Tree Fruit: Breeding For Disease Resistance Is A Difficult But Worthy Task

Desmond LayneIf you have read any of my columns over the last 10 years, you know the strong emphasis I place on properly choosing the best cultivar for your location, growing conditions, ripening season, and market.

I wonder, though, when you are considering planting an orchard to a new apple, pear, cherry, or peach cultivar, what are the primary criteria that you use to make this decision? Is resistance to disease on the list? How is the decision impacted if the fruit are destined for the conventional versus organic fresh market? How is the decision impacted if the fruit are destined for local retail markets versus national or even international wholesale markets (e.g., where pesticide residue levels are a significant concern for importers)? What if the fruit will be used primarily or secondarily for value-added products (i.e., fresh cut, canned, brined, frozen, or made into cider, sauce, pie filling, or baby food)?

As you address these and other questions, how important is the fact that a new cultivar is resistant (or not) to one or more primary diseases?

For apples and pears, this could be resistance to fire blight or scab. For cherries, it could be resistance to powdery mildew or leaf spot. For peaches, it could be resistance to bacterial spot or brown rot.

The economic losses that occur from these diseases and the costs associated with trying to control them can be enormous. Does the potential for pathogen resistance development to the limited registered fungicides and bactericides or even the future accessibility to those products weigh into your cultivar choices? Does the expense associated with managing these diseases enter into the cost/benefit analysis you make in choosing new cultivars for your operation?

Challenges In Developing Disease-Resistant Cultivars
For decades, various tree fruit breeding programs around the world have worked hard to develop disease-resistant cultivars. While several resultant cultivars have been released with enhanced tolerance or even resistance to one or more of these primary diseases, they represent a distinct minority of the cultivars offered by most U.S. wholesale nurseries. Often, these resistant/tolerant cultivars are planted in smaller acreages and are designated for a particular market niche.

Why is this? Sometimes, the grower’s reason for not choosing them is because of some real or perceived deficiency in one or more critical production or quality factors (e.g., reliability of cropping, biennial bearing, fruit appearance, color, size, sweetness, maintaining firmness, ripe date, sensitivity to bruising, rate of softening, postharvest storage performance, etc.).

When compared with the other disease-susceptible cultivars that may have both high consumer appeal and price points, it may be worth taking the risk to grow the latter!

Or, it may be that resistance to only one disease while susceptibility to another may not provide sufficient economic benefit if there are other deficient factors as already noted. In some cases, single site resistance mechanisms in resistant cultivars have been overcome by the pathogen over time (e.g., the Vf resistance gene for apple scab, Venturia inaequalis).

I was acutely aware of the challenges for disease management while previously working with peach growers in the humid Southeastern U.S. There were no commercially relevant cultivars that were resistant to brown rot (Monilinia fructicola) fungus and many that were grown were highly susceptible to bacterial spot (Xanthomonas arboricola pv. pruni) disease. I watched as the acreage planted to bacterial-spot-sensitive cultivars bred in California was increasing rapidly, the incidence of bacterial spot disease was increasing, and the grower “spray bill” to combat this disease was skyrocketing.

To complicate matters further, based on conversations with Clemson University’s Dr. Guido Schnabel it appeared that peach brown rot management was becoming increasingly more difficult because of rising resistance in the brown rot fungus to different and important classes of fungicides.

Finding A Solution In Genes
So what are public fruit breeders at the Land-Grant universities and USDA-ARS doing to help? One powerful solution is genetic, minimizing the need for sprays, dips and other cultural management practices to ward off infection.

With all of the modern DNA-based tools and techniques and access to disease-resistant germplasm from the centers of origin of these crops, do breeders have all the tools needed in their toolboxes to miraculously provide growers with the new “bullet proof” apple, pear, cherry, or peach cultivars with superior productivity and fruit quality?

The obvious answer is no. Although the potential return on investment is huge, breeding programs are typically long-term, diverse and complex, labor-intensive, and expensive to run. Relying only on performance results of the parents, the odds are against any single cross providing an eventual superior new release.

