Food and Farming, and other industry organizations have been quick to stand in opposition to the Environmental Working Group’s latest “Dirty Dozen” list, released this week.

The following statement comes directly from PMA president Bryan Silbermann:

“The Environmental Working Group (EWG) has just released its 2013 ‘Dirty Dozen/Clean Fifteen’ shopper’s guide. Industry members all along the produce supply chain can take steps to help counter EWG’s false claims, including directing consumers to the Alliance for Food and Farming’s www.safefruitsandveggies.com where consumers can learn the facts.

The Alliance’s website is a consumer resource for science-based information about the safety of organic and conventional produce backed by expertise in toxicology, pharmacology, risk assessment, and nutrition. On the site, interested consumers can also put residues in proper perspective by using the eye-opening Pesticide Residue Calculator.

Here are additional suggestions for setting this important record straight with your customers and consumers:
• Communicate the truth about pesticides by using the factual information found on the Safe Fruits and Veggies website on packaging, in-store signage, websites, social platforms, dietitian newsletters, and even on menus.
• Educate people about the importance of eating more fruits and vegetables, not less, for better health; Produce for Better Health Foundation’s www.fruitsandveggiesmorematters.com is a terrific resource.
• Advise people to ‘Just Wash It’ with water if concerned about pesticide residues, guidance that’s based on government recommendations.
• Share stories about growers’ farming practices and food safety commitment to give consumers the complete picture behind their food.

Because PMA believes in the business of informing consumers and upholding the industry’s commitment to providing safe produce, we must set the Dirty Dozen record straight. This is also why PMA remains one of the Alliance’s largest financial supporters and I proudly serve as vice chair of its board of directors. Our support empowers industry to counter misinformation about pesticide residues on fresh produce with science — the same foundation we use to continuously improve food safety.”

Topics: ,

Leave a Reply

4 comments on “Industry Groups Blast Latest “Dirty Dozen” List

  1. Said the mouthpiece of the group who wants to protects it's own farming methods. Those that want to believe the produce marketing association, are free to do so. Those that would choose to reduce their exposure to conventional pesticides can use the EWG's list to know which fruits and veggies to buy organic or local where they can inquire about the farmers own practices. Just because a government mouthpiece sets a standard that is "safe" does not necessarily mean consumers will trust it. Especially when government entities will just change the standards whenever they can not be met or when they can not be met feasibly. A good case in point is trace radiation in foods. The NRC upped the "safe" limit of radioactive contamination of foods by over 1000% after Fukushima. So the new "safe" is just as "safe" as the old standard. Many people no longer trust large marketing companies who are paid and supported by those companies who stand to profit by what they say. The same is true of many government agencies because the people working at those agencies got their positions by using money from the same companies who have interest in the policies be made that favor them. So what is a consumer to do? An independent group that is NOT linked to ANY company or government body that has a bone to pick is who I would trust. They would be the only impartial observers. The EWG may not be 100% impartial, but they list the fruits and veggies that MAY have the most potential for pesticide residue. If you had two glasses of water, one with no/undetectable levels of contaminants and one with "safe" levels of contaminants, which will you choose? The government says they are both perfectly safe. MOST people will choose the one with FEWER contaminants. Until the PMA stops looking like a mouthpiece for the big producers, the EWG lists will be given weight, whether the PMA likes it or not.

  2. You forgot to mention that the PMA is responsible for killing Kennedy. The glass of water reference is completely absurd…..define "contaminants". "Organic" farmers have had their share of "contaminants", we should not forget Germany 2011 where 50 people died and over 4300 were sickened.And the large marketing companies are really just us little guys pooling our money so our voices will be heard.If you look at EWG budget it is over $6,000,000.00 and they have received grants of over $23,000,000.00. Just look at their board of directors and biggest donors, they have huge investments in Canadian farms. One could surmise that if American agriculture fails the folks invested in Canadian agriculture might make a buck or two. I just love folks that get on their high horse and preach down to the rest of us plebeians.

    1. Dave, which Kennedy?

      I see nothing in the PMA response regarding the underlying assertions of the dirty dozen; just lots of ways to obfuscate and confuse the consumer with industry “fact” web sites and PR spin. If you, the PMA and their ilk have any science (independent, non industry funded research please) to refute the EWG please share it with us.

      As for “… guidance that’s based on government recommendations.” I consider that a warning label, not a vote of confidence.

  3. Dave, The "outbreak" which you refer to Germany in 2011 had ZERO positive proof that it was an organic farm that caused the problems. Tests on the farm could not find ANY contamination. It is MORE likely that the sprouts were contaminted AFTER they left the farm. The outbreak of e-coli however would NOT be limited or more likely on an organic farm. It also has NOTHING to do with the dirty dozen list which deals with chemicals contaminents. Hence my reference to water with contaminents in them. I did NOT call the PMA or it's proposals a conspiracy theory. They are arguing that conventional produce is SAFE. Even the EWG admits that in it's first two paragraphs, that is IF you read the article. They then go on to state that the list is composed of those crops which have the "highest" levels of residual chemicals and suggests consumers seek sources with LESS contaminents. I find NOTHING wrong with this assertion. What problem do y ou have with a consumer who wants to have LESS potential contaminements in their food. Part of the problem is a few conventional producers who put product that exceeds the MRL into the marketplace are not punished by the FEDS and other regulatory agencies. This leads to a large drop in consumer trust in both government as a watchdog and in conventional producers being trusted. Organic agriculture by defintion uses LESS chemicals so it is easy to turn to. Look at the largest milk marketing board. They want the FDA to allow the addition of Aspartame to milk without listing it on the label. Actions like these paint ALL conventional producers with a very negative brush. Some consumers will just abandone conventional products. My father ALWAYS poo-poo's organic and local producers until he read about that in the newspaper. They now only buy organic milk and I have seen other organic produce showing up in their home, at least until our own produce is in season. Trust in an industry takes a LONG time to establish and very little time to destroy.

