Considerations Before Purchasing Non-Tunnel Covering Systems For Sweet Cherries

Greg Lang
Greg Lang

In my September 2014 sweet cherry column, I discussed the potential to reduce rain-induced fruit cracking with regards to orchard covering systems, specifically high tunnels. The key first questions to be asked by growers considering any sort of covering system are: What are the specific marketing opportunities and anticipated returns for their operation? What is the likelihood and extent of crop loss from rain?

Since cherries can be grown under various types of protective covers, from high tunnels that cover multiple rows per cover to cable-and-pole tent-like structures that cover individual rows, to retractable-roof greenhouse-like structures that cover entire orchards, the differential strengths, weaknesses and costs must all be considered.

A covering system that is only needed to protect the crop from rain during ripening adds a single benefit to production. A system that also protects from frost and/or promotes earlier ripening and/or facilitates pick-your-own customers on rainy weekends adds additional return-on-investment benefits.

High Tunnel Benefits
High tunnels vary in price across and within manufacturers, generally based on the gauge of steel used for hoops and legs, the amount of steel bracing (particularly important in areas with strong wind gusts), auxiliary components such as doors or gutters, and the durability of plastic for covers.

There are numerous manufacturers of high tunnels, the most well-known being Haygrove Tunnels from the United Kingdom. Material costs per acre for such tunnels tend to range from about $39,000 to $48,000. As with all covering systems, labor quality and site characteristics (stony soils, wind exposure, etc.) can add additional costs to establishment.

Our 10 years of research on high tunnel fruit production — which expanded recently to include apricots, nectarines, and plums/pluots — has shown reductions in sweet cherry rain cracking and bird netting quantity. It is only needed for doors, sides, and valleys between tunnels rather than the entire orchard, and some diseases and insects, while promoting healthier trees, protecting from frosts — with the use of supplemental heaters when doors and sides are added, and advancing harvest date through earlier spring heat unit accumulation.

The greatest challenge in high tunnels is the venting of excessive daily heat that accumulates on sunny days during fruit ripening, which can quickly and sometimes irreversibly reduce fruit quality by causing fruit to stop growing or accumulating sugar, and softening.

non tunneling covering for sweet cherries chart
Figure 1. A pole-and-cable tent-like row covering system and tree development plan for a central leader canopy architecture, e.g., the tall spindle axe (TSA) system.

On The Lower End Of The Cost Spectrum
Pole-and-cable tent-like row covers (Fig. 1) are the least costly covering system, generally ranging from $15,000 to $23,000 per acre. As with tunnels, prices vary based on types of posts used (wood, steel, concrete), the amount and gauge of cable for cross-bracing, the type of plastic for covers, and functional mechanisms such as seasonally fixed or manually/daily retractable operation. Bird netting may be reduced if the plastic tents connect closely between rows; otherwise, netting the entire orchard above the tent covers may be needed.

Closely connected tent covers also trap heat during ripening if they are fixed rather than retractable, though this trait can help in early spring for minor frost protection. Tent covers with wide gaps between rows trap less heat in the summer, but this also renders them less useful for spring frost prevention, advancing bloom and harvest, or wind protection.

Pole-and-cable tent covers often are engineered locally on an orchard-by-orchard basis, but one international manufacturer, VOEN from Germany, has become well-known for its proprietary plastic-and-net panels as well as its engineered support structure. The plastic flaps overlay netting panels, therefore allowing hot air and wind to vent through the netting while the plastic flaps close for protection during rain.

Many Features With Retractable Covers
Automated retractable orchard-wide covers are the most costly type of system, generally starting from $65,000 per acre. These systems approach greenhouse-type operations for environmental modification, with the ability to open and close the roof as well as optional sides based on inputs from weather station sensors for rain, temperature, wind, etc.

Figure 2. A retractable flat-roof greenhouse-like covering system and tree development plan for a fruiting wall narrow canopy architecture, e.g., the upright fruiting offshoots (UFO) or Super Slender Axe (SSA) system.
Figure 2. A retractable flat-roof greenhouse-like covering system and tree development plan for a fruiting wall narrow canopy architecture, e.g., the upright fruiting offshoots (UFO) or Super Slender Axe (SSA) system.

