New Study On Tomatoes Addresses GM Biochemical Concerns

Does genetic manipulation cause unintended changes in food quality and composition? Are genetically modified (GM) foods less nutritious than their non-GM counterparts, or different in unknown ways?

Despite extensive cultivation and testing of GM foods, those questions still linger in the minds of many consumers. A new study in the March issue of The Plant Genome demonstrates a potentially more powerful approach to answering them.

In research led by Owen Hoekenga, a Cornell University adjunct assistant professor, scientists extracted roughly 1,000 biochemicals, or “metabolites,” from the fruit of tomatoes. These tomatoes had been genetically engineered to delay fruit ripening — a common technique to help keep fruits fresher longer. The researchers then compared this “metabolic profile” from the GM fruit to the profile of its non-GM variety.

Extracting and analyzing hundreds of metabolites at once gives researchers a snapshot of the fruit’s physiology, which can be compared against others.

When the scientists compared the biochemicals of the GM tomato and a wide assortment of other non-GM tomatoes, including modern and heirloom varieties, they found no significant differences overall. Thus, although the GM tomato was distinct from its parent, its metabolic profile still fell within the “normal” range of biochemical diversity exhibited by the larger group of varieties. However, the biochemicals related to fruit ripening did show a significant difference — no surprise because that was the intent of the genetic modification.

The finding suggests little or no accidental biochemical change due to genetic modification in this case, as well as a “useful way to address consumer concerns about unintended effects” in general, Hoekenga says.

He explains that FDA already requires developers of GM crops to compare a handful of key nutritional compounds in GM varieties relative to their non-GM parents. The process is designed to catch instances where genetic manipulation may have affected nutritional quality, for example.

Moreover, comparing a GM variety to diverse cultivars can help scientists and consumers put into context any biochemical changes that are observed. “We accept that there isn’t just one kind of tomato at the farmer’s market. We look for diverse food experiences,” Hoekenga says. “So we think that establishing the range of acceptable metabolic variability [in food] can be useful for examining GM varieties.”

The process was expensive, and the chemistry methods can’t yet be used in official safety assessments, Hoekenga acknowledges. Making statistical comparisons of metabolic “fingerprints” is no easy task. In their study, Hoekenga’s group adapted a style of statistics used in other research.

But the techniques don’t apply only to tomato. “The method can be applied to any plant or crop,” Hoekenga says. “We’ve made something fundamentally useful that anyone can use and improve on.”

When crossing parent plants, for example, breeders often like to track the genes underlying their trait of interest, such as resistance to a pathogen. That’s because pinpointing offspring that carry the right genes is often faster and easier than examining plants for the trait itself.

But sometimes, so many genes contribute to a single trait that figuring out which genes are involved in the first place becomes onerous. This is where Hoekenga thinks his style of research and analysis might one day help. “We’re trying to describe at the biochemical level what might be responsible for a trait. And from that, you could extract genetic information to use in breeding.”

For more information, the full article can be found at: https://www.crops.org/story/2014/apr/thu/a-new-approach-to-detecting-unintended-changes-in-gm-foods

Source: The Crop Science Society of America news release

Topics: ,

Leave a Reply

2 comments on “New Study On Tomatoes Addresses GM Biochemical Concerns

  1. Apparently, all this study says is that a genetically modified tomato is still a tomato. Since ripening is a key element to the nutritional benefits of tomatoes, I wonder did they compare unripe tomaotes to unripe tomatoes? That would not be a useful comparison. Furthermore, what does it meant to say that the ripening biochems are different. That could be an extremely important negative that is just glossed over. From what I can see, this study is useless other than to show that the GM tomato is not a “monster” with unintended chems in it. Finally, it’s the GM foods that grow or allow systemic chemicals (RoundUp and Bt etc) that are really harmful. Considering that no one has studied the long-term effects of RoundUp and Bt ingestion on humans, the crops and products of such crops should be clearly labeled as contaiing RoundUp and Bt (as well as all systemic pesticides used in crop production).

  2. As long as the GM industries and researchers continue to use the phrase “no significant differences” without listing the insignificant differences the public will continue to be sceptical of the work. What is it you people don’t understand about open and comprehensive when it comes to explaining the science? You make the same mistakes over and over again and wonder why the public is suspicious. They have a long history of poor corporate science to to go by that was proven wrong over time causing uncountable harm and death and you still can’t seem to get it right.
    Based on Einstein’s premise it is not insanity to do the same work over and over again expecting a different outcome it is stupidity. Get it right will you.

