Future Herbicide Injury Concerns Winegrape Growers

Dicamba injury is seen on a secondnd-leaf grapevine in the Texas High Plains in 2016. (Photo credit: Ed Hellman)

Spray drift is something growers worry about constantly, especially on smaller parcels of land which are near other farmland. As herbicide resistance becomes a greater concern, newer formulas of herbicides are released to offer growers another option to combat resistant broadleaf weeds.

These new dicamba formulations, such as a Monsanto product called Xtendimax with VaporGrip, are said to offer lower drift potential. Another is Dow’s Enlist Duo with 2,4-D and glyphosate with Colex-D technology to also reduce drift. EPA recently amended the current registration for Enlist Duo to make it available in 19 additional states for use on treated corn, soybean, and cotton crops.

“If cotton farmers use Xtendimax according to label directions for use, and are especially cautious near sensitive crops like grapevines, there is will be a low risk of injury to vineyards,” says Ed Hellman, Professor of Viticulture with Texas Tech University.

However, with the release of dicamba-resistant cotton and soybean varieties, specialty crops growers fear cotton and soybean growers will opt for older dicamba products on the market instead of newer dicamba formulations. These new crop varieties require the use of new formulations, but they will likely be more expensive than older formulations.

“The current concern is that row crop use of both 2,4-D and dicamba is expected to increase dramatically in 2017 now that cotton varieties tolerant to these herbicides have been approved for use by EPA,” he says. “This enables cotton farmers to spray either 2,4-D or dicamba, depending on which herbicide-tolerant variety they grow, during most of the growing season rather than only before planting as has been the case previously. From strictly a probability standpoint, it seems likely that increased usage of these herbicides is likely to result in more incidences of off-target spray drift damage to vineyards.”

In fact in 2016, EPA received 117 complaints of dicamba injury in Alabama, Arkansas, Illinois, Kentucky, Minnesota, Mississippi, North Carolina, Tennessee, and Texas. In Missouri alone, EPA reports damage from dicamba misuse was reported on more than 42,000 acres of crops including peaches, tomatoes, cantaloupes, watermelon, peas, and other row crops. Hellman says there were several suspicious incidents of dicamba injury to vineyards in the Texas High Plains last year.

In light of these reports, EPA released a compliance advisory which stated “The EPA has not registered any dicamba herbicides for application at planting or over the top of growing cotton or soybean plants, including crops genetically modified to tolerate dicamba.”

Herbicide-Exposed Vines
Although the severity of dicamba damage to exposed vines varies, grape leaves can be stunted or malformed, which Hellman characterizes as an “upward cupping.” He says shoot growth is stunted and shoot tips can be killed, too.

“If 2,4-D or dicamba exposure occurs during grapevine bloom, fruit set can be reduced. Damaged vines are less able to fully ripen fruit, and a weakened condition may make them more susceptible to other stresses,” he says.

As damaging as 2,4-D and dicamba exposure is, Hellman says this is nothing new to Texas winegrape growers — spray drift is an issue they’re very aware of. In fact, Hellman is a member of the Texas Wine and Grape Growers Association’s 2,4-D Committee.

“2,4-D has commonly been used by row crop farmers practicing no-till or minimum tillage practices and spray drift damage to vineyards has sometimes occurred,” he says. “Reduced tillage row crop farmers use 2,4-D to clean up winter weeds before planting crop seeds. If the row crop farm is near a vineyard and herbicide spraying is done carelessly after grapevines have broken bud, there is the potential for vine injury.”

What Can a Grower do?
A recent story from the Fort Worth Star-Telegram paints a bleak future of the Texas winegrape industry in light of these new formulations. However, researchers and industry groups say the purported demise of the winegrape industry is premature. That’s not to say growers aren’t concerned. But no winegrapes in Texas? That’s a gross overstatement.

These industry groups and researchers say outreach to row crop growers is necessary, and it’s been something Texas grape growers have been working toward, Hellman says.

“Grape producers have worked hard, and mostly successfully, at developing good relations with their neighbors to prevent such accidental off-target spray damage,” he says.

