Organic Industry Rocked By Synthetics

Judging by the comments we’ve received on the two California companies who were suspected of adding synthetic fertilizer to purportedly organic products I’m not the only one who’s disturbed by these developments. Like it or not, those growing and selling organic vegetables are trading on the belief of the consumers. Violating that belief is dangerous.

In fact, I’m somewhat surprised there hasn’t been more outrage from organic consumers. That might be due to the fact that these stories haven’t seen greater play in consumer media, whether on TV, in newspapers, or on the Internet. I have no idea why these developments haven’t seen more publicity, as in my experience, nothing boosts viewership like these “scare” stories. Whatever the reason, organic growers should feel fortunate that the stories haven’t been more widely publicized.

In case you’re not familiar with the details, both cases involved large companies — at least in terms of the organic fertilizer market — allegedly adding a synthetic fertilizer, ammonium sulfate, to what were allegedly organic products. One company, California Liquid Fertilizer, which was based near Salinas,
reportedly held as much as one-third of the California market in 2006. The other, Port Organic Products Ltd. of Bakersfield, reportedly produces nearly half the state’s liquid organic fertilizer.

A few weeks ago, federal agents raided Port Organics Products. And that came just a few weeks after it was reported that despite the fact that California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA) officials were notified of a problem with California Liquid Fertilizer in June 2004, CDFA did not order California Liquid Fertilizer to remove its product, Biolizer XN, from the organic market until January 2007.

Does the industry require more scrutiny? These developments clearly suggest that it does. Consumers who purchase organic vegetables do so based on the faith that those products are, in fact, organically grown. Violating that faith could mean losing those consumers, especially for larger growers who don’t have direct contact with their customers. But in the meantime, it’s incumbent on all involved in the industry to be increasingly vigilant. It’s a lot easier to retain consumers’ trust than it is to get it back after it’s gone.

Leave a Reply

2 comments on “Organic Industry Rocked By Synthetics

  1. As one who buys organic products, I believe that anyone in the chain from seed to market that violate the rules should be suspended for three years and THEN begin the three year re-certification with additional probational reporting for a period after that. Also, the name of the offending business should be listed as such with the governing bodies website and made available to the public. If you can’t make a living going by the rules then do something else.

  2. As one who buys organic products, I believe that anyone in the chain from seed to market that violate the rules should be suspended for three years and THEN begin the three year re-certification with additional probational reporting for a period after that. Also, the name of the offending business should be listed as such with the governing bodies website and made available to the public. If you can’t make a living going by the rules then do something else.

