Up for Debate: Do You Think Hydroponics Should be Considered Organic?

By Greenhouse Grower|February 18, 2022

Over the past year, the Center for Food Safety (CFS) and the Coalition for Sustainable Organics (CSO) have debated whether hydroponics should continue to be eligible for organic certification. The original discussion started when the National Organic Standards Board (NOSB) considered recommending that USDA revoke the ability for hydroponic, aquaponic, aeroponic, and other container-based growing methods to be certified organic.

Recently, the Organic Produce Network provided an update from both sides of the debate. CSO is currently working with a team of lawyers to write an amici curiae (friends of the court) brief in support of hydroponics in organic agriculture. The organization believes hydroponics should continue to be eligible for organic certification for a number of reasons.

“The CSO is all in on the lawsuit,” says CSO Executive Director Lee Frankel, referring to the legal action taken by the Center for Food Safety and several other plaintiffs against the USDA in 2020. The lawsuit came about after CFS filed a petition in 2019 asking the USDA to engage in rulemaking based on the NOSB Spring 2010 formal recommendation to prohibit hydroponics from being eligible for organic certification. (The 2010 NOSB recommendation defined hydroponics as “the production of normally terrestrial, vascular plants in nutrient rich solutions or in an inert, porous, solid matrix bathed in nutrient rich solutions.”)

For more, continue reading at GreenhouseGrower.com.

CEAg World addresses the market trends, challenges, innovations and business implications for the controlled environment industry through in-depth coverage and conversations with emerging and leading perspectives across the ecosystem. It brings thought leadership and context to the expanding global business of growing food under cover and the connective tissues that facilitate its viability and acceleration. Learn more about CEAg World here >

Greenhouse Grower^® and GreenhouseGrower.com represent the best interests of the commercial controlled environment growing industry with a focus on the knowledge and tools to sustain and enhance the sector’s vitality and profitable growth. Its readers are growers of ornamental crops, greenhouse vegetables, cannabis, hemp, and other floriculture crops. See all author stories here.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Hawley Forde says:

February 18, 2022 at 5:23 pm

Should tractors and other mechanical means be allowed to be used in organic farming from the plowing of the fields to the harvesting of the product. One question is as valid as the other concerning organics. Farming evolves as technology evolves. To be ‘fair’ to both sides of the “is it organic or not” question there could be the simple solution of labeling ‘organically grown through hydroponics (OR) aquaponics’. This would also begin to educate the public of the products origin, and that there are viable alternatives to dirt farming.