Tomatoes Stories

TomatoesSeminis Introduces Dixie Red Fresh Tomato Variety
October 7, 2014
New variety features larger fruit, better disease package, and higher yield potential compared to Florida 47 R tomato hybrid. Read More
TomatoesTop 100 Vegetable Grower Jon Esformes Is A Champion For Worker Rights
October 6, 2014
Labor has been at the top of many growers’ minds — for better or for worse — in recent years. Read More
BerriesReal Estate Firm, Wish Farms Strike Large Land Deal
October 1, 2014
$13.8 million transaction includes more than 800 acres acquired from longtime Central Florida produce operation. Read More
TomatoesDrought Update For Fresh And Processed Tomatoes
September 8, 2014
The 2014 production numbers are expected to be the highest on record; however, growers are facing a few challenges from the drought that have some shifting acreage to areas with more water. Read More
Disease ControlBeet Curly Top Virus Is An Unpredictable Disease
September 5, 2014
Researchers are trying to determine the conditions that favored the ‘perfect storm’ for beet curly top virus, which caused $100 million in losses last year. Read More
TomatoesTomatoes: The Most Versatile Of All The Vegetables? [Opinion]
July 28, 2014
Tomatoes offer a variety of culinary options for consumers--from pizza to ice cream, the choices are many. Read More
Protected AgricultureFarm Research Helps New York High Tunnel Tomato Growers With Leaf Mold
July 28, 2014
A four-page fact sheet is available to help high tunnel tomato growers fight leaf mold. Read More

The Latest

TomatoesSeminis Introduces Dixie Red Fresh Tomato Variety
October 7, 2014
New variety features larger fruit, better disease package, and higher yield potential compared to Florida 47 R tomato hybrid. Read More
TomatoesTop 100 Vegetable Grower Jon Esformes Is A Champion For…
October 6, 2014
Labor has been at the top of many growers’ minds — for better or for worse — in recent years. Read More
BerriesReal Estate Firm, Wish Farms Strike Large Land Deal
October 1, 2014
$13.8 million transaction includes more than 800 acres acquired from longtime Central Florida produce operation. Read More
OrganicResearchers Breeding Organic Tomato Varieties Receive $…
October 1, 2014
Purdue University accepts funding to lead multi-institution research to breed organic varieties that will resist foliar diseases. Read More
TomatoesDrought Update For Fresh And Processed Tomatoes
September 8, 2014
The 2014 production numbers are expected to be the highest on record; however, growers are facing a few challenges from the drought that have some shifting acreage to areas with more water. Read More
Disease ControlBeet Curly Top Virus Is An Unpredictable Disease
September 5, 2014
Researchers are trying to determine the conditions that favored the ‘perfect storm’ for beet curly top virus, which caused $100 million in losses last year. Read More
TomatoesProduction Reaches An All-Time High For Processing Toma…
August 29, 2014
A record high is predicted for the 2014 processing tomato crop. Read More
TomatoesScientists Develop Tomato Plant That Can Tolerate 24 Ho…
August 12, 2014
Researchers discover a gene that could allow commercial tomatoes to tolerate light all day and night. Read More
TomatoesTomatoes: The Most Versatile Of All The Vegetables? [Op…
July 28, 2014
Tomatoes offer a variety of culinary options for consumers--from pizza to ice cream, the choices are many. Read More
Protected AgricultureFarm Research Helps New York High Tunnel Tomato Growers…
July 28, 2014
A four-page fact sheet is available to help high tunnel tomato growers fight leaf mold. Read More
TomatoesArcadia Biosciences Receives U.S. Patent For Extended S…
July 25, 2014
The new technology helps vine-ripened tomatoes stay fresh from farm to table. Read More
TomatoesLearn To Manage Late Blight Resistance In Tomatoes
July 25, 2014
Researchers discuss how understanding the genetic changes in the late blight pathogen along with a proactive approach to control may help with resistance issues. Read More
TomatoesTomato And Carrot Flavored Ice Cream Hits Japanese Supe…
July 7, 2014
Häagen-Dazs released its Spoon Vege series of ice cream featuring Tomato Cherry and Carrot Orange flavors. Read More
TomatoesTomato Varieties For 2014
June 23, 2014
Check out a slideshow featuring 19 varieties from leading seed breeders and distributors to add to your collection. Read More
Crop ProtectionNew ‘Tomato MD’ App On Call For Sick Crops
June 17, 2014
Digital-based information resource from American Phytopathological Society available for iPhone and iPad use. Read More
TomatoesFord, Heinz Motivated To Turn Tomatoes Into Auto Parts
June 10, 2014
Skins of the fruit key to sustainability strategy for both companies. Read More
TomatoesManaging Botrytis And Sclerotinia White Mold In High Tu…
June 9, 2014
These two diseases can be severely damaging to tomatoes in protected environments if not managed properly. Read More
Crop ProtectionStudy Reveals Origins Of Late Blight In Potatoes And To…
June 3, 2014
Study traces late blight to South America instead of Mexico, as previously thought, providing key insight to the pathogen’s genetic diversity and behavior. Read More