Unintended Consequences Of Food Safety Regulation Quite Costly

FoodSafety_IconThe Food SafetyModern-ization Act (FSMA) signed by President Obama in 2011 is the first reform of FDA food safety policy since the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act of 1938. FSMA mandates a science-based and risk-based policy to improve the safety of our food. It gives FDA authority to implement this policy recognizing resource limitations that mandate identification of the greatest risks and focusing resources where the greatest opportunities are to reduce those risks.

Under FSMA, all food-handling facilities are required to register with FDA every two years and cannot sell into interstate commerce without being registered. On-farm handling, holding, and packing operations are treated as a food facility, which is required to develop and implement a Hazard Analysis Critical Control Point plan. Realizing the potential adverse implications for small businesses, Congress added a number of exemptions to ease the burden on these small businesses. These include exemptions to those farms that sold food in the previous three-year period of $500,000 or less, and if more than 50% of their food sales were directly to qualified end-users. Qualified end-users included the consumers of the food regardless of location, or a restaurant or retail food establishment in the same state or not more than 275 miles from the farm. Commercially processed produce also is exempt if processed in a manner to adequately reduce pathogens. Other exemptions included farms with food sales of $25,000 or less and produce that is rarely consumed raw.

Same, But Not Equal

These exemptions result in 149,426 farms that are exempt or not covered by the law, leaving 40,211 that are covered (as reported by FDA in their analysis of economic impacts). Even exempt farms will be required to post notice of their business name and location at the point of sale, resulting in total costs of $3.8 million to those firms. To non-exempt domestic producers, total first year costs for compliance with the rules outlined by FDA were estimated at $699.79 million with recurring costs of $419.28 million to $459.6 million.
FDA estimates the benefits of this policy to be a 56.09% reduction in the estimated illnesses attributable to produce, from 3.12 million illnesses annually prior to the implementation of FSMA to 1.75 million illnesses after implementation. They contend these savings amount to $1.036 billion annually.

Paying The Price

The intention of these regulations is to make food safer for consumers and to mitigate the cost of food safety incidents in our society. Unintended consequences are those impacts occurring as a result of the regulation that do not contribute to the intent of the legislation. Exemptions provided under these regulations will provide more incentives for locally grown produce. The regulations would have minimal impact if they were equally felt by all producers. The regulations will increase the cost of growing and selling covered commodities in the national market. Those commodities will suffer a price impact on their demand, forcing them to compete with rival commodities that may be exempt. Non-exempt growers also will be forced to compete with growers who hold those exemptions because of size (small farms being exempt) or market (those selling into local markets are exempt).

The unintended consequences of this regulation are those producers who have established their presence in the national market will see their competitive advantage whittled away to small and local growers. We can only hope Congress understands these impacts and helps growers adjust to these rules. That will require money to develop safer technologies and to help implement those new technologies. Where does that money come from?

Topics: ,

Leave a Reply

4 comments on “Unintended Consequences Of Food Safety Regulation Quite Costly

  1. Are you serious?? This country was built on the backs of the small farmers. It was estimated that it would cost the small farmers more than $4K a year to comply with this monstrosity. This law was a mistake in the first place and was pushed forward by a consortium of big growers. Growers with enough income to be able to comply with all the regulations this law creates. The small grower will have to abide in some instances because of the liability created by past food issues such as the cantaloupe, spinach, lettuce, green onion, strawberry troubles. How about we really take a look at the reason for the contamination on a case by case basis and actually see what the problem was. I am willing to bet that it was something to do with manure on the organic front, improper hygiene by illegals on the large farms or blatant cutting of corners. Because of our small size we are more in contact with the growing of our produce than many of the large farms. Most of those guys are so large they can hardly call themselves farmers but now ride the seat of a CEO chair. Better stop, step back and take a look at what you have wrought. We should have just managed ourselves better and used GAP better. Don’t worry too much big guys as you will be pushing us little guys out and you will be able to improve your profits so you can continue to buy vacation properties and condos like that tomato grower.

  2. “The unintended consequences of this regulation are those producers who have established their presence in the national market will see their competitive advantage whittled away to small and local growers”

    Sounds good to me!!!

    1. And so the true meaning of the FSMA comes out. Push out the little guy with tons of regulations. RARELY is the little guy the problem. Even if he is, his produce is sold locally and the impact of any illness is felt locally and easily traced to his farm.

      Imported produce, large farm produce, etc. goes through multiple distribution chains, etc. any of which can be contamination sources. The small farmer is the backbone of the food chain. Not the guy growing 3000 acres who is no longer personally connected with what he is growing. His hundreds of employees do the work and he acts solely as a CEO or supervisor. That is NOT the definition of a “farmer”. It is the definition of corporate manager.

      This type of article is to be expected from national publications. Their advertisers push sales to mega farms. When was the last time you saw any of the large companies market to small growers? Ever?

      1. Matt, you are partially right. It is often harder for small growers to comply with food safety guidelines. That is probably why statistically there are more pathogens on produce from small growers. The contamination issues that affect many people are from the larger growers and these are the incidents that hit the news while often those from small growers are not reported – at least not on a national scale.

        And I agree that many of the contamination issues are away from the farm. Many of the recalls and sicknesses involve packing shed procedures. It seems that this is especially true in the processed produce products where the produce is cut, washed, and repackaged. These cut portions must be prime for pathogens reproducing and are often eaten without further culling of damaged or decaying portions of the product. Even if the pathogen can be traced back to the farm, the problem was multiplied by the processing and shipping package environment.

        The backbone of our food supply is now the large farmer. I can’t remember the exact statistics but it is something like 80% of our food is produced by 20% of our growers. I, farming with my brothers and sons, consider myself a middle size grower with just under 3000 acres (just over 1000 produce.) We don’t have hundreds of employees (actually less than 20) and don’t act solely as CEO or supervisors and are personally connected with what we are growing. But to do a good job and keep the food safe we have to think professionally and attend to detail much the way a corporate manager does.

