Grower Vows To Fight Clean Water Act Violation Suit

The story of John Duarte and 450 acres in Northern California is a complicated matter. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers says it’s a tale of a clear violation of the Clean Water Act. Duarte, on the other hand, says the real story is about assumptions and overreach by the government.“I call it peeling the onion because this thing goes so many layers deep,” he says.

John Duarte
John Duarte

Duarte is owner of Duarte Nursery, one of the largest grapevine and nut tree suppliers on the West Coast.
In 2012, he purchased 450 acres in Tehama County that, according to Duarte, had been in the USDA’s Conservation Reserve Program under previous owners.

In 2012, he purchased 450 acres in Tehama County that, according to Duarte, had been in the USDA’s Conservation Reserve Program under previous owners.

The land had been planted with wheat many times, Duarte says. And a portion of adjoining land was farmed as late as 2011. As part of the land purchase, NorthStar Engineering, an environmental consulting firm, mapped buffers around the wetlands that were a part of the property.

“We consider ourselves accomplished ecologists when it comes to agricultural production,” Duarte says. “This land is over-farmed wetland. It has been planted to wheat before and had been used as grazing ground for a few decades.”

NorthStar found vernal pools, vernal swales, seasonal wetlands, seasonal swales and other waters which are considered pre-jurisdictional waters of the U.S., and would fall under the Clean Water Act

Tilling Or Ripping?
In 2012 Duarte decided to plant wheat on the 450 acres. He contracted with an equipment operator to prepare the land for planting.

In November 2012 a representative from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers drove past Duarte’s property and saw what he believed were Clean Water Act violations. The representative returned to the property the following month to observe what he believed to be deep ripping.

Duarte suspects the Corps of Engineers representative assumed the equipment operator was deep ripping to prepare to plant trees or vines. However, Duarte says the operator was just plowing the field.

The Army Corps of Engineers would not comment on this particular case, however provided a statement from the EPA on the Clean Water Act litigation.

“The agencies look forward to vigorously defending the merits of the Clean Water Rule, which the agencies continue to believe is fully consistent with the law and based on the best available peer-reviewed science,” the EPA says.
Duarte received a formal cease and desist letter in February 2013 stating he had discharged dredged or fill material into the seasonal wetlands, vernal pools, vernal swales, and other waters without a permit.

Duarte’s attorney sent letter a letter to the U.S. Corps of Engineers requesting the Corps provide copies of all the information it gathered on the farm to back up the claims it was making. He also requested a hearing on the claims.Instead, he received another letter in March 2013 stating the case was transferred to the EPA for enforcement.

Due Process Claim
Duarte then sought help from the Pacific Legal Foundation, a conservative nonprofit, which said the case was a due process case. Duarte filed a due process claim against the U.S. Corps of Engineers.

“The government can’t just tell you to stop farming your land because they thought they saw something without giving you an opportunity to share facts; this is a due process issue,” Duarte said.

Duarte says the U.S. Department of Justice filed a destruction of wetlands countersuit against Duarte Nursey, and against John Duarte. Duarte says they allege that the land was deep-ripped or tilled 36 inches deep or more.

“We filed a counterclaim that the destruction of wetland suit was a retaliatory suit based on our due process claim,” Duarte says. “We simply planted wheat in the dark spots where wheat had been planted before.”

Soil experts from the Department of Justice visited the parcel to examine and measure the land. Duarte says the experts asserted the tillage was 4-7 inches deep and left plow furrows 24 inches apart peak to peak and a gully of 5 inches, and was not deep ripping. Even worse, the department’s employees dug up the vernal pools in question. The Corps of Engineers contends the raised part of these furrows created constitute mini mountain ranges. Duarte jokingly calls them the Sierra Minimas.

“[They said] the bottom of the furrow is still a wetland, but the top of the furrow is now a converted upland,” Duarte says.

Duarte is being prosecuted under the Clean Water Act, however, he says if he was being charged under the new Waters of the U.S. Rule (WOTUS), 95% of the Tehama County property would be considered a wetland.