Our research experience with this structure, manufactured by Cravo from Canada, has demonstrated the greatest suite of benefits, as one should expect from the greatest investment. The system retains heat from solar radiation or supplemental propane heaters in spring for the most effective protection from spring frost.

The roof opens for optimized honeybee activity during bloom on sunny days and closes for improved honeybee activity during rainy days. The roof is programmed to close to optimize heat units to advance bloom and fruit development for earlier ripening, while opening to eliminate excessive heat accumulation that would adversely affect fruit quality.

The most expensive design uses a peak-and-valley roof with gutters to shield the orchard from rainfall. The least expensive design uses a flat roof with small T-shaped slits in the plastic spaced in rows to capture rainfall and channel it to specific drainage areas throughout the orchard, requiring the use of fruiting wall-type tree architectures to avoid wetting of the fruit (Fig. 2).

Fruiting Walls And Covering Systems
The development of fruiting wall architectures is explained in a new joint extension bulletin from Oregon State University, Michigan State University, and Washington State University (PNW 667). Performance of such training systems after six years of trials will be discussed in my next column.

Topics: , , ,

Leave a Reply

One comment on “Considerations Before Purchasing Non-Tunnel Covering Systems For Sweet Cherries

Protected Agriculture Stories
Production
May 31, 2017
Speak Your Greenhouse Plants’ Language
Let’s go over some the necessary terms you need to understand so you can talk about your plants. Read More
Production
March 22, 2017
Weighing the Good and Bad of Six Soilless Media Options
Trying to decide which growing media is the right one for your greenhouse vegetable production? Take a look at these six options. Read More
Crop Protection
March 11, 2017
How to Stop Plant Diseases Before They Grab Hold
These smart strategies play off the science behind infestations, instead of merely treating symptoms. Read More
Leafy Vegetables
March 8, 2017
The Dos and Don’ts of Growing Greenhouse Vegetables
Thinking of adding growing vegetables under cover? Here are a few things you need to consider first. Read More
Production
March 1, 2017
Iran Is Moving All Vegetable Growing Into Greenhouses
Iran will be converting all its vegetable farms to greenhouses within 10 years, The Financial Tribune reports. Its agriculture minister Read More
More Vegetables
January 10, 2017
High Tunnel, Greenhouse Vegetable IPM Webinars Slated for February and March
Topics to be covered include production and disease, insect, and weed management tactics. Read More
Ed Pines citrus grower
Citrus
December 14, 2016
Planting Citrus Under Protective Screen Goes Commercial
Production practice offers benefits beyond excluding the psyllid and HLB. Read More
More Vegetables
November 30, 2016
Keys To Successful Bell Pepper Production In High Tunnels
Proper water management and pruning strategies can help improve yields. Read More
Production
November 1, 2016
Vertical Farming Innovator Urban Crops Opens U.S. Regional Headquarters
The Belgium-based company produces tailored growth infrastructures that are turnkey, automated, robotized, and able to be integrated into existing production facilities. Read More
Protected Agriculture
October 12, 2016
NatureFresh Farms Launches OhioRed Tomato Program
The greenhouse operation also was named a PMA Impact Award Finalist. Read More
Production
September 6, 2016
NatureFresh Farms Hits A New Level For Locally Grown
The company's Ohio-grown greenhouse tomatoes hit the marketplace as phase two and three of a state-of-the-art facility are being completed. Read More
Marketing
September 6, 2016
Red Sun Farms Becomes Part Of The ‘Ohio Proud’ Program
After breaking ground on a second greenhouse in the spring, Red Sun plans to start the hiring process this fall and plant the first crop in early 2017. Read More
Protected Agriculture
September 5, 2016
Greenhouse Structures: It’s All In The Planning
In deciding about the size of the plot of land for your greenhouse, be sure you take into account whether you will be a wholesale or a retail business, or some combination of the two like many growers. Read More