Food Safety Stories

Food SafetyLinkfresh ERP Technology Provides A Comprehensive Traceability Solution For Growers
August 12, 2014
ERP technology from Linkfresh is Produce Traceability Initiative compliant, and helps growers streamline their traceability plan from field to fork. Read More
Food SafetyTraceability Software Offers Flexible System For Users
August 4, 2014
The software, available from Schoneman Inc., provides growers with the tools they need to remain PTI compliant. Read More
Food SafetyTraceability And Food Safety: Are You Prepared? [Opinion]
August 1, 2014
My relatives are asking questions about the safety of your produce. Help me make sure I have a great story to tell. Read More
Food SafetyU.S. And Mexico Form Partnership To Strengthen Produce Safety
July 29, 2014
The two countries agree to work toward strengthening their cooperation on the pressing matter. Read More
Farm ManagementGMO Debate Worth The Fight [Opinion]
June 20, 2014
Despite barrages against modern agriculture, there is hope. Read More
Farm ManagementFood Safety Water Rules Getting Stricter
June 13, 2014
The Food Safety Modernization Act will prescribe numbers to a once generic standard. Read More
Food SafetyDogs Sniff Out Food-borne Pathogens
May 30, 2014
Man's best friend is being trained to use scent detection to identify contaminated produce. Read More

The Latest

Food SafetyLinkfresh ERP Technology Provides A Comprehensive Trace…
August 12, 2014
ERP technology from Linkfresh is Produce Traceability Initiative compliant, and helps growers streamline their traceability plan from field to fork. Read More
Food SafetyTraceability Software Offers Flexible System For Users
August 4, 2014
The software, available from Schoneman Inc., provides growers with the tools they need to remain PTI compliant. Read More
Food SafetyWawona Packing Expands Recall Of Stone Fruit
August 4, 2014
Dates extended to July 17 added as precaution of possible listeria contamination of packed peaches, plums, nectarines, and plots. Read More
Food SafetyTraceability And Food Safety: Are You Prepared? [Opinio…
August 1, 2014
My relatives are asking questions about the safety of your produce. Help me make sure I have a great story to tell. Read More
Food SafetyU.S. And Mexico Form Partnership To Strengthen Produce …
July 29, 2014
The two countries agree to work toward strengthening their cooperation on the pressing matter. Read More
Food SafetyPacking Company Recalls Stone Fruit For Possible Lister…
July 22, 2014
Peaches, nectarines, plums, and pluots packed in June and July tested positive during internal testing at Wawona Packing Company. Read More
Farm ManagementGMO Debate Worth The Fight [Opinion]
June 20, 2014
Despite barrages against modern agriculture, there is hope. Read More
Farm ManagementFood Safety Water Rules Getting Stricter
June 13, 2014
The Food Safety Modernization Act will prescribe numbers to a once generic standard. Read More
Food SafetyDogs Sniff Out Food-borne Pathogens
May 30, 2014
Man's best friend is being trained to use scent detection to identify contaminated produce. Read More
Food SafetyWestern Institute For Food Safety And Security Strives …
May 30, 2014
The Western Institute for Food Safety and Security is focusing on rural communities and making them aware of threats to crops or livestock. Read More
Apples & PearsNon-GMO Fruit Labels Send The Wrong Message To Consumer…
April 29, 2014
Consumers don't equate fresh fruit and genetically modification technology. GMO-free labels confuse the issue and create fear where there should be none. Read More
Farm ManagementGrowers Can Control Our Industry’s Public Image […
April 3, 2014
Negative portayals of ag in the media aside, the real threat to the public image of the grower is growers themselves. Read More
Food SafetyStudy Shows Treating Spinach With Viruses Reduces E. Co…
April 2, 2014
A Purdue University study shows that treating food products with bacteriophages, which are viruses that kill bacteria, may significantly lower concentrations of E. coli. Read More
Farm ManagementTap Into Time-Saving Software For Food Safety’s S…
April 1, 2014
A GenNext Grower takes the reins on implementing a program to accurately track and maintain logs from the field to the packing shed. Read More
CitrusOld Trick Shines New Light On Citrus Food Safety
March 21, 2014
Researchers are taking a close look at the potential of using ultraviolet LEDs on the packing line. Read More
CitrusOpinion: When It Comes To GMOs, Sentiment Often Outweig…
March 18, 2014
Florida Grower editor Frank Giles says it's time to dumb down the message on the current and future state of food production. Read More
CucurbitsFDA Officer Reviews Deadly Salmonella Outbreak And Offe…
March 10, 2014
FDA officer Michael Mahovic reviews the findings from Chamberlain Farms’ 2012 outbreak and provides food safety pointers. Read More
Apples & PearsMichigan Man Sentenced To Prison After Selling Sweet Ci…
March 4, 2014
First felony conviction under Michigan’s state food law; owner charged with willful misbranding and adulteration of food products. Read More