Public Policy Decisions And The Influence Of Dangerous Data [Opinion]

Over the past year, a series of actions by EPA have shown an agencywide outlook that does not rely on solid science but appears to be bending to popular opinion. In the nutrition world, reliance on popular data that is less robust has caused confusion among consumers, as experts first recommended a low-fat diet and are now backpedaling.

As vegetable growers, you know that scientific data on soil, nutrients, water efficiency, and growth plays a critical role in healthy crop production and output. Scientific data also should be the basis for deciding when to approve new pesticides, alter their indicated uses, or remove them from the market. However, the type of data being used for influential decisions by EPA is a cause for concern for growers of vegetables and is an issue the National Potato Council takes seriously.

How Studies Differ
First, it is important to understand the differences in types of research studies and the data provided as they affect your business and policy decisions made by the government. Epidemiology (Epi) studies, also known as observational studies, are used to examine what risk factors (or exposures) are associated with an increased or decreased risk that a person will develop a disease. They rely on data collection via recall methods or via surveys/interviews.

On the other end of the spectrum are laboratory and clinical studies, which can be done by directly collecting cell samples from live animal or human subjects. A clinical trial is any research study that prospectively assigns human participants or groups of humans to one or more health-related interventions to evaluate the effects on health outcomes. Clinical observations are the gold standard in determining causality. An Epi study shows only an association and the observations relate primarily to groups of people.

In the past few years, Epi studies have been the basis for associating potato intake with certain health problems like diabetes and obesity. These studies are observational and do not actively involve a control group and other clinical measures, and they often get misinterpreted by news outlets who need big headlines. When the results are sensationalized and applied too broadly, the studies are publicly given more significance than is scientifically justified.

Relying largely on Epi data is troublesome as it does not carry the weight of studies specifically designed to look at clinical effects. Once clinical data is available, dietary advice is likely to change, which confuses consumers and creates conflicting messages.

Growers should be aware they are directly affected by Epi data when EPA evaluates insecticides for their effect(s) on human health. In a case where EPA is seeking to revoke the tolerances for an organophosphate product, one or two Epi studies are being used to supplant the findings of hundreds of animal clinical studies that supported the safety of the product. This could lead to the removal of the product from the market. To make matters worse, in this example, the raw data from the Epi studies is not available for review by the scientific community.

For growers, it could mean one less tool to combat crop damage when a pesticide is banned without a credible scientific review. For consumers, it can mean a more limited food supply and higher prices.

A Rush To Judgment
In a related move, EPA released the endangered species effects determination for three chemicals in May, including chlorpyrifos, and opened the docket for public comment. The comment deadline was short, ignoring the fact that accompanying documents requiring comment included more than 1,200 pages of text. This suggests EPA is rushing through the regulatory process without giving stakeholders enough time to review and without properly weighing the huge amount of data. Again, this is a cause for concern.

NPC has gone on record regarding the need for sound scientific principles in the regulatory process. When clinical studies are available, they should be given priority by federal agencies, policy review panels, and government experts. Just as solid data leads to a better crop, it leads to the best decision-making when changing public policy.

