Researchers Look To The Sun For Help In Citrus Greening Fight

Dr. Yong-Ping Duan and colleague Melissa Doud inspect tented citrus trees undergoing heat treatment. Photo courtesy of USDA
Dr. Yong-Ping Duan and colleague Melissa Doud inspect tented citrus trees undergoing heat treatment.
Photo courtesy of USDA

Scientists have thrown a lot of research toward HLB in hopes of finding ways to mitigate the threat to Florida’s citrus industry. Many agree the solution might not come as a silver bullet fix, but from a number of approaches targeting the psyllid and the bacteria that spreads the disease.
Researchers at USDA’s Horticultural Lab in Ft. Pierce believe one of those fixes could come by turning up the heat on HLB — literally. Thermotherapy has been used to treat other plant diseases, including citrus viral diseases. Dr. Yong-Ping Duan, a plant pathologist at the lab, decided to test the approach on the HLB bacteria. He has worked closely with USDA-ARS colleagues Michele Hoffman, Melissa Doud, David Hall, and Ed Stover in the research project.
“We came up with the idea to impose heat stress to infected trees and first treated potted HLB-affected citrus with various temperatures above 98.6°F for two to 10 days under controlled conditions,” says Duan. “Through the research, we were able to narrow down temperatures and durations needed to suppress or eliminate the HLB bacteria in the potted tree.”
From initial experiments, the scientists found that young infected potted plants exposed to constant heat of 104°F for 48 hours in a controlled growth chamber completely killed the HLB bacterium Candidatus Liberibacter asiaticus (Las). “These cured potted trees have remained disease free for three years in a psyllid-free greenhouse,” says Duan.

Taking It To The Groves

With the excellent results in the lab, Duan turned to test the technique in the field. To generate extra heat in field experiments, Duan utilized tents to place around infected trees.
“Our outside tent experiments began in February 2011 at our Picos Farm,” says Duan. “We initially started with very large 9-foot tall tents, but soon after changed to 6-foot tall tents. Our first trial of commercial heat treatment experiments began in March 2011.”

While lab results showed heat would kill HLB in potted trees, the field trials indicate thermotherapy will suppress the bacteria but not eliminate it. “Solar energy can heat the air inside the tent above 104°F for a few hours a day,” says Duan. “Our results have shown that the heat treatment can kill some of the HLB bacteria in the canopy but is unable to penetrate the soil to kill the bacteria in the roots. Thus, after heat treatment, there is a reduction in Las in the tree but not a complete elimination.
“This reduction in bacteria is greatest within the first six months after heat treatment. Any flush that develops after heat treatment within that time is asymptomatic for HLB. Symptoms are still present in the old symptomatic leaves that existed before the treatment. As time goes on, the amount of bacteria increases. The rate of increase varies from tree to tree. Much of our data still shows Las present in the trees two years after heat treatment but the bacterial titer (concentration) was still less than the amount of bacteria present before treatment. Additionally as the leaves age, post treatment leaves will eventually show typical HLB symptoms.”
While the heat treatment doesn’t eliminate HLB, one of the most notable effects can be seen in the overall growth of treated trees. “Those trees treated will soon after produce a large flush throughout the whole tree, while non-treated trees continue to decline,” says Duan. “Results have shown that most heat-treated trees continue to grow well for at least two years.”

Growers Giving It A Try

Duan utilized commercially available tents for his research, but he says some growers are building their own. “Many of the homemade tents have been constructed out of PVC pipe and visqueen,” he says. “Some people simply lie a stretched out roll of visqueen over the trees and then tuck the bottom of the plastic into the ground using soil to weigh the material down.”
Currently, Duan is cooperating with three growers for field trial research. “In general, growers are optimistic about thermotherapy and are pleased with the results,” he says. “They have stated that they notice increased growth and fruit production from treated trees that were beginning to decline before treatment. Growers are now interested in determining how long the positive effects will last and developing ways to more conveniently heat treat trees.”

HLB Heating Pointers

Research shows several important considerations in thermotherapy:

  • Treatments are recommended during hottest months of the year or when daytime temperatures are in the mid-80s or higher for most of the day. If it is quite sunny and the temperatures are high enough, the treatment window can start as early as mid-March and run into early October. Heat treatments in the winter are not effective.
  • Treatment times are subject to variation, but the shortest duration is 72 hours. This would be at least three days where the outside temperature gets close to or above 90°F and afternoon storms don’t start before 2 p.m. (June-August). These conditions will allow the inside of the tent to be above 104°F for at least two hours to potentially eight hours each day. Type of tent, weather (rain and temperature), and size of tree all affect treatment times.
  • Monitor temps inside tent because it is possible to burn or kill the scion. Multiple hours above 125°F for more than two days can burn off the canopy of a 5-foot tree. Vent the tent if more than the top foot of the tree becomes brown or temperatures exceed 125°F.
Topics: ,