In fact, Andy Timmons, president of the High Plains Wine Growers Association, cites an old proverb of “being a good neighbor increases the value of your property,” when responding to the Star-Telegram’s story on the High Plains Wine Growers Association’s Facebook page. It’s that exact outreach that Timmons says the winegrape industry needs to understand — unlike in other major American Viticultural Areas (AVAs), in the High Plains AVA, row crop and winegrape growers are often one in the same. Singling out a commodity won’t help the end return, he says.

“Many of our largest grape growers are also large scale row crop producers as well,” he says. “We share school boards and church pews as well as the sky above and the dirt below. Each instance is site- and circumstance-specific and that can seem formidable. Together we are responsible and through transparency, communication, and advocacy we’ll go forth.”

Hellman says concerned growers “can also appeal to local retailers of pesticides to be more cautious about selling old, more volatile formulations of dicamba.”

Moving Forward
Hellman says the Texas Wine and Grape Growers Association and its 2,4-D Committee is considering the introduction of legislation to help specialty crop growers.

“The Texas Wine and Grape Growers Association is considering proposing state legislation to restrict the use of these herbicides near sensitive crops. This approach is still under discussion,” he says. “Texas Wine and Grape Growers Association will continue to educate grape producers and the general public about the issue of herbicide spray drift damage.”

Timmons says working together is vital to the Texas agriculture industry.

“It’s important that [consumers] see our two ag sectors coexisting together — versus at opposition. Row crop commodities have made much larger and longer term financial contributions than our new specialty crop.”

Topics: , ,

Leave a Reply

2 comments on “Future Herbicide Injury Concerns Winegrape Growers

  1. Unfortunately, here in Washington State, the reduction of herbicide drift from the levels of the 70’s and 80’s was largely driven by lawsuits.
    Watch your vines, at the first signs of drift affects, document your entire neighborhood. Call the authorities from sherif on up. It is illegal to drift.
    Have a list of numbers to call, including a law firm.
    Ask your neighbors to be careful because you have a highly sensitive crop and don’t want to charge them for its loss.

    1. Your right on Paul. Grape plants are the “parakeet in the mine” so to speak indicator of 2-4D products. Dr Clore made a statement in the 70’s that one tablespoon of Hi vol 24D properly distributed was adequate to injure all grapes grown in the Yakima Valley. With the go forward of the Food Security Act all stewards need to be aware of the damage that can precipitate from improper use of pesticides.

