Take A Closer Look At The Tall Spindle Axe Training System

In the January issue, I covered some of the results through six years of the NC-140 Sweet Cherry Canopy Architecture and Rootstock Trials in North America. Over the course of the next several columns, I will explore each of these intensive training systems in that trial in more depth. This month will focus on the Tall Spindle Axe (TSA), one of the more traditional of the three-dimensional canopies, which has demonstrated good early and sustained yields in the trial thus far.

 

Notice the branch angles in this photo of a TSA growing system. (Photo credit: Greg Lang)
Notice the branch angles in this photo of a TSA growing system. (Photo credit: Greg Lang)

The Basics of TSA
The TSA utilizes the classic “fruiting unit” of sweet cherry trees (see Growth Progression diagram): a 3-year-old section of branch that contains fruiting spurs (multiple fruit buds and leaves at each node on wood beginning its third growing season), non-spur fruits (single flower buds, with no vegetative bud) and non-fruiting spur leaves on wood a year younger, and large single leaves on current season new shoot growth. Older branches contain these same fruit and leaf populations, plus older fruiting spurs since spurs can remain productive as long as their light environment remains favorable. The non-spur fruit is usually of the best quality (size and sweetness) while the more abundant spur fruit provides the best yield potential.

The TSA could be viewed simply as part of the ongoing evolution of various central leader tree architectures, such as the Zahn spindle and Vogel central leader canopies, which adapt readily to higher planting densities and create good light distribution throughout the canopy. In their natural forest habitat, sweet cherry trees tend to develop a central leader shape due to strong apical dominance — the ability of the terminal growing point(s) to inhibit outgrowth of lower lateral growing points.

Survival is improved by competing aggressively for light with surrounding trees, so the terminal shoot grows vigorously toward the top of the forest canopy. Several strong lateral shoots develop each spring primarily just below the new growth of the terminal, capturing as much light as high as possible in the canopy to compete with or shade out neighboring trees, at the expense of previously developed lower shoots that eventually become shaded and unproductive.

The Early Spindle Days
In the 1980s and 1990s, German pomologists such as Fritz Zahn and Tobias Vogel were familiar with the economic advantages that dwarfing rootstocks and higher tree densities were having in apple production. They began training cherry tree canopies to spindle (Christmas tree-like) shapes as well. These canopies required annual heading or bud-scoring to break the apical dominance and initiate lower lateral branches, and removal of the upper buds that otherwise would have grown into strong branches, shading upper lateral branches. Initially these utilized standard Mazzard seedlings or Colt rootstocks, the latter of which provided a modest amount of vigor control when grown without irrigation.

The adoption of spindle cherry canopies advanced significantly as new precocious and dwarfing cherry rootstocks from the University of Giessen, aka the Gisela series, became commercially available in the 1990s. Not only did these rootstocks promote very early flowering, provide various levels of vigor control, and yield prodigiously, they also exhibited a bit less apical dominance. This resulted in easier lateral branch formation and wider branch angles to better achieve the spindle shape (see Branch Angles diagram) desired for good light interception and distribution (and therefore good fruitfulness) from the top of the canopy to the bottom.

Spindle canopies evolved further in the 2000s, again following apple training systems, first as the French Solaxe and later as the Tall Spindle from the U.S. The Solaxe focused on minimal heading cuts and pendant orientation of long lateral branches, often through tying down, which ultimately resulted in fruit borne primarily on spurs and supported primarily by spur leaves. However, in cherry, fruit quality tended to decline as the Solaxe branches aged and required spur thinning to improve leaf-to-fruit ratios.

Tall Spindle Axe GrowthHow TSA Impacts Leaf Area
TSA cherry training promotes the use of heading cuts to the previous year’s terminal shoots. This stimulates lateral branching (increasing leaf area, especially larger new shoot leaves compared to smaller spur leaves), maintains a favorable mix of spur and basal solitary fruit buds, and just as importantly, pre-emptively removes future densely-spaced spurs (reducing crop load) to yield a more balanced leaf-to-fruit ratio. Any upright, pendant, or overlapping lateral branches are removed via thinning cuts to maintain good light distribution. Thus, several significant crop and tree management tasks are accomplished entirely through specific pruning decisions.

TSA tree maintenance borrows the concept of selective fruiting limb renewal from the Kym Green Bush (KGB) cherry training system. In general, each year the largest limb on the leader should be cut back to a stub, preferably with a visible bud or young lateral shoot, to promote the continuous re-development of a relatively young population of fruiting spurs, to eliminate old spurs, and to maintain good light distribution throughout the canopy so that future buds for fruiting and renewal do not become too shaded. Likewise, adequate vigor must be maintained through good nutrition and irrigation, particularly on more dwarfing rootstocks like Gi.3, in order to achieve consistent and strong renewal.

While similar, TSA cherry training differs from Tall Spindle apple training in several ways. First, is the fact that the requisite well-feathered nursery trees for establishing Tall Spindle apple orchards generally are not available for cherry in the U.S. Second, there is no tying down of new branches or “columnarization” (removal of secondary lateral branches, leaving only spurs) of fruiting branches in cherry as there is in apple. These manipulations would shift the canopy too much toward a Solaxe-like fruiting relationship.

