Melon Vs. Watermelon

Food safety is an issue that will never go away and federal regulations will be coming, probably in the near future. Unfortunately, those regulations will come at a cost to the grower, and those costs will be difficult to pass along to the consumer. As a result, those expenses have the potential to present a significant burden for some growers.

That is why the National Watermelon Association (NWA) is aggressively pleading its case to FDA in regard to the agency’s classification of watermelon. Watermelon currently is grouped in the melon category, which is one of the seven high-risk categories based on outbreaks traced by FDA, states NWA Executive Director Robert Morrissey in a letter to the watermelon industry last month. Watermelon, however, has had no outbreaks related to production practices.

In the letter to the industry, Morrissey asks producers and others in the industry to contact FDA and ask the agency to reconsider how it views watermelon in relation to food safety. “FDA has verified that watermelon has no outbreaks related to production or industry practices,” states Morrissey. “Yet, many of our farmers and handlers are required to invest ‘unnecessarily’ in additional audits and other food safety programs by their customers due to the inclusion in the melon category.

“We are following GAPs and good handling principles and expect to continue to do so, in many cases doing more than what is expected on our farms and in our packingsheds,” he continues. “What we need to do is to separate our ‘safe’ crop from unnecessary protocols and audits that are required of high-risk categories.”

Understanding Risk

In a letter drafted for its members to send to their representatives in Congress to make them aware of the watermelon situation, the NWA cites comments made by United Fresh Produce Association that point out the differences in the melon category: “The industry recognizes that netted skin melons, like cantaloupe, have a different contamination risk profile from waxy skin melons, like watermelon, and this is reflected in the relative frequency that each has been associated with illness outbreaks.”

What Growers Can Do

NWA is encouraging growers to plead their case to FDA, but time is running out. The deadline for comments is May 24. To submit comments, growers can visit the docket FDA has opened to gather information on current practices and conditions for fresh produce production and packing at www.regulations.gov (The ID number is FDA-2010-N-0085-0070.)

NWA also is asking those in the industry to contact their senators and representatives to ask them for their support. To view a draft of the letters to send to Congress and Morrissey’s letter to the watermelon industry go to www.nationalwatermelonassociation.com.

Because watermelons have never been the cause of a foodborne illness outbreak, it makes sense that they should not be lumped in with other melons, but what is your take on this?  Post your thoughts in the comment box below.