He also says the exemptions within the Clean Water Act permit farmers to plow in wetlands without a permit and that moving the soil in the act of plowing does not cause a discharge. However, a federal judge said that because the plow lifted the soil a few inches and moved it a few inches to create the furrows, the soil moved is a pollutant and therefore does not fall under the plowing protection. He also says the government claimed sovereign immunity to protect itself and countersue against his first amendment claim.

“There is no protection for farming, and according to this judge there never has been,” Duarte says.

Says He’s Taking It To The Mat
Duarte vows to fight the charges.

“One reason we brought this [suit] is Duarte Nursery is a large tree and vine nursery, we sell trees all over the California and the West Coast, we hear farmer after farmer tell us about these horror stories,” he says. “Nobody wants to stand up. This is not new. The only new aspect is that we’re taking it to the mat and trying to get it cleaned up.”

The lawsuit is not only against Duarte Nursery but also against John Duarte himself. John Duarte’s brother, Jeff, has created a GoFundMe page to help his brother to raise funds to fight it out in the courts. John Duarte estimates he needs about $2 million to help pay the legal fees to fight the case.

“I have a millions of dollar penalty liened against my family because a field agent thought that I was deep ripping 36 inches deep,” John Duarte says.

Duarte says he’s appealing the trial court decisions from the Eastern District of California. However, he says the EPA wants to assess penalties in court before the appeals are decided on so he would be bonded to the judgments before the appeal claims are heard.

“If we lose this case, the prosecution against us for simply farming wetlands that had been farmed before, irrespective of the Clean Water Act’s protection for agriculture, this will allow the Army Corps of Engineers and federal agencies to go door to door and extract the net worth of farmers nationwide,” he says. “We’re fighting for all agriculture nationwide.”

What This Case Means For Growers
Tree fruit and nut growers may be vulnerable to extra scrutiny in light of John Duarte’s case, say American Farm Bureau’s Don Parrish, senior director of regulatory relations, and Danielle Quist, senior counsel for public policy.

“The Corps sees the planting of those types of commodities as something that’s going to deep rip into the ground,” Quist says. “They are so sensitive to the expansion of orchard and nut crops. They’re going to take a look at the land, even if you’re not planting those. If you’re a grower and that’s your general business, they’re going to be out there, looking to see what you’re doing on the land.”

Quist and Parrish say the trouble with this case is it could happen to any grower in the country.

“This isn’t an exemption issue, this is them saying it’s not plowing — it’s something else — sidecasting, moving soil out of a wetland and creating hills inside of a wetland,” Quist says. “You’re not allowed to turn a wetland into an upland, but he didn’t do that. He just created the furrow and ridges that every plow in America does.”

Parrish also wonders how growers will navigate the WOTUS rule in light of these rulings.

“Almost all plowing creates the furrows and ridges that the government now says are mini-mountain ranges,” he says. “How can any farmer plow through a wetland or ephemeral drain (under the new WOTUS rule) if doing so will always create a mini-mountain range?”

Parrish and Quist also say the difficult part of the case is that John Duarte himself, not just Duarte Nursery, is being sued for a violation of the Clean Water Act.
“It’s his own personal finances – not his company – that are on the line,” Quist says. “It’s not a criminal case, but the fact that our government is personally going after farmers makes it harder for farmers to fight back.

They don’t have that corporate shield.”

Above all Parrish and Quist say growers need to come together to bring attention to this issue.

“They can’t be an island. They can’t sit back and say ‘This isn’t going to happen to me,’” Parrish says. “If they sit back and don’t act, they are going to lose more of their property and lose more use of their land. If we’re not working together as farmers and ranchers to push back on the agencies, we’re just going to get steamrolled.”

They also say growers should also not keep silent if they find themselves in trouble with the Corps of Engineers and the EPA. Anthony Francois, senior staff attorney, of the Pacific Legal Foundation agrees.
“If the Army Corps threatens any enforcement action, growers should consult with a knowledgeable Clean Water Act attorney, he says. “They can always submit inquiries to Pacific Legal Foundation.”