Federally funded efforts such as the 2009-2014 USDA-National Institute of Food and Agriculture (NIFA) Specialty Crop Research Initiative, RosBREED project, have brought together conventional breeders, allied scientists, Extension professionals, students, and industry stakeholders to develop and use genetic markers for economically important attributes.

This allows the breeding programs to make more creative, accurate, and efficient progress in their efforts to provide sustained genetic solutions to industry challenges and consumer demands. In contrast to the past when many breeding programs were more independent of each other and there was limited sharing of resources and technology, now there is a strong community of faculty, students and stakeholders working together on opportunities and talking with each other about future ideas and goals.

With An Eye To The Future
An ambitious goal being discussed now is the combination in new cultivars of both disease resistance (to multiple critical threats) and superior fruit quality. To date, this grand union has been unattainable by fruit breeders. But strong momentum in collaboration, resources, tools, knowledge, and scientific understanding may make this a viable outcome in the near future.

So you might ask, what can I do to help? For one, you can intentionally interact with breeders and Extension faculty to let them know about your issues, concerns, and problems. You can volunteer to participate as part of a breeding program advisory committee. You can attend summer field days (or other times of the year) when fruit of superior selections are made available for tasting and evaluating and you can provide input.

In some cases, you may be able to participate with breeders to host a trial site on your farm where advanced selections can be compared with industry standard cultivars. Further, you can communicate with university and government officials to thank them for supporting fruit breeding programs and specialty crop research (e.g., the recently signed 2014 Farm Bill) and be a willing industry stakeholder partner for future grant-funded projects in your region.

