Vegetable Pest Populations Can Soar in High Tunnels, Study Shows

Researchers saw significant increases in the number of tomato hornworms (pictured here) in high tunnels. The pests caused severe damage to tomato plants. Photo by MTSO fan

Although high tunnels are widely used by vegetable growers, surprisingly little research has been conducted to test their performance. Purdue University researcher Ricky Foster and his team set out to change that with a study focusing on pest levels.

“Many growers using high tunnels, or hoop houses, can extend their growing season significantly,” says Brian Wallheimer, who wrote the article profiling the study for Purdue. “But an assumption about how the enclosures guard against insect protection isn’t backed up by this study. Rather than keeping insects out, the high tunnels seem to keep pests in, sometimes with significant damage associated.”

Here are Some Details of the Study

  • Crops Tested: Three different crops and the pests that are most often associated with them: Tomatoes and hornworms; broccoli and the cabbage looper, imported cabbageworm and diamondback moth; and cucumber and the cucumber beetle.
  • Length of Study: Two years
  • Results in Brief: Pest populations on the whole were higher than populations in adjacent fields:
    • Tomato Hornworm was a particular problem. “In field situations, hornworms are kind of an anomaly. They’re there, but not in great numbers. We found that in high tunnels, they just exploded,” Foster, who is a Purdue professor of entomology told Wallheimer. “There was just nothing green left on the plants. There were just stems hanging on them.”
    • The Likely Culprit of High Pest Levels? Ventilation. Researchers raised the side coverings on warm days to prevent temperatures reaching more than 120 degrees. That allowed pests to enter, and then they were often trapped when the sides were lowered or when pests wanted to fly up and were stopped by the top of the high tunnel structure.

 

Possible Counter Measures

Laura L. Ingwell, a postdoctoral researcher at Purdue, is conducting related research that is evaluating ways to counter the pest pressure.

She is testing ways to screen crops without sacrificing ventilation, evaluating three different screens of varying pore size.

She is also seeing if growing floral crops — zinnia and gomphrena — among vegetables has an impact on pest populations. Wallheimer reports she’s seeing good results on this front.

“We saw a higher diversity and abundance of predators and less pest outbreaks on the focal produce crops,” Ingwell says. “The flowers offer alternative food for a lot of the beneficial insects. They’ll feed on the pest insects, but they also need pollen and nectar for their diets.”

The study results can be seen in the trade journal, Pest Management Science.



 

Topics: ,

Leave a Reply

One comment on “Vegetable Pest Populations Can Soar in High Tunnels, Study Shows

  1. Ron Goldy at Michigan State found similar results with hornworms in high tunnels about 10 years ago and eventually concluded that hornworm moths were active at night and therefore were not influenced by changes in light spectra under plastic covers, but flight of the parasitic wasp for hornworm occurred during the day and the change in light spectra tended to inhibit wasp flight into tunnels (possibly similarly to how honeybee navigation is disrupted under many plastics that alter light spectra).