Topics: , ,

Leave a Reply

9 comments on “Grower Vows To Fight Clean Water Act Violation Suit

  1. You get what you vote for.. CA keeps voting for “Progressive” Democrats” ( AKA Big Government) and they keep getting kicked in the ass.. It is hard to commiserate with these folks.

    1. Government employees are accountable to no one. They can say and do whatever they wish and have it enforced by the barrel of a gun>

    2. Except Marco that no farmers here in CA vote for these liberal idiots. We are being taken over by the ignorant people in LA and SF. But thanks for your support, sounds like you really care about farming and justice.

  2. Bureaucracies have been allowed to grow and assume the powers of the three branches of government. They bypass Congress in making their own Rules in violation of the Constitution. They enforce their Rules, and they prosecute. This is not what the Founding Fathers had in mind.

  3. John, we’re with you, but Kalipornia is a hell hole, full of wickedness, and seizing your land for Cesar is expected. I fled 4 1/2 years ago to Idaho. I encourage all good folks there to move to another state where you can be proud that your tax dollars are going to a good purpose. Many good people in the U.S. pray that Kali will fall into the ocean and take their wickedness with them to the ocean floor. Here in Idaho, almost everyone loves our farmers and ranchers; we’re grateful. Good luck John.

  4. I feel like I’ve been transported into some parallel universe, a bizzaro world. Would it be asking to much to have government employees take an IQ test before assuming any kind duties?

  5. Does this apply to all land that has been leveled and plowed many years ago, or only virgin soil with actual vernal pools still in tact?