Leave a Reply

One comment on “Researchers Look To The Sun For Help In Citrus Greening Fight

Citrus Stories

Insect & Disease UpdateManage HLB From The Bottom Up
December 17, 2014
Finding the right balance between the roots and shoots is critical to disease mitigation. Read More
CitrusUSDA Offers Crop Disaster Assistance For Fruit And Vegetable Growers
December 16, 2014
Free basic coverage plans and premium discounts available for new, underserved, and limited income farmers who had been ineligible for federal crop insurance. Read More
CitrusSouth Florida Takes Plunge With Major Expansion Of Water Storage Program
December 15, 2014
New ag land partnerships, including a $124 million deal with Alico, more than double the current holding capacity. Read More
CitrusApplications Now Being Accepted For Florida Specialty Crop Block Grants
December 12, 2014
$4.5 million available to help fund industry-enhancing projects. Read More
CitrusFlorida Citrus Crop Forecast Update: So Far, So Good
December 10, 2014
USDA estimates hold steady for third month in a row. Read More
CitrusFlorida Citrus Hall Of Fame Selects Class Of 2015
December 10, 2014
Three more industry stalwarts added to prestigious list. Read More
CitrusSurvey Shows Food Safety, GMOs Among Public-Issue Concerns For Floridians
December 9, 2014
Need for education clear as confusion, misperception rampant among results. Read More

The Latest

CitrusFeed The People With Food And Food For Thought [Opinion…
December 19, 2014
Educating the general public about agriculture is a daunting task that can be accomplished one bite at a time. Read More
CitrusSouthwest Florida Citrus Bus Tour Yields Learning Oppor…
December 18, 2014
Find out what Florida Grower editor Frank Giles saw and heard during Peace River Valley Citrus Growers Association's annual outing. Read More
CitrusStudy: Florida Citrus Valued At More Than $10 Billion
December 17, 2014
Industry continues to have large impact on the state’s economy. Read More
CitrusUSDA Offers Crop Disaster Assistance For Fruit And Vege…
December 16, 2014
Free basic coverage plans and premium discounts available for new, underserved, and limited income farmers who had been ineligible for federal crop insurance. Read More
CitrusSouth Florida Takes Plunge With Major Expansion Of Wate…
December 15, 2014
New ag land partnerships, including a $124 million deal with Alico, more than double the current holding capacity. Read More
CitrusApplications Now Being Accepted For Florida Specialty C…
December 12, 2014
$4.5 million available to help fund industry-enhancing projects. Read More
CitrusFlorida Citrus Crop Forecast Update: So Far, So Good
December 10, 2014
USDA estimates hold steady for third month in a row. Read More
CitrusFlorida Citrus Hall Of Fame Selects Class Of 2015
December 10, 2014
Three more industry stalwarts added to prestigious list. Read More
CitrusSurvey Shows Food Safety, GMOs Among Public-Issue Conce…
December 9, 2014
Need for education clear as confusion, misperception rampant among results. Read More
CitrusProspects Perking Up For Florida Citrus In 2015 [Opinio…
December 5, 2014
Positive alignment of numerous programs give reason for optimism. Read More
CitrusDemand For Florida Farmland Exceeding Supply 
December 5, 2014
High prices and water shortages in other parts of the country have potential buyers looking to the Sunshine State. Read More
CitrusTrio Of Acquisitions Make Alico Top Citrus Producer In …
December 3, 2014
With growth opportunity in its sights, Florida company pulls trigger on strategic purchases of three local operations totaling more than $360 million for nearly 30,000 acres. Read More
CitrusFlorida Citrus Commission Adds New Member
December 1, 2014
Gov. Rick Scott appoints Dan Casper of Southern Gardens to replace Virginia Pena; reappoints two others. Read More
CitrusJuicy Subjects In Store For 2015 Florida Citrus Show
December 1, 2014
Day 1 of the annual two-day gathering in Ft. Pierce to provide a refresher course on HLB management strategies. Read More
CitrusGenNext Growers Webcast Calls For Action
December 1, 2014
Young leaders need to activate and motivate now more than ever. Read More
CitrusBe Willing To Take A ‘Wild Turkey’ Approach…
November 27, 2014
Editor Frank Giles says Florida Grower will be stepping up to the bully pulpit in 2015 addressing topics that impact the industry the most. Read More
CitrusNew Partnership To Expand ‘Fresh From Florida’ Foot…
November 26, 2014
Latest deal puts exclamation point on successful Asia marketing campaign. Read More
CitrusReasons Aplenty Florida Growers Should Feel Good Going …
November 24, 2014
Thanks to recent industry achievements, the next 12-month period is shaping up to be a year to remember --- fondly. Read More