Insect Control Stories
Insect Control
September 6, 2017
Vegetable Pest Populations Can Soar in High Tunnels, Study Shows
High tunnels alone are not enough to control pest populations, the study shows. To control pest levels, growers need to take other steps that allow ventilation while screening crops, and supporting natural predators. Read More
Biocontrols Conference
September 1, 2017
Dispelling the Rumors: Using Biologicals and Biochemicals in IPM Programs
Whether you’re a grower, packer, processor, or retailer, you have experienced the dramatic shift in consumer preference for sustainable practices Read More
fall armyworm
Insect Control
August 24, 2017
Stop Fall Armyworm from Getting the Drop on Your Sweet Corn Crop
Learn how to identify, the survival and spread, as well as management methods for this notorious pest. Read More
Insect Control
August 22, 2017
Stink Bug Threatens High-Dollar Crops in California
While populations are low, it appears invasive pest has recently stumbled upon the state’s peaches and almonds. Read More
a freshly picked avocado cradled in hand
Crop Protection
August 3, 2017
Can Avocados Be Saved from Deadly Laurel Wilt Disease?
Scientists from Florida and California are on the case and collaborating. Read More
sprayer nozzles
Biocontrols Conference
July 31, 2017
11 New Biocontrol Products You Need to Know
One of the highlights of the Biocontrols Conference & Expo Series is getting an early look at some of the Read More
Diamondback-Moth-adult-Stormy-Sparks
Crop Protection
July 25, 2017
Vegetable Field Scouting Guide: Diamondback Moth
Due diligence is needed to help take down this pest of biblical proportions. Read More
Fruits
July 14, 2017
Brown Marmorated Stink Bug Predator Egg Mass Found
Samuri wasp parasitized egg mass found in Southern New Jersey peach orchard. Read More
Beet-armyworms-on-a-tomato-plant
Citrus
July 12, 2017
Tomato Pests Can Be Induced to Cannibalism, New Study Shows
The University of Wisconsin's John Orrock says when beet armyworms are exposed to concentrations of methyl jasmonate, they will abandon eating tomatoes — and start eating one another. Read More
darkwinged fungus gnat larvae
Fruits
July 12, 2017
How to Deal with Annoying Fungus Gnats on the Farm
Learn how to identify, the survival and spread, as well as management methods for this insect pest. Read More
Close-up of mature diamondback moth
Insect Control
July 7, 2017
Can Genetic Engineering Put an End to Diamondback Moth Plague?
USDA OKs field release of pest with self-limiting gene at Cornell research farm. Read More
Crop Protection
June 25, 2017
Study Suggests Closer-Proximity Lures Help Increase Insect Pest Catches
Research shows single-trap locations are not as effective as those kept close together. Read More
Crop Protection
June 21, 2017
Early-Season Scouting Tips for Sweet Corn Growers
Black cutworm and true armyworm have been caught in relatively high numbers across the Midwest, including Michigan. Learn more about determining risk and scouting in your sweet corn plantings. Read More
Illustration of CRISPR-Cas9
Citrus
June 15, 2017
Make Way for Life-Saving Science on Your Farm [opinion]
While nature always finds a way to adapt, science continues to find other ways to cope. Read More
Fruits
May 31, 2017
Is CRISPR/Cas9 a Viable Solution for the Control of Crop Insect Pests?
Gene editing has the potential to aid growers in control of invasive pests. Read More
The Latest
Insect Control
September 20, 2017
Whitefly Troubles Go From Bad to Worse i…
Growers should have a plan for managing the pest from beginning to end of season. Read More
Biocontrols Conference
September 13, 2017
Get Better Results From Your Biopesticid…
Softer crop protection programs are becoming a must in specialty crop production. Growers who aren’t learning more about their options Read More
Biocontrols Conference
September 11, 2017
The Grower’s Take: Citrus, HLB, and Biol…
Uncle Matt’s Organic orange juice brand has enjoyed steady growth since its 2002 inception. The brand’s success is due to Read More
Insect Control
September 6, 2017
Vegetable Pest Populations Can Soar in H…
High tunnels alone are not enough to control pest populations, the study shows. To control pest levels, growers need to take other steps that allow ventilation while screening crops, and supporting natural predators. Read More
Biocontrols Conference
September 1, 2017
Dispelling the Rumors: Using Biologicals…
Whether you’re a grower, packer, processor, or retailer, you have experienced the dramatic shift in consumer preference for sustainable practices Read More
Insect Control
August 24, 2017
Stop Fall Armyworm from Getting the Drop…
Learn how to identify, the survival and spread, as well as management methods for this notorious pest. Read More
Insect Control
August 22, 2017
Stink Bug Threatens High-Dollar Crops in…
While populations are low, it appears invasive pest has recently stumbled upon the state’s peaches and almonds. Read More
Crop Protection
August 3, 2017
Can Avocados Be Saved from Deadly Laurel…
Scientists from Florida and California are on the case and collaborating. Read More
Biocontrols Conference
July 31, 2017
11 New Biocontrol Products You Need to K…
One of the highlights of the Biocontrols Conference & Expo Series is getting an early look at some of the Read More
Crop Protection
July 25, 2017
Vegetable Field Scouting Guide: Diamondb…
Due diligence is needed to help take down this pest of biblical proportions. Read More
Fruits
July 14, 2017
Brown Marmorated Stink Bug Predator Egg …
Samuri wasp parasitized egg mass found in Southern New Jersey peach orchard. Read More
Citrus
July 12, 2017
Tomato Pests Can Be Induced to Cannibali…
The University of Wisconsin's John Orrock says when beet armyworms are exposed to concentrations of methyl jasmonate, they will abandon eating tomatoes — and start eating one another. Read More
Fruits
July 12, 2017
How to Deal with Annoying Fungus Gnats o…
Learn how to identify, the survival and spread, as well as management methods for this insect pest. Read More
Insect Control
July 7, 2017
Can Genetic Engineering Put an End to Di…
USDA OKs field release of pest with self-limiting gene at Cornell research farm. Read More
Crop Protection
June 25, 2017
Study Suggests Closer-Proximity Lures He…
Research shows single-trap locations are not as effective as those kept close together. Read More
Crop Protection
June 21, 2017
Early-Season Scouting Tips for Sweet Cor…
Black cutworm and true armyworm have been caught in relatively high numbers across the Midwest, including Michigan. Learn more about determining risk and scouting in your sweet corn plantings. Read More
Citrus
June 15, 2017
Make Way for Life-Saving Science on Your…
While nature always finds a way to adapt, science continues to find other ways to cope. Read More
Fruits
May 31, 2017
Is CRISPR/Cas9 a Viable Solution for the…
Gene editing has the potential to aid growers in control of invasive pests. Read More