What Are the Best Herbicides for Threespike Goosegrass?

What Are the Best Herbicides for Threespike Goosegrass?

Threespike goosegrass

The most distinguishable attribute of this species is its finger-like spikes of threespike goosegrass (E. tristachya).
Photo courtesy of University of California, Davis

Threespike goosegrass was first reported in California in 1967. Since then, this species has become a significant concern in almonds and other orchard cropping systems throughout the Central Valley, primarily because of its lifecycle, stature, and poor control with glyphosate. Vigorous grasses like threespike goosegrass are particularly problematic during the first four years of orchard establishment due to their ability to reduce tree growth by directly competing for water and nutrients, and indirectly by interfering with irrigation distribution uniformity. Once the trees reach bearing age, the tufted growth habit of threespike goosegrass can reduce harvest efficiency by making it more difficult to recover nuts from the orchard floor.

Threespike goosegrass (Eleusine trystachya) is a low-growing, coarsely tufted, warm-season perennial grass, which has a prominent fold at the mid rib in young leaves that flatten when mature. The most distinguishable attribute of this species is its finger-like spikes. This species is often misidentified due to its common name and for being closely related to the highly successful invasive, goosegrass (Eleusine indica).


However, there are some major phenological and morphological differences. Goosegrass is a large stature and erect annual with larger spikes, generally having five to eight spikes which are 1.5 to 6 inches long. Threespike goosegrass has a more compact inflorescence and fewer spikes (two to four) which are shorter, typically 0.4 to 1.2 inches.

Orchard Weed Management Trials
When selecting an integrated weed management strategy for this species, options may vary from orchard to orchard and may be influenced by geographic location, climatic conditions, soil texture and profile, irrigation practices, topography, cost, and grower preferences. A good orchard weed management program is composed of preventative strategies, orchard floor management (including cultural, mechanical, chemical, and biological methods), and weed monitoring. The proper use of pre- and postemergence herbicides and timely discing and cultivation are important factors in weed management.

For this study, two field trials were conducted in 2018 to evaluate the performance of several pre-emergent (PRE) and post-emergent (POST) herbicides on threespike goosegrass: one in a walnut orchard at the CSU Chico Agriculture and Teaching Center in Chico, CA, and the other in a commercial almond orchard near Livingston, CA. Both locations had medium tohigh infestations of threespike goosegrass. Herbicide treatments were applied with a CO2 pressurized backpack sprayer, calibrated to deliver 30 GPA at 30 PSI through three TeeJet XR11003 flat fan nozzles. The herbicide treatments (Tables 1 & 2) were applied in a five-foot band on both sides of the tree row.

Pre-Emergency Study
Data collection included visual assessments at monthly intervals for PREs, starting one month after the January 2018 application and continued for five months. One treatment included an additional PRE-application in March as part of a sequential herbicide program. The purpose of this sequential approach was to apply a second PRE-herbicide closer to germination and emergence of this warm season grass, rather than relying on a single winter application. POST treatments were applied in May 2018 and control assessments were conducted at weekly intervals, starting one week after application for approximately one month. Threespike goosegrass control was estimated using a 0 to 100 scale, where 0 means no control and 100 means plants were completely killed.

PRE-emergent treatments* (Applied January 2018)
Active Ingredient Trade Name Rate (product/A) Herbicide Efficacy 5 MAT**
Flazasulfuron Mission 2.85 oz 47.8
Rimsulfuron Matrix 4 oz 50.3
Oryzalin Surflan 4 qt 54.3
oxyfluorfen + oryzalin Goal + Surflan 5 pt + 4 qt 60.3
penoxsulam + oxyfluorfen Pindar GT 2 pt 61.3
indaziflam + rimsulfuron Alion + Matrix 3.5 fl oz + 4 oz 62.8
Indaziflam Alion 3.5 fl oz 65.8
flumioxazin + pendimethalin Chateau + Prowl H2O 10 oz + 4 qt 69.8
Pendimethalin Prowl H2O 4 qt 71.8
penoxsulam + oxyfluorfen Pindar GT 3 pt 73.8
Indaziflam Alion 5 fl oz 74.5
indaziflam fb pendimethalin*** Alion fb Prowl H2O*** 3.5 fl oz + 3 qt 90.1

AMS (1% v/v), NIS (0.25 % v/v), and Rely 280 (32 fl oz/A) were added to treatments according to label recommendations.
** MAT= Months After Treatment. *** fb = “followed by” applied in March.

Multiple PRE herbicides in these trials, including Alion (Bayer CropScience), Prowl H2O (BASF), and Pindar GT (Corteva Agriscience) provided adequate control of seedling threespike goosegrass. The greatest control of this warm season perennial was obtained with the sequential application of Alion followed by Prowl H2O, presumably due to the second PRE-herbicide applied late March closer to germination and emergence of this warm season grass, rather than relying on extended residual activity from a single winter application.

Results from this study suggest that a management plan utilizing a PRE-herbicide applied later in the spring may minimize seedling recruitment of this species.

Post-Emergence Study
POST herbicide data collected (Table 2) in the 2018 field trials confirmed that threespike goosegrass is extremely tolerant to glyphosate. Even when Roundup Weathermax (Bayer CropScience) was applied at the higher rate of 2 qt/A, threespike goosegrass control did not exceed 54% and many plants recovered and later produced new shoots and panicles. The graminicides tested, Fusilade (Syngenta), Select Max (Valent USA), and Poast (BASF) provided the greatest POST control of threespike goosegrass. Of these, Fusilade was the most effective in this study, resulting in up to 92% control five weeks after treatment.

POST-emergent treatments* (Applied May 2018)
Active Ingredient Trade Name Rate (product/A) Herbicide Efficacy 5 MAT**
glyphosate + rimsulfuron WM + Matrix 1 qt + 2 oz 37.4
glyphosate (1X) Roundup Weathermax (WM) 1 qt 45.5
glyphosate (2X) Roundup WM 2 qt 54.4
glyphosate + oxyfluorfen WM + GoalTender 1 qt + 0.5 pt 57.3
glyphosate + glufosinate WM + Rely280 1 qt + 2 qt 67.4
sethoxydim Poast 2 pt 75.5
clethodim SelectMax 12 fl oz 82.5
fluazifop Fusilade 12 fl oz 90.9

NIS (0.25 % v/v) OR MSO (1% v/v) were added to treatments according to label recommendations. ** WAT= Weeks After Treatment.

Overall, the field trials conducted in this study determined that in areas where this warm season grass species was the most concerning, the greatest control was obtained by shifting some of the PRE herbicide components to target the germination of the summer species, rather than trying to achieve summer weed control with only the PRE herbicides applied in the winter. There also are a number of effective post-emergent herbicides to keep in the toolbox.

Effective control includes careful consideration the biology of the weed, weed-control goals, and the weed-management tools at your disposal. Remember to rotate herbicide modes of action and to monitor after herbicide application to prevent the appearance of herbicide resistance or tolerance, such as the high level of tolerance exhibited by threespike goosegrass to glyphosate treatments shown in this study.