Why Farm Succession Often Stalls Before It Starts

Ask any family-run vegetable producer what keeps them awake at night, and succession usually makes the list. Most farms have a business plan, but far fewer have a succession plan. And fewer still have had a frank, honest family conversation about it.

From my research on intergenerational farm transfer over the past decade, published widely in international, peer-reviewed journals and books, I have learned that what holds families back is rarely the paperwork. It is about emotion, identity, and belonging.

For many older farmers, being the farmer is central to who they are. Handing over control of the business can feel like surrendering a lifetime of purpose, self-worth, and standing in the community. That is why even the strongest legal or financial plans can stall if the human side of the process is left unattended.

Why Structures Alone Don’t Solve the Problem

Across the world, partnership models and other collaborative ventures are promoted as pathways to farm transfer. On paper, they encourage intergenerational cooperation and give the next generation opportunities for recognition and leadership, while easing the older generation toward retirement.

In practice, however, these structures can falter when they overlook the complex micro-politics of family farm life.

My research on these household power dynamics has found that older farmers often (and understandably) strive to protect their lifelong sense of status and authority — what social scientists call “symbolic capital” — built on decades of hard work and peer respect.

Sometimes that legitimate authority drifts into what I describe in a paper published in the Journal of Rural Studies as “symbolic authoritarianism”: the subtle, unspoken ways the older generation maintains control in later life by emphasizing their indispensability, steering key decisions, and reinforcing their leadership to keep existing reins firmly in place.

---

RELATED CONTENT: Analyzing the Need for Agricultural Succession Planning

---

When this happens, successors may find themselves operating under a “generational shadow,” where even well-designed succession plans or partnerships fail to deliver real transition, despite structures that look perfect on paper.

Beyond Paperwork: Attending to Identity and Belonging

Policies and programs that focus only on the financial or legal mechanics of transfer often miss this deeper human reality. The real challenge is to honor the older generation’s identity while creating genuine space for the next generation to lead.

In practice, this means designing succession processes that preserve the older generation’s status in constructive ways while preventing overreach that stifles progress. Clear, staged roles for both generations — with well-defined responsibilities and decision rights that evolve over time — allow successors to build credibility while the older generation retains dignity, purpose, and a valued presence on the farm.

A farm succession succeeds when families treat identity, purpose, and belonging as core components of the transition—not as afterthoughts.