Opinion: Replanting Citrus Insane, Or Insanely Intelligent?

Paul RusnakSome contend the definition of “insanity” is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results. For the Florida citrus growers out there seeking to replant acreage — especially amid the HLB crisis — many would say you have a certifiable case for committal. The uphill battle producers, packers, and other stakeholders have been enduring since greening’s arrival has and continues to take its toll. To their credit, many different mitigation methods and various stall tactics have been applied to stop the bleeding and hold on until a cure comes. Almost a decade in, and there is still no solution. Yet, there are plenty of growers still willing to do more planting than pushing.
Is this just bullheadedness? Desperation? Orange-colored pipe dreams? All of the above? Maybe for some, but definitely not for all.

Confidence Stirred

Nearly a year ago, it was announced Coca-Cola — in partnership with Cutrale Citrus Juices and Peace River Citrus Products — was investing $2 billion in the state’s citrus industry via a 20-year agreement. The giant-sized ‘Coke and a smile’ looked past greening to greener pastures to the tune of what would be 5 million new citrus trees on 25,000 acres. Almost sounded too good to be true.
Today, the seeds of that promise are taking hold. Duda’s Citrus Division is one of the operations participating in the deal. Lucky for them, right? Yes and no. One major detail is none of the money is seen up front. Appears to be even more of a gamble than what I first thought. However, the company is all in. Duda’s grove manager Rob Atchley says some think they’re “crazy” for putting in so many acres of new trees at this time. But he’s not crazy. He’s confident, not only in being able to harvest a good crop, but also in the industry’s ability to push forward through likely its roughest patch. That’s great to hear. And even better, he’s not alone in his thinking.

Believe It Or Not

Late last summer, Florida Grower polled citrus growers about whether they were actively replanting (resets/blocks) citrus trees. Nearly 89% said that they were. Just recently, FNGLA’s Citrus Nursery Division fished for feedback from nursery owners about several different topics including rootstocks, inventory issues, and HLB challenges. Regarding tree orders, the statistics were telling. Half of respondents said they had increasing tree orders compared to the last couple years; 40% were even; and only 10% reported a decline. The results not only parallel with those of our informal poll, but also to how the industry is proceeding. Whether you see it as crazy for trying or just being insanely confident, much money is being poured in to buoy citrus — well beyond Coca-Cola’s bump. I couldn’t imagine all that time, effort, and cash going to a lost cause. That would just be nutty.

Topics: , ,

Leave a Reply

One comment on “Opinion: Replanting Citrus Insane, Or Insanely Intelligent?

  1. 89% is a huge ratio. If so many people are actively involved in replanting citrus trees then there has to be some amount of benefit attached to it. Undoubtedly the rootstocks, inventory issues, and HLB challenges are important and should not be ignored, but then there are people who have doubled their plantations to face such challenges. Hopefully, investing such a great deal of time, effort and cash won’t be lost in vain; they would definitely be able to harvest a good crop. Cheers!