Featured Stories
CitrusResearchers Say Drones Will Play A Major Role In Farming
August 4, 2015
Texas A&M AgriLife researchers say the technology will offer growers precise information about their crops. Read More
Farm ManagementFarm Bureau Awards Mini-Grants To Communities Across The Country  
August 4, 2015
White-Reinhardt grants are allocated through county and state farm bureaus and are used to create new agricultural literacy projects or expand existing ag literacy efforts. Read More
Asian citrus psyllid closeup
Insect & Disease UpdateStudy: Citrus Greening Bacterium Gives Vector Unexpected Boost
August 4, 2015
Researchers find Asian citrus psyllids can travel further and more often once carrying the deadly disease. Read More
Apples & PearsSmaller Apple Crop Expected In Washington
August 4, 2015
An early apple harvest is expected in Washington state this year as warm summer temperatures and an early start to Read More
Disease ControlCopper Injury And Bacterial Spot Are Easily Confused
August 4, 2015
In her latest bulletin for tree fruit growers, Kari Peter of Penn State University Extension says it is easy to confuse the Read More
Apples & PearsNew York Apple Growers Unveils New Organization Name
August 4, 2015
=New York Apple Growers (NYAG) has changed its name to Crunch Time Apple Growers.  The organization is comprised of 145 Read More
Apple Grower of the YearBill Dodd Is An Apple Grower For Our Future
August 3, 2015
The judging for the Apple Grower Of The Year award is an interesting process that takes us through new twists Read More
GenNext GrowersPotato Industry Leadership Institute Program To Be Held In February
August 3, 2015
The application and scholarship deadline is Oct. 15, 2015. Read More
More Vegetables13 Of The Latest Pepper Varieties
August 3, 2015
This month’s variety specs feature focuses on pepper varieties. Features highlighted include great disease resistance packages, excellent yield potential, and more. Be Read More
Apple Grower of the YearBill Dodd, The 2015 Apple Grower Of The Year
August 3, 2015
  Informed of his selection as the 2015 Apple Grower Of The Year by American Fruit Grower® and Western Fruit Grower™ Read More
The Latest
CitrusResearchers Say Drones Will Play A Major Role In Farmin…
August 4, 2015
Texas A&M AgriLife researchers say the technology will offer growers precise information about their crops. Read More
Farm ManagementFarm Bureau Awards Mini-Grants To Communities Across Th…
August 4, 2015
White-Reinhardt grants are allocated through county and state farm bureaus and are used to create new agricultural literacy projects or expand existing ag literacy efforts. Read More
Asian citrus psyllid closeup
Insect & Disease UpdateStudy: Citrus Greening Bacterium Gives Vector Unexpecte…
August 4, 2015
Researchers find Asian citrus psyllids can travel further and more often once carrying the deadly disease. Read More
Apples & PearsSmaller Apple Crop Expected In Washington
August 4, 2015
An early apple harvest is expected in Washington state this year as warm summer temperatures and an early start to Read More
Disease ControlCopper Injury And Bacterial Spot Are Easily Confused
August 4, 2015
In her latest bulletin for tree fruit growers, Kari Peter of Penn State University Extension says it is easy to confuse the Read More
Apples & PearsNew York Apple Growers Unveils New Organization Name
August 4, 2015
=New York Apple Growers (NYAG) has changed its name to Crunch Time Apple Growers.  The organization is comprised of 145 Read More
Apple Grower of the YearBill Dodd Is An Apple Grower For Our Future
August 3, 2015
The judging for the Apple Grower Of The Year award is an interesting process that takes us through new twists Read More
GenNext GrowersPotato Industry Leadership Institute Program To Be Held…
August 3, 2015
The application and scholarship deadline is Oct. 15, 2015. Read More
More Vegetables13 Of The Latest Pepper Varieties
August 3, 2015
This month’s variety specs feature focuses on pepper varieties. Features highlighted include great disease resistance packages, excellent yield potential, and more. Be Read More
Apple Grower of the YearBill Dodd, The 2015 Apple Grower Of The Year
August 3, 2015
  Informed of his selection as the 2015 Apple Grower Of The Year by American Fruit Grower® and Western Fruit Grower™ Read More
Farm ManagementLocally Grown The Lipman Way
August 3, 2015
With Lipman Local, the Florida operation has developed a mutually beneficial program that sources local produce around the country and helps smaller growers raise their game. Read More
Farm ManagementCorrect Misconceptions About Farming [Opinion]
August 3, 2015
Misinformation about agriculture abounds. We need to put a stop to it and set the record straight. Read More
UFR-2 Vernia citrus rootstock
Citrus Achievement AwardLessons Learned Via Citrus Variety Evaluation Never End
August 1, 2015
Orie Lee, the 2015 Citrus Achievement Award winner, discusses his decades-long involvement with Vernia. Read More
Florida Ag ExpoResearchers To Put 3 Major Crop Threats On Trial
August 1, 2015
Nematode, disease, and weed management on deck for the 10th annual Florida Ag Expo. Read More
woman smashing an alarm clock with a hammer
CitrusDon’t Become A Time Crunch Casualty
July 31, 2015
Finding the balance between work life and home life is easier said than done for GenNext Growers. Read More
PotatoesLate Blight Confirmed In Areas Of Idaho; Number Of Pota…
July 31, 2015
The number of potato psyllids decline while additional fields are noted as having late blight. Read More
Apples & PearsReTain Now Registered For Double Application
July 31, 2015
ReTain plant growth regulator (PGR) has been registered by EPA with a new label use that allows pome fruit growers Read More
Crop ProtectionLettuce Disease Gives E. Coli A Boost
July 31, 2015
E. coli prefer cut, injured, and young lettuce leaves. Read More