Topics: , ,

Leave a Reply

Stone Fruit Stories
Freeze protected blueberry bushes in Florida
Berries
March 25, 2017
Florida Blueberry Crop Escapes Slap from Late-Season Cold Snap
Freeze protection tactics prove fruitful as local producers look to gain from Georgia’s loss. Read More
Frozen blueberries
Berries
March 15, 2017
Arctic Blast Gives Southern Fruit Growers the Chills
Peaches and berries in bloom most at risk from freezing temperatures. Read More
UFGem peach variety
Marketing
March 15, 2017
Florida Peaches Scoring Points with Consumers on the Go
Snack-sized fruit presents unique marketing opportunity for growers. Read More
Mycelial fans armillaria root rot
Nuts
February 27, 2017
Getting to the Root of Devastating Stone Fruit Fungus
Armillaria root rot is a death sentence for trees and replant sites; however, researchers are looking to breed fungus-resistant rootstocks to make replanting economically feasible. Read More
Florida potato field in bloom.
Citrus
February 22, 2017
New Insecticide Available to Combat Sucking, Chewing Pests
Minecto Pro from Syngenta has received EPA approval for use in specialty and vegetable crops to control lepidopteran and other pests. Read More
Stone Fruit
February 14, 2017
Georgia Peach Growers Brace for Low Chill Hours
Last year trees netted almost 700 chill hours; however, Extension agent expects that figure to drop to 600 hours this year. Read More
a trio of peaches
Stone Fruit
February 4, 2017
Clemson Researchers Hope to Breed Tastier, Healthy Peaches
Health boosting, more flavorful stone fruit will hopefully be on the horizon thanks to new grant. Read More
Stone Fruit
January 28, 2017
Take a Close Look at Super Spindle Axe
Fruiting walls can help tame the vigor of early cropping systems. Read More
Stone Fruit
January 3, 2017
State of the Industry: Stone Fruit Growers are Optimistic
Only in the Northeast, where a wicked frost wiped out many growers’ crops, are there major concerns. Read More
Apple Grower of the Year
December 6, 2016
2014 Apple Grower Of The Year Bill Evans Dies
Legendary apple grower Bill Evans, who along with his wife, Jeannette, farmed more apple acreage than any grower in the Read More
Stone Fruit
December 2, 2016
Managing Risks And Reward Of Going High Density In Michigan
The King family sees dwarfing high-density system as the future of their sweet cherry production. Read More
Stone Fruit
November 29, 2016
Going High Density In Tart Cherries
Grower’s take on a high-density system meant modifying a berry harvester to fit his system. Read More
Disease Control
November 28, 2016
Tips To Keep Your Stone Fruit Orchard Clean
Managing serious plant diseases of peach and plums requires a cooperative approach. Read More
Labor
November 1, 2016
Michigan Tree Fruit Commission Helps Research Station Obtain New Orchard Platform
Funding to help increase efficiency, make data collection easier. Read More
Stone Fruit
October 28, 2016
Cherry Training Systems From Traditional To Transformative
Early and sustained yields can be achieved with upright fruiting offshoots system. Read More
The Latest
Stone Fruit
May 8, 2017
USDA Researchers Say Georgia Peach Crop …
Spring freeze, not enough chill hours make for a tough growing season. Read More
Stone Fruit
April 29, 2017
Challenging Cherry Disease Keeps Growers…
With a few years of experience with more is understood about little cherry disease, however, few unknowns remain. Read More
Stone Fruit
March 29, 2017
Plum Varieties are Complex and Fascinati…
While diversity in species gives the consumer many options, plums can be a challenge for growers and marketers. Read More
Berries
March 25, 2017
Florida Blueberry Crop Escapes Slap from…
Freeze protection tactics prove fruitful as local producers look to gain from Georgia’s loss. Read More
Berries
March 15, 2017
Arctic Blast Gives Southern Fruit Grower…
Peaches and berries in bloom most at risk from freezing temperatures. Read More
Marketing
March 15, 2017
Florida Peaches Scoring Points with Cons…
Snack-sized fruit presents unique marketing opportunity for growers. Read More
Nuts
February 27, 2017
Getting to the Root of Devastating Stone…
Armillaria root rot is a death sentence for trees and replant sites; however, researchers are looking to breed fungus-resistant rootstocks to make replanting economically feasible. Read More
Citrus
February 22, 2017
New Insecticide Available to Combat Suck…
Minecto Pro from Syngenta has received EPA approval for use in specialty and vegetable crops to control lepidopteran and other pests. Read More
Stone Fruit
February 14, 2017
Georgia Peach Growers Brace for Low Chil…
Last year trees netted almost 700 chill hours; however, Extension agent expects that figure to drop to 600 hours this year. Read More
Stone Fruit
February 4, 2017
Clemson Researchers Hope to Breed Tastie…
Health boosting, more flavorful stone fruit will hopefully be on the horizon thanks to new grant. Read More
Stone Fruit
January 28, 2017
Take a Close Look at Super Spindle Axe
Fruiting walls can help tame the vigor of early cropping systems. Read More
Stone Fruit
January 3, 2017
State of the Industry: Stone Fruit Growe…
Only in the Northeast, where a wicked frost wiped out many growers’ crops, are there major concerns. Read More
Apple Grower of the Year
December 6, 2016
2014 Apple Grower Of The Year Bill Evans…
Legendary apple grower Bill Evans, who along with his wife, Jeannette, farmed more apple acreage than any grower in the Read More
Stone Fruit
December 2, 2016
Managing Risks And Reward Of Going High …
The King family sees dwarfing high-density system as the future of their sweet cherry production. Read More
Stone Fruit
November 29, 2016
Going High Density In Tart Cherries
Grower’s take on a high-density system meant modifying a berry harvester to fit his system. Read More
Disease Control
November 28, 2016
Tips To Keep Your Stone Fruit Orchard Cl…
Managing serious plant diseases of peach and plums requires a cooperative approach. Read More
Labor
November 1, 2016
Michigan Tree Fruit Commission Helps Res…
Funding to help increase efficiency, make data collection easier. Read More
Stone Fruit
October 28, 2016
Cherry Training Systems From Traditional…
Early and sustained yields can be achieved with upright fruiting offshoots system. Read More