Fruits Stories
Sunset on Florida potato field day
Citrus
July 19, 2017
Researchers On a Mission to Find More Places for Growing Produce
Federal grant to aid exploration of food security solutions for the future. Read More
Citrus
July 19, 2017
Farm Labor Stories Making the News This Week
The agricultural labor shortage is strong enough that the consumer press is beginning to report on it regularly. Here are the stories making headlines this month. Read More
farm hacks collage
Citrus
July 19, 2017
Florida Grower Magazine is Seeking Your Farm Hacks
Life hacks are common in social media threads these days. They are those clever ideas or tricks aimed at making Read More
Fruits
July 14, 2017
Brown Marmorated Stink Bug Predator Egg Mass Found
Samuri wasp parasitized egg mass found in Southern New Jersey peach orchard. Read More
Rain drops on leaf
Citrus
July 14, 2017
Everglades Agricultural Area Farmers Winning at Water Quality
Annual report shows use of best management practices results in another massive reduction in phosphorus flow. Read More
Citrus
July 13, 2017
The Road is Long to Farm Bill 2018 [Opinion]
Participation in this process will be crucial to ensure your needs are understood and addressed. Read More
2015 FFVA Annual Convention crowd
Citrus
July 13, 2017
Trade Talk to Top Florida Fruit & Vegetable Association Convention Agenda
Trade issues are top of mind these days for specialty crop producers. Efforts have been underway since early this year Read More
Beet-armyworms-on-a-tomato-plant
Citrus
July 12, 2017
Tomato Pests Can Be Induced to Cannibalism, New Study Shows
The University of Wisconsin's John Orrock says when beet armyworms are exposed to concentrations of methyl jasmonate, they will abandon eating tomatoes — and start eating one another. Read More
Citrus
July 12, 2017
USDA Pulls 8 Products from Approved Organic Production List
After a few months of speculation, the USDA's Agricultural Marketing Service has published its Sunset 2017 final rule on approved products for organic production and handling. Read More
darkwinged fungus gnat larvae
Fruits
July 12, 2017
How to Deal with Annoying Fungus Gnats on the Farm
Learn how to identify, the survival and spread, as well as management methods for this insect pest. Read More
Carl and Dustin Grooms of Fancy Farms
Business Planning
July 11, 2017
Young Florida Farmers Ready to Take the Reins
As growers age, the next generation is stepping up and stepping into leadership roles on the farm. Read More
Dr. Martha Roberts
Citrus
July 10, 2017
Florida Reveals Its Latest Woman of the Year in Agriculture
2017 award recipient a true trailblazer and champion for the advancement of the state’s farming industry. Read More
Mobile technology farming
Citrus
July 10, 2017
Practical Solutions Are Bringing Precision Agriculture Closer to Earth
Growing the budding ag-tech sector to maturity likely will require a deeper meeting of the minds between technologists and agriculturists. Read More
Online shopping graphic for GenNext Growers webcast
Business Planning
July 10, 2017
Farming for Online Sales Will Require Growers to Reboot
Modern agriculture might not be for everyone, but it’s here to stay. Embrace it. Read More
Fruits
July 9, 2017
USDA Invests $6.8 Million for Pollinator Health
Projects focus on colony losses, pollinator habitats, and increase pollinator populations. Read More
The Latest
Crop Protection
July 23, 2017
USDA Invests $7.6 Million toward Benefic…
Projects to promote beneficial organisms as part of a pest control strategy. Read More
Citrus
July 22, 2017
Representative from Washington Proposes …
Move broadens use of H-2A to all of agriculture to include those with multiple crops and harvests. Read More
Citrus
July 20, 2017
Atlantic Hurricane Forecast Taken Up a N…
Current conditions in the tropics warrant marked revision in potential storm season scenarios. Read More
Citrus
July 19, 2017
Researchers On a Mission to Find More Pl…
Federal grant to aid exploration of food security solutions for the future. Read More
Citrus
July 19, 2017
Farm Labor Stories Making the News This …
The agricultural labor shortage is strong enough that the consumer press is beginning to report on it regularly. Here are the stories making headlines this month. Read More
Citrus
July 19, 2017
Florida Grower Magazine is Seeking Your …
Life hacks are common in social media threads these days. They are those clever ideas or tricks aimed at making Read More
Fruits
July 14, 2017
Brown Marmorated Stink Bug Predator Egg …
Samuri wasp parasitized egg mass found in Southern New Jersey peach orchard. Read More
Citrus
July 14, 2017
Everglades Agricultural Area Farmers Win…
Annual report shows use of best management practices results in another massive reduction in phosphorus flow. Read More
Citrus
July 13, 2017
The Road is Long to Farm Bill 2018 [Opin…
Participation in this process will be crucial to ensure your needs are understood and addressed. Read More
Citrus
July 13, 2017
Trade Talk to Top Florida Fruit & Ve…
Trade issues are top of mind these days for specialty crop producers. Efforts have been underway since early this year Read More
Citrus
July 12, 2017
Tomato Pests Can Be Induced to Cannibali…
The University of Wisconsin's John Orrock says when beet armyworms are exposed to concentrations of methyl jasmonate, they will abandon eating tomatoes — and start eating one another. Read More
Citrus
July 12, 2017
USDA Pulls 8 Products from Approved Orga…
After a few months of speculation, the USDA's Agricultural Marketing Service has published its Sunset 2017 final rule on approved products for organic production and handling. Read More
Fruits
July 12, 2017
How to Deal with Annoying Fungus Gnats o…
Learn how to identify, the survival and spread, as well as management methods for this insect pest. Read More
Business Planning
July 11, 2017
Young Florida Farmers Ready to Take the …
As growers age, the next generation is stepping up and stepping into leadership roles on the farm. Read More
Citrus
July 10, 2017
Florida Reveals Its Latest Woman of the …
2017 award recipient a true trailblazer and champion for the advancement of the state’s farming industry. Read More
Citrus
July 10, 2017
Practical Solutions Are Bringing Precisi…
Growing the budding ag-tech sector to maturity likely will require a deeper meeting of the minds between technologists and agriculturists. Read More
Business Planning
July 10, 2017
Farming for Online Sales Will Require Gr…
Modern agriculture might not be for everyone, but it’s here to stay. Embrace it. Read More
Fruits
July 9, 2017
USDA Invests $6.8 Million for Pollinator…
Projects focus on colony losses, pollinator habitats, and increase pollinator populations. Read More