Topics: , , ,

Leave a Reply

Apples & Pears Stories
Apples & Pears
August 26, 2017
‘EverCrisp’ Apple gets PLU Approval
Midwest Apple Improvement Association prepares for large harvest and larger distribution reach for first variety released. Read More
Apple Grower of the Year
August 22, 2017
U.S. Apple Association Hosts Annual Apple Outlook Conference in Chicago
American Fruit Grower® and Western Fruit Grower® magazine’s 2017 Apple Grower of the Year will be officially presented on Thursday, Aug. 24, during the first day of the conference. Read More
Apples & Pears
August 20, 2017
APHIS Seeks Comments on Risk Removal for Dormant Apple Cuttings
Dormant live cuttings from countries in the European Union must currently go through pest risk assessment. Read More
Apples & Pears
August 15, 2017
Wet Weather Breeds Phytophthora in Young Apple Plantings
Crown rot, root rot flourishing in very wet growing season. Read More
Apples & Pears
August 9, 2017
2017 Washington Apple Crop Down Slightly
Forecasted harvest predicted to be 131 million boxes, down 1.2% from 2016. Read More
Apples & Pears
August 5, 2017
Penn State University Develops Bitter Pit Prediction Model
Research team unlocks relationship between bitter pit, minerals, and shoot lengths. Read More
Apples & Pears
August 1, 2017
New York Growers’ Input Needed on Apple Tree Decline
Project has begun to identify rapid collapse and chronic decline being found in young Eastern apple orchards. Read More
Apples & Pears
July 25, 2017
Tips to Transition to an Apple Fruiting Wall System
Follow these suggestions to make the move from a 3-D spindle-shaped canopy to a 2-D system using mechanical pruning. Read More
Apples & Pears
June 30, 2017
Tackling the Challenges of Organic Apple Production Head-on
Researchers at Michigan State University test organic controls for fire blight. Read More
Apples & Pears
June 29, 2017
Integrating Control Methods to Tackle Fire Blight
Fire blight is a damaging disease, no matter the location. Most production areas of the Pacific Northwest and California experience Read More
Apples & Pears
June 28, 2017
Apple Tree Insurance Program Being Developed
U.S. Apple Association working with AgriLogic Consulting, LLC and USDA Risk Management Agency to offer new risk management option which takes into effect weather damage and fire blight loses. Read More
Apples & Pears
June 26, 2017
Cosmic Changes Coming in Apple Production [Opinion]
‘Cosmic Crisp’ is an apt moniker for Washington’s new apple, because the changes coming to the industry are immense Read More
Apples & Pears
June 23, 2017
Take Advantage of Technology to Help Manage Diseases, Pest Pressure
Expert farm advisers provide several options for apple orchard management decisions. Read More
Apples & Pears
June 19, 2017
Bee-ware: New Resources Released for National Pollinator Week
New videos, webinars available during week-long observance. Read More
The Latest
Apples & Pears
September 22, 2017
Media Reflects Modern Society [Opinion]
Little about fruit growing — or any agriculture — appears because too few of us are willing to illuminate the media. Read More
Apples & Pears
September 16, 2017
Researcher Finds Bacteria Can Stop Blue …
The natural bacterium found in soil can survive in cold storage; this promising biocontrol offers an alternative to chemical treatments. Read More
Apples & Pears
September 5, 2017
Pears Finding Home in Fermentation
Perry, a fermented beverage similar to hard apple cider, is gaining popularity in the U.S., and growers are learning about the production process from square one. Read More
Apples & Pears
August 26, 2017
‘EverCrisp’ Apple gets PLU Approval
Midwest Apple Improvement Association prepares for large harvest and larger distribution reach for first variety released. Read More
Apple Grower of the Year
August 22, 2017
U.S. Apple Association Hosts Annual Appl…
American Fruit Grower® and Western Fruit Grower® magazine’s 2017 Apple Grower of the Year will be officially presented on Thursday, Aug. 24, during the first day of the conference. Read More
Apples & Pears
August 20, 2017
APHIS Seeks Comments on Risk Removal for…
Dormant live cuttings from countries in the European Union must currently go through pest risk assessment. Read More
Apples & Pears
August 15, 2017
Wet Weather Breeds Phytophthora in Young…
Crown rot, root rot flourishing in very wet growing season. Read More
Apples & Pears
August 9, 2017
2017 Washington Apple Crop Down Slightly
Forecasted harvest predicted to be 131 million boxes, down 1.2% from 2016. Read More
Apples & Pears
August 5, 2017
Penn State University Develops Bitter Pi…
Research team unlocks relationship between bitter pit, minerals, and shoot lengths. Read More
Apples & Pears
August 1, 2017
New York Growers’ Input Needed on Apple …
Project has begun to identify rapid collapse and chronic decline being found in young Eastern apple orchards. Read More
Apples & Pears
July 25, 2017
Tips to Transition to an Apple Fruiting …
Follow these suggestions to make the move from a 3-D spindle-shaped canopy to a 2-D system using mechanical pruning. Read More
Apples & Pears
July 6, 2017
International Fruit Tree Association See…
Deadline for proposals is July 31. Read More
Apples & Pears
June 30, 2017
Tackling the Challenges of Organic Apple…
Researchers at Michigan State University test organic controls for fire blight. Read More
Apples & Pears
June 29, 2017
Integrating Control Methods to Tackle Fi…
Fire blight is a damaging disease, no matter the location. Most production areas of the Pacific Northwest and California experience Read More
Apples & Pears
June 28, 2017
Apple Tree Insurance Program Being Devel…
U.S. Apple Association working with AgriLogic Consulting, LLC and USDA Risk Management Agency to offer new risk management option which takes into effect weather damage and fire blight loses. Read More
Apples & Pears
June 26, 2017
Cosmic Changes Coming in Apple Productio…
‘Cosmic Crisp’ is an apt moniker for Washington’s new apple, because the changes coming to the industry are immense Read More
Apples & Pears
June 23, 2017
Take Advantage of Technology to Help Man…
Expert farm advisers provide several options for apple orchard management decisions. Read More
Apples & Pears
June 19, 2017
Bee-ware: New Resources Released for Nat…
New videos, webinars available during week-long observance. Read More