Citrus Stories
CitrusWestern Growers Praises Introduction Of California Emergency Drought Relief Act
July 30, 2015
Legislation contains short- and long-term provisions to deal with the historic drought. Read More
CitrusGroup Food Safety Audits May Help Prepare You For The Produce Rule
July 29, 2015
Group food safety audits, slated to be available next spring, may save small- to mid-size growers time and money. Read More
CitrusNew Director Named For Florida’s Citrus Research And Education Center
July 28, 2015
Michael Rogers takes a positive charge at finding solutions to greening. Read More
Washington Capitol building
CitrusHouse Passes Bill To Block State GMO Food Labeling Mandates
July 27, 2015
The legislation would offer a federal standard for voluntary labeling of foods containing GMOs.   Read More
Citrus2 Dozen Florida Nurseries Vying For Coveted Cannabis Growing Licenses
July 27, 2015
With only five spots available to produce the low-THC ‘Charlotte’s Web’ strain, tedious review process is in full swing. Read More
Insect & Disease UpdateSecond Case In A Month Of Citrus Greening In California
July 24, 2015
More trees testing positive for disease within close proximity of original find. Read More
CitrusUSDA Expands Crop Insurance Options For Fruit And Nut Growers
July 24, 2015
The USDA announced the expansion of crop insurance to provide additional options for fruit and nut producers. The Supplemental Coverage Read More
The Latest
woman smashing an alarm clock with a hammer
CitrusDon’t Become A Time Crunch Casualty
July 31, 2015
Finding the balance between work life and home life is easier said than done for GenNext Growers. Read More
money
CitrusBankrupt Florida Farm To Yield Plenty Of Land, Equipmen…
July 30, 2015
As many as seven different buyers could be part of this Chapter 11 proceeding. Read More
CitrusWestern Growers Praises Introduction Of California Emer…
July 30, 2015
Legislation contains short- and long-term provisions to deal with the historic drought. Read More
CitrusGroup Food Safety Audits May Help Prepare You For The P…
July 29, 2015
Group food safety audits, slated to be available next spring, may save small- to mid-size growers time and money. Read More
CitrusNew Director Named For Florida’s Citrus Research And Ed…
July 28, 2015
Michael Rogers takes a positive charge at finding solutions to greening. Read More
Washington Capitol building
CitrusHouse Passes Bill To Block State GMO Food Labeling Mand…
July 27, 2015
The legislation would offer a federal standard for voluntary labeling of foods containing GMOs.   Read More
Citrus2 Dozen Florida Nurseries Vying For Coveted Cannabis Gr…
July 27, 2015
With only five spots available to produce the low-THC ‘Charlotte’s Web’ strain, tedious review process is in full swing. Read More
CitrusUSDA Expands Crop Insurance Options For Fruit And Nut G…
July 24, 2015
The USDA announced the expansion of crop insurance to provide additional options for fruit and nut producers. The Supplemental Coverage Read More
FFVA 2015 Annual Convention logo
CitrusFlorida Fruit & Vegetable Association Annual Conven…
July 23, 2015
Association's 72nd gathering to feature high-profile speakers, up-to-the-minute Issues Forums, and some fun to mix in with the business of the day. Read More
CitrusMarketing Order Amendments Referendum Set For Fresh Flo…
July 22, 2015
Changes include the authorization and regulation of new varieties. Read More
Shannon Shepp
CitrusInterim Executive Director Named For Florida Department…
July 22, 2015
Shannon Shepp will take on leadership duties immediately after unanimous Citrus Commission vote. Read More
CitrusInternational Report Confirms 2014 As Earth’s Warmest Y…
July 21, 2015
Scientific compilation notes climate markers continue to show global warming trend. Read More
non-gmo label leafy greens
CitrusGMO Labeling Battle Moves To House Floor
July 21, 2015
The Safe and Accurate Food Labeling Act of 2015 was passed by the Agriculture Committee last week and will head Read More
Doug Ackerman
CitrusFlorida Department Of Citrus Executive Director Resigns
July 21, 2015
Doug Ackerman steps down after traffic incident. Read More
CitrusWOTUS Wranglings Leaving Agriculture High And Dry [Opin…
July 17, 2015
In late May, the EPA announced the highly anticipated final rule re-defining the waters of the United States (WOTUS) under Read More
man expressing opinion through bullhorn
CitrusStay Opinionated, My Farmer Friends
July 15, 2015
How far are you willing to go to defend your beliefs? Read More
CitrusSouth Florida Water Managers Keeping Close Eye On Dry C…
July 15, 2015
Traditional wet season has been anything but so far as certain parts of the region now experiencing “extreme drought.” Read More
Washington Capitol building
CitrusUnited Fresh Washington Conference Connects You With Ke…
July 14, 2015
United Fresh has announced the Washington Conference, which will be held Sept. 28-30 in Washington D.C. The conference offers an Read More