        I feel for you small growers. Even with our combined operation we are still a small business and the Food Safety paperwork alone feels crushing. I can’t imagine doing it alone for a small operation. But I also fear the impulse to cut corners on food safety because the operation is small and you are trying to do everything yourself.

Farm Management Stories
Young Grower Alliance members survey some of the plantings in the peach architecture research block at USDA's Appalachian Fruit Research Laboratory in Kearneysville, WV. (Photo credit: Christina Herrick)
GenNext Growers
December 4, 2016
New Loans Available For Small, Beginning, Urban Growers
USDA recently announced streamlined guaranteed Loans and additional lender category for small-scale operators. Read More
Low-volume center pivot irrigation at Jones Potato Farm in Florida
Farm Management
December 1, 2016
Florida Farmers Are Good For The Environment
All three recipients of this year’s Agricultural-Environmental Leadership Awards are proof of agriculture’s longstanding commitment to conserving the Sunshine State's precious natural resources. Read More
woman looking at a computer screen FEATURE
GenNext Growers
November 30, 2016
Virtual Conference Designed For New, Beginning Farmers
National Farmers Union to present a conference that is entirely web-based. Read More
Cut sugarcane in South Florida
Citrus
November 23, 2016
Strength Of Sugar Fuels South Florida Economy [Opinion]
The Sunshine State's sugar industry employs more than 14,000 people and has an annual income of more than $800 million with a total direct and indirect economic impact of greater than $3 billion. Read More
At a one-on-one meeting, Patrick Pinkard, Assistant Manager of Terranova Ranch, (center) meets with Spectrum Technologies' Bridget Graf and Kevin Monk.
Farm Management
November 22, 2016
VegetableGrowerConnect: Delivering Results For Growers And Suppliers
One-on-one meetings with suppliers and networking opportunities were highlights of the third annual Connect. Read More
Photo credit: Washington State University
Farm Management
November 22, 2016
A Hops Crop To Be Thankful For
Washington State University researcher looks back on the growth in the craft beer industry, and a monster hop crop this year. Read More
Sugarcane variety CP 09-1952
Citrus
November 21, 2016
7 Sweet Releases In Florida Sugarcane
New cultivars focus on disease resistance and yield. Read More
The Latest
Citrus
December 8, 2016
A Look Inside Florida’s Newest Cannabis …
Given the official go-ahead to dispense alternative medicine, Knox Medical unveils its state-of-the-art lab. Read More
Citrus
December 6, 2016
Report: Florida Cannabis Business To App…
Lofty projections include a compound annual growth rate of 140%. Read More
Citrus
December 5, 2016
South Florida Endures Driest November On…
Region has not experienced any significant rainfall since Hurricane Matthew. Read More
Farm Management
December 1, 2016
Florida Farmers Are Good For The Environ…
All three recipients of this year’s Agricultural-Environmental Leadership Awards are proof of agriculture’s longstanding commitment to conserving the Sunshine State's precious natural resources. Read More
Citrus
November 23, 2016
Strength Of Sugar Fuels South Florida Ec…
The Sunshine State's sugar industry employs more than 14,000 people and has an annual income of more than $800 million with a total direct and indirect economic impact of greater than $3 billion. Read More
Farm Management
November 22, 2016
VegetableGrowerConnect: Delivering Resul…
One-on-one meetings with suppliers and networking opportunities were highlights of the third annual Connect. Read More
Farm Management
November 22, 2016
A Hops Crop To Be Thankful For
Washington State University researcher looks back on the growth in the craft beer industry, and a monster hop crop this year. Read More
Citrus
November 21, 2016
7 Sweet Releases In Florida Sugarcane
New cultivars focus on disease resistance and yield. Read More
Citrus
November 21, 2016
Insight Welcome On Florida Agriculture&#…
Poorly thought-out government policies loom as a major threat that prevents Florida farmers and ranchers from feeding a hungry world. Read More
Citrus
November 19, 2016
USDA Gives $200 Million To Expand Ag Exp…
USDA Secretary Tom Vilsack has announced the USDA’s Foreign Agricultural Service (FAS) is awarding $200 million to more than 70 Read More
Citrus
November 17, 2016
How Soil Type Affects Land Values
Sand, loam, and muck all offer something different when setting property prices. Read More
Business Planning
November 17, 2016
Financial Flux Forcing Extra Groundwork …
With challenging issues afoot, it’s not too early to start thinking about policies and funding implications surrounding the next Farm Bill. Read More
Citrus
November 17, 2016
Florida Farming, Sugarcane Pioneer Passe…
George H. Wedgworth founded and led the Sugar Cane Growers Cooperative of Florida for 50 years. Read More
Citrus
November 15, 2016
Help On The Way To Florida Farmers Hurti…
USDA designates four counties as primary natural disaster areas; loans offered to those eligible. Read More
Citrus
November 15, 2016
How The Trump Administration Will Impact…
In new report, experts say policy changes, especially immigration, could have long-term implications on the industry. Read More
Farm Management
November 14, 2016
Asian Trade Deal Killed
In what one prominent economist says is a blow to U.S. fruit exporters, the White House concedes the Trans-Pacific Partnership is not going to be ratified. Read More
Citrus
November 14, 2016
Dry Season Dangers Not On The Radar For …
Emerging from an extended period of plentiful precipitation, near-term water supply, drought issues not anticipated in the coming months. Read More
Citrus
November 9, 2016
U.S. Sweats Out Third-Warmest October On…
So far, 2016 is the second-warmest year-to-date in 122 years. Read More