Topics: ,

Leave a Reply

Crop Protection Stories
Citrus
October 9, 2017
(We Won’t Back Down … ) Stand Your Ground for Agriculture
You don’t have to be a super hero, rock star, or award-winning scientist to aid farming. You can help by supporting professionalism in fields. Read More
Greenhouse structure damage at SWFREC in Immokalee
Citrus
October 6, 2017
Complications Persist as Florida Growers Pick up After Irma
Ground zero perspective reveals how citrus and vegetable producers are facing different, daunting challenges in wake of destructive storm. Read More
pressure rinsing empty pesticide container
CEU Series
October 1, 2017
CEU Series: Mix and Load Pesticides Safely
Caution used during preparation stages are worth your time and effort. Read More
Crop Protection
September 27, 2017
AMVAC Expands Non-Crop Business by Acquiring OHP
Transaction to facilitate market access in the greenhouse and nursery markets. Read More
Sweet potato weevil
Insect Control
September 25, 2017
Prevent Sweet Potato Weevil From Giving You the Slip
Learn how to identify, the survival and spread, as well as management methods for this insect pest. Read More
Whiteflies on a leaf
Insect Control
September 20, 2017
Whitefly Troubles Go From Bad to Worse in Florida
Growers should have a plan for managing the pest from beginning to end of season. Read More
Bacterial wilt symptoms on blueberry leaves
Berries
September 20, 2017
Getting to the Bottom of Bacterial Wilt in Blueberries
Prolific plant pathogen now presenting a new challenge for Florida producers and researchers. Read More
Fruits
September 19, 2017
EPA Mulls Restricting Dicamba Use
Proposal is a part of agency’s focus on reducing herbicide injury in vulnerable crops. Read More
Laurel wilt-damaged avocado tree leaves
Disease Control
September 15, 2017
Scientist Uncovers Chilling Side of Deadly Avocado Disease
Lab tests indicate laurel wilt pathogen grows faster in the fall and winter. Read More
Biocontrols Conference
September 13, 2017
Get Better Results From Your Biopesticide Program
Softer crop protection programs are becoming a must in specialty crop production. Growers who aren’t learning more about their options Read More
Torn field plastic and drip tubing thanks to Irma
Citrus
September 13, 2017
Florida Farmers Digging out From Impacts of Irma
Damage reports flood in from the field following monster storm, and it's not pretty. Read More
Biocontrols Conference
September 11, 2017
The Grower’s Take: Citrus, HLB, and Biological Control
Uncle Matt’s Organic orange juice brand has enjoyed steady growth since its 2002 inception. The brand’s success is due to Read More
Insect Control
September 6, 2017
Vegetable Pest Populations Can Soar in High Tunnels, Study Shows
High tunnels alone are not enough to control pest populations, the study shows. To control pest levels, growers need to take other steps that allow ventilation while screening crops, and supporting natural predators. Read More
Biocontrols Conference
September 1, 2017
Dispelling the Rumors: Using Biologicals and Biochemicals in IPM Programs
Whether you’re a grower, packer, processor, or retailer, you have experienced the dramatic shift in consumer preference for sustainable practices Read More
Biocontrols Conference
September 1, 2017
Silicon: a Biocontrol Agent that Boosts Plant Immunity
Quality and profitability are two important factors that drive our agricultural markets. We have fine-tuned our cultivation processes over centuries Read More
The Latest
Crop Protection
October 17, 2017
EPA Takes Steps to Reduce Risk of Drift-…
With reports of dicamba injuries in tomatoes, peaches, grapes, and other crops, the agency works to reduce the impact of spray drift on vulnerable crops. Read More
Crop Protection
October 9, 2017
Field Scouting Guide: Black Rot of Brass…
Follow these tips for spotting and treating Xanthomonas campestris. Read More
Citrus
October 9, 2017
(We Won’t Back Down … ) Stan…
You don’t have to be a super hero, rock star, or award-winning scientist to aid farming. You can help by supporting professionalism in fields. Read More
Citrus
October 6, 2017
Complications Persist as Florida Growers…
Ground zero perspective reveals how citrus and vegetable producers are facing different, daunting challenges in wake of destructive storm. Read More
Crop Protection
September 27, 2017
AMVAC Expands Non-Crop Business by Acqui…
Transaction to facilitate market access in the greenhouse and nursery markets. Read More
Biocontrols Conference
September 13, 2017
Get Better Results From Your Biopesticid…
Softer crop protection programs are becoming a must in specialty crop production. Growers who aren’t learning more about their options Read More
Citrus
September 13, 2017
Florida Farmers Digging out From Impacts…
Damage reports flood in from the field following monster storm, and it's not pretty. Read More
Biocontrols Conference
September 11, 2017
The Grower’s Take: Citrus, HLB, and Biol…
Uncle Matt’s Organic orange juice brand has enjoyed steady growth since its 2002 inception. The brand’s success is due to Read More
Biocontrols Conference
September 1, 2017
Dispelling the Rumors: Using Biologicals…
Whether you’re a grower, packer, processor, or retailer, you have experienced the dramatic shift in consumer preference for sustainable practices Read More
Biocontrols Conference
September 1, 2017
Silicon: a Biocontrol Agent that Boosts …
Quality and profitability are two important factors that drive our agricultural markets. We have fine-tuned our cultivation processes over centuries Read More
Citrus
August 25, 2017
California EPA Seeking to Review Chlorpy…
Department of Pesticide Regulation, Office of Environmental Health pursuing health protections. Read More
Crop Protection
August 23, 2017
New Biological Fungicide Approved for Fr…
Howler fungicide, developed by AgBiome, receives EPA registration for high-value, specialty crops. Read More
Crop Protection
August 11, 2017
Do Fungicide- and Insecticide-Treated Se…
The University of New Hampshire has received half a million dollars to investigate if seed treatments inadvertently protect weed seeds from its usual predators. Read More
Citrus
August 11, 2017
Field Scouting Guide: Common Lambsquarte…
Take a look at these tips for identifying and treating this pervasive weed. Read More
Crop Protection
August 9, 2017
Why Some of the Most Dangerous Potato Di…
If you understand the role oxygen, and its lack, plays in potato diseases, you'll be better equipped to battle them. Read More
Crop Protection
August 3, 2017
Can Avocados Be Saved from Deadly Laurel…
Scientists from Florida and California are on the case and collaborating. Read More
Crop Protection
August 2, 2017
Report: 90% of NY Beehives Had Varroa Mi…
Cornell University's NYS Beekeeper Tech Team recent report also shows most hives are infected with Deformed Wing Virus (DWV), a disease linked to the mites. Read More
Biocontrols Conference
July 31, 2017
11 New Biocontrol Products You Need to K…
One of the highlights of the Biocontrols Conference & Expo Series is getting an early look at some of the Read More