Grapes Stories
Grapes
April 19, 2017
Donnell Brown Named President of National Grape & Wine Initiative
New president brings experience in wine industry communications. Read More
Grapes
March 28, 2017
Understanding the Economics Of Red Blotch in Grapes
An economist and a plant pathologist team up to help growers understand the threshold for action when a vine is diagnosed with the virus. Read More
Grapes
March 6, 2017
Washington Announces Record Winegrape Harvest
‘Cabernet Sauvignon’ is the leading grape variety, accounting for more than a quarter of the total harvest. Read More
Grapes
February 26, 2017
Winegrowers See Total Sustainability in Their Sights
Sonoma County Winegrowers eyes 2019 to become the U.S.’s first completely sustainable wine region. Read More
Grapes
February 18, 2017
Sustainability Is a Growing Factor in Wine Purchasing
California Sustainable Winegrowing Alliance updates certification program, shows sustainability is important part of wine trade. Read More
Grapes
February 17, 2017
Washington Organization Rebrands Itself
Washington Association of Wine Grape Growers unveils new identity at convention, now known as Washington Winegrowers Association. Read More
Grapes
February 14, 2017
2016 California Winegrape Crush Up 9%
Prices were up 12%, and red wine grapes continue to gain on white wine grapes in popularity, though ‘Chardonnay’ remained king. Read More
Grapes
January 30, 2017
Is the Intelligent Vineyard the Future of Winegrape Growing?
In the high desert of Arizona grows the world’s biggest viticulture laboratory. Read More
Grapes
January 30, 2017
Future Herbicide Injury Concerns Winegrape Growers
While new formulas of herbicides are released in conjunction with herbicide-tolerant corn, cotton, and soybean varieties to reduce risk of drift and crop injury, winegrape growers worry some row crop farmers will opt for older formulations. Read More
Grapes
January 27, 2017
How to Match the Fence to Your Vineyard
Follow these tips to determine how much fence you’ll need. Read More
Grapes
January 20, 2017
Live Reports on the State of the Wine Industry
The Unified Wine & Grape Symposium, by far the nation’s largest winegrape conference, is happening this week in Sacramento, CA. Read More
Grapes
January 19, 2017
U.S. Challenges Canadian Trade Measures Allege Discrimination against U.S. Wine
Trade enforcement action challenges British Columbia regulations that unfairly exclude U.S. wine from grocery store shelves. Read More
Grapes
January 6, 2017
Meet Wendy Brannen, New Executive Director of the Lodi Winegrape Commission
Commodity association veteran believes she has found a home with the Lodi Winegrape Commission. Read More
Grapes
January 5, 2017
There are Many Factors Affecting Table Grapes
The loss of table grape berries from their pedicels, or cap stems, during packing, shipping, postharvest storage, or at the Read More
Grapes
January 4, 2017
Grape Growers Say Season Affected by Weather, Water, and Regulation Woes
Grape growers see challenges this past growing season. Read More
The Latest
Grapes
May 19, 2017
Researchers Still Have a Lot to Learn ab…
While some feeding habits have been recognized, there’s still a learning curve with this enigmatic invasive pest. Read More
Grapes
April 25, 2017
Examining the Effectiveness of Biologica…
Growing conditions in the East are breeding grounds for pathogens, and coupled with highly susceptible Vitis vinifera cultivars proves to make sustainable grape growing practices a challenge. Read More
Grapes
April 20, 2017
Would You Be Willing to Pay More for Org…
While consumers might be ready to fork over more for organic produce, study says the feeling isn't quite the same when it comes to the adult beverage. Read More
Grapes
April 19, 2017
Donnell Brown Named President of Nationa…
New president brings experience in wine industry communications. Read More
Grapes
March 28, 2017
Understanding the Economics Of Red Blotc…
An economist and a plant pathologist team up to help growers understand the threshold for action when a vine is diagnosed with the virus. Read More
Grapes
March 6, 2017
Washington Announces Record Winegrape Ha…
‘Cabernet Sauvignon’ is the leading grape variety, accounting for more than a quarter of the total harvest. Read More
Grapes
February 26, 2017
Winegrowers See Total Sustainability in …
Sonoma County Winegrowers eyes 2019 to become the U.S.’s first completely sustainable wine region. Read More
Grapes
February 18, 2017
Sustainability Is a Growing Factor in Wi…
California Sustainable Winegrowing Alliance updates certification program, shows sustainability is important part of wine trade. Read More
Grapes
February 17, 2017
Washington Organization Rebrands Itself
Washington Association of Wine Grape Growers unveils new identity at convention, now known as Washington Winegrowers Association. Read More
Grapes
February 14, 2017
2016 California Winegrape Crush Up 9%
Prices were up 12%, and red wine grapes continue to gain on white wine grapes in popularity, though ‘Chardonnay’ remained king. Read More
Grapes
January 30, 2017
Is the Intelligent Vineyard the Future o…
In the high desert of Arizona grows the world’s biggest viticulture laboratory. Read More
Grapes
January 30, 2017
Future Herbicide Injury Concerns Winegra…
While new formulas of herbicides are released in conjunction with herbicide-tolerant corn, cotton, and soybean varieties to reduce risk of drift and crop injury, winegrape growers worry some row crop farmers will opt for older formulations. Read More
Grapes
January 27, 2017
How to Match the Fence to Your Vineyard
Follow these tips to determine how much fence you’ll need. Read More
Grapes
January 20, 2017
Live Reports on the State of the Wine In…
The Unified Wine & Grape Symposium, by far the nation’s largest winegrape conference, is happening this week in Sacramento, CA. Read More
Grapes
January 19, 2017
U.S. Challenges Canadian Trade Measures …
Trade enforcement action challenges British Columbia regulations that unfairly exclude U.S. wine from grocery store shelves. Read More
Grapes
January 6, 2017
Meet Wendy Brannen, New Executive Direct…
Commodity association veteran believes she has found a home with the Lodi Winegrape Commission. Read More
Grapes
January 5, 2017
There are Many Factors Affecting Table G…
The loss of table grape berries from their pedicels, or cap stems, during packing, shipping, postharvest storage, or at the Read More
Grapes
January 4, 2017
Grape Growers Say Season Affected by Wea…
Grape growers see challenges this past growing season. Read More