Leave a Reply

Featured Stories
BerriesSpotted Wing Drosophila: Small Fly – Big Problem
May 29, 2015
Entomologists from throughout the U.S. share their experiences and what you might expect from this formidable pest in 2015. Read More
OrganicOrganic Fruit Production Pollinator Conservation Tactics
May 29, 2015
Many fruit crops are dependent on insect pollinators, so supporting them is critical to your farm’s success. Read More
Apples & PearsMillions Of Washington Apples Dumped
May 29, 2015
Monster crop, port slowdown blamed for tremendous waste of apples. Read More
CitrusBuzzworthy Trend: Florida’s Bee Colonies Building
May 29, 2015
Cooperation between beekeepers and growers paying off. Read More
ProductionNMSU Researchers Use Protected Agriculture For Season Extension
May 28, 2015
The demand for safe, nutritious, affordable local food, particularly for fresh fruits and vegetables, is rising in New Mexico. However, Read More
Farm ManagementGreat Ag Careers Are Going Wanting [Opinion]
May 28, 2015
There are 22,500 jobs going unfilled annually for an industry that’s extremely critical to the future of mankind. Read More
CitrusEPA Announces Final Rule On New Clean Water Act’s Jurisdiction
May 28, 2015
Landmark redefinition of “waters of the U.S.” called a land grab by opponents. Read More
OrganicNumbers Of Organic Farms, Sales, Continue To Soar
May 28, 2015
Of all the fruits and vegetables sold in the U.S., 12% is now organic, doubling market share in the past decade. Read More
Disease ControlTips For Grapevine Trunk Disease Diagnostics, Prevention, and Control
May 28, 2015
Various pathogens and environmental factors are considered to be major threats to the vineyard’s health. Pathogens are disease-causing organisms such Read More
Disease ControlPotential New Peach Disease In California
May 28, 2015
Last year, disease levels were very low in the cling peach growing districts of California. Still, several diseases continue to Read More
The Latest
BerriesSpotted Wing Drosophila: Small Fly – Big Problem
May 29, 2015
Entomologists from throughout the U.S. share their experiences and what you might expect from this formidable pest in 2015. Read More
OrganicOrganic Fruit Production Pollinator Conservation Tactic…
May 29, 2015
Many fruit crops are dependent on insect pollinators, so supporting them is critical to your farm’s success. Read More
Apples & PearsMillions Of Washington Apples Dumped
May 29, 2015
Monster crop, port slowdown blamed for tremendous waste of apples. Read More
CitrusBuzzworthy Trend: Florida’s Bee Colonies Building
May 29, 2015
Cooperation between beekeepers and growers paying off. Read More
ProductionNMSU Researchers Use Protected Agriculture For Season E…
May 28, 2015
The demand for safe, nutritious, affordable local food, particularly for fresh fruits and vegetables, is rising in New Mexico. However, Read More
Farm ManagementGreat Ag Careers Are Going Wanting [Opinion]
May 28, 2015
There are 22,500 jobs going unfilled annually for an industry that’s extremely critical to the future of mankind. Read More
CitrusEPA Announces Final Rule On New Clean Water Act’s Juris…
May 28, 2015
Landmark redefinition of “waters of the U.S.” called a land grab by opponents. Read More
OrganicNumbers Of Organic Farms, Sales, Continue To Soar
May 28, 2015
Of all the fruits and vegetables sold in the U.S., 12% is now organic, doubling market share in the past decade. Read More
Disease ControlTips For Grapevine Trunk Disease Diagnostics, Preventio…
May 28, 2015
Various pathogens and environmental factors are considered to be major threats to the vineyard’s health. Pathogens are disease-causing organisms such Read More
Disease ControlPotential New Peach Disease In California
May 28, 2015
Last year, disease levels were very low in the cling peach growing districts of California. Still, several diseases continue to Read More
Vegetables10 Cole Crop Varieties For Your Collection
May 28, 2015
This month’s variety specs feature showcases 10 cole crop varieties from the nation’s leading seed breeders and distributors. Features highlighted Read More
GrapesDeadline Extended For Crucial Winegrape Disease And Pes…
May 27, 2015
Returned ballots to continue the Pierce’s Disease/Glassy-Winged Sharpshooter referendum must be returned by June 10. Read More
CitrusPMA Comments On FDA’s Proposed FSMA Implementation Work…
May 27, 2015
In written comments submitted today to the FDA proposed Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA) implementation work plans (Focus on Implementation Read More
A view from a low-altitude helicopter shows avocado groves in south Miami-Dade County.
Disease ControlEyes In The Sky Provide Early Detection Of Destructive …
May 27, 2015
Study using multispectral photography helps scientists successfully scout out laurel wilt-affected trees. Read More
BerriesThree Promising New Berries From USDA
May 27, 2015
USDA breeding programs in Maryland and Oregon have introduced three promising berry cultivars that could work well for growers both East Read More
EquipmentThe Benefits Of Vineyard Mechanization
May 27, 2015
Labor accounts for a substantial fraction of the production costs of most fruits, including grapes. Manual harvest is particularly laborious, Read More
FruitsRegistration Is Open For 2015 International Fruit Tree …
May 26, 2015
Registration is now open for the International Fruit Tree Association’s (IFTA) 2015 Regional Study Tour. This registration includes hotel accommodations Read More
Stone FruitEarly Cherry Harvest In Pacific Northwest
May 26, 2015
Cherry harvest is off to an early start in the Pacific Northwest reports the Tri-City Herald thanks to a warmer-than-average Read More