four spinach varieties in a bin
Leafy Vegetables
August 8, 2016
Researchers Find Cold Weather Makes For Tastier High Tunnel-Produced Spinach
New Hampshire scientists conducted a two-year winter trial to determine the best spinach varieties and planting dates for production in unheated high-tunnels. Read More
Production
August 2, 2016
SARE Grant Expands Tomato Research In High Tunnels
Researchers in New Hampshire receive grant to expand research for tomato nutrient and pest management in high tunnels. Read More
The Latest
Insect Control
September 6, 2017
Vegetable Pest Populations Can Soar in H…
High tunnels alone are not enough to control pest populations, the study shows. To control pest levels, growers need to take other steps that allow ventilation while screening crops, and supporting natural predators. Read More
Production
August 30, 2017
Houweling’s Tomatoes Grows Produce with …
Houweling’s Tomatoes exceeds industry standards for locally grown produce while pioneering innovative technologies that improve sustainability. Read More
Production
August 9, 2017
Greenhouse Vegetable Production Systems …
From fully automated deepwater culture to vertical growing systems, growers and manufacturers weigh in on tools for producing top-quality vegetables and greens. Read More
Production
May 31, 2017
Speak Your Greenhouse Plants’ Language
Let’s go over some the necessary terms you need to understand so you can talk about your plants. Read More
Production
March 22, 2017
Weighing the Good and Bad of Six Soilles…
Trying to decide which growing media is the right one for your greenhouse vegetable production? Take a look at these six options. Read More
Crop Protection
March 11, 2017
How to Stop Plant Diseases Before They G…
These smart strategies play off the science behind infestations, instead of merely treating symptoms. Read More
Leafy Vegetables
March 8, 2017
The Dos and Don’ts of Growing Greenhouse…
Thinking of adding growing vegetables under cover? Here are a few things you need to consider first. Read More
Production
March 1, 2017
Iran Is Moving All Vegetable Growing Int…
Iran will be converting all its vegetable farms to greenhouses within 10 years, The Financial Tribune reports. Its agriculture minister Read More
More Vegetables
January 10, 2017
High Tunnel, Greenhouse Vegetable IPM We…
Topics to be covered include production and disease, insect, and weed management tactics. Read More
Citrus
December 14, 2016
Planting Citrus Under Protective Screen …
Production practice offers benefits beyond excluding the psyllid and HLB. Read More
More Vegetables
November 30, 2016
Keys To Successful Bell Pepper Productio…
Proper water management and pruning strategies can help improve yields. Read More
Production
November 1, 2016
Vertical Farming Innovator Urban Crops O…
The Belgium-based company produces tailored growth infrastructures that are turnkey, automated, robotized, and able to be integrated into existing production facilities. Read More
Protected Agriculture
October 12, 2016
NatureFresh Farms Launches OhioRed Tomat…
The greenhouse operation also was named a PMA Impact Award Finalist. Read More
Production
September 6, 2016
NatureFresh Farms Hits A New Level For …
The company's Ohio-grown greenhouse tomatoes hit the marketplace as phase two and three of a state-of-the-art facility are being completed. Read More
Marketing
September 6, 2016
Red Sun Farms Becomes Part Of The ‘Ohio …
After breaking ground on a second greenhouse in the spring, Red Sun plans to start the hiring process this fall and plant the first crop in early 2017. Read More
Protected Agriculture
September 5, 2016
Greenhouse Structures: It’s All In The …
In deciding about the size of the plot of land for your greenhouse, be sure you take into account whether you will be a wholesale or a retail business, or some combination of the two like many growers. Read More
Leafy Vegetables
August 8, 2016
Researchers Find Cold Weather Makes For …
New Hampshire scientists conducted a two-year winter trial to determine the best spinach varieties and planting dates for production in unheated high-tunnels. Read More
Production
August 2, 2016
SARE Grant Expands Tomato Research In Hi…
Researchers in New Hampshire receive grant to expand research for tomato nutrient and pest